3 ms·
To the results oriented person, a physics class is not an intellectual exploration of the properties of physics, it is a series of lectures, concepts, exams, an
by grandalf 17y ago
To the results oriented person, a physics class is not an intellectual exploration of the properties of physics, it is a series of lectures, concepts, exams, and a grade.
Someone who focuses too much on the learning/conceptual aspect might be tremendously insightful about some of the concepts, but may omit others because they seem less interesting, etc.
If tested on peak reasoning ability, the "learner" might do far better, yet might do significantly worse academically.
Many people have a mix of both intellect and results orientation, but they are independent characteristics. I've known some relatively non-bright people who are very successful -- they find what works and run with it.
IQ alone is only good for doing well on IQ tests. That doesn't mean it's a useless measure, but it's far more signicant as a measurement of potential than of anything else.
This is why valedictorians get into lots of colleges -- they are proven results getters and have proven that they are able to identify the prize and win it. Someone may be brighter but not care about the prize or be too lazy to do what it takes to win.
- HSO 17y agoYou nailed it. This idea or distinction is certainly not new, anyone who's attended university or even high-school knows this somewhere inside, but this is the best verbalization I've yet seen. Thanks! Now the question is, when is what strategy better?
- mannicken 17y agoBetter for what? Valedictorians will suffer and sweat under an overseer of their own making -- goal from the future. Failed intellectuals will enjoy the immediate fun of solving a complex problem or satisfying their innate curiosity yet rapidly changing priorities as soon they get bored. At what price? I personally enjoy the carpe-diemishly failed intellectual's path; I don't deem myself smart but I do enjoy hacking C++, Ruby and LISP out of pure fun and my college GPA is around 2.4 with several failed classes. I never finished high school due to bureaucratic crap I haven't liked to deal with. I've done drugs too, just out of curiosity. I probably look like a typical failed teenager but I can't look at myself with a pair of eyes other than mine. My friend is a totally different story. Before his freshman year of high school he set a goal -- get a 4.0 GPA and get into a totally awesome university. I watched him -- it was easy since we shared schools -- months and months, digging into assignments, spending nights at the library, working a part-time job and paying an SAT tutor. He was like a bulldog; he grasped the system by the very throat (yet he seemed like a prisoner of his own mind). He got 3.99 GPA and 2200 SAT (up from 1680). He kept focus for four years. I consider myself lucky if I keep focused on something for more than two months. He went to Berkeley. Me? I consistently skipped school, learned stuff on my own, been the typical slacker, failed classes, and somehow picked up programming contracts while in high school. Now he's finishing Berkeley and I'm taking classes in community college, just for intellectual stimulation, working part-time as a C++ programmer and towards my goal: frugal passive income from web-startup that would give me freedom to explore and learn, not being stuck in office (like he might). My friend has prestige, respect and he is very succesful but I wouldn't live his life even for a second. I value the freedom from all that crap too highly :) Different people want different things, I guess. Hope that answered your question.
- azanar 17y agoYou seem to have this implicit conclusion that being results-oriented is the better way to go. You highlight the non-bright people you know who are successful, and declare that they are results-driven. You highlight bright people who aren't successful, at least with the examples of prizes you pick out, and declare that they are not results-driven What about the other permutations? I can see some of the valedictorians doing something that you don't account for in your description, nor really in your description of the dumb but successful: after identifying the prize, they determined if it was a prize worth having at the cost it demanded. They became valedictorians in part because there were many other prizes that they identified, but decided not to pursue. Not every prize is worth winning, and this is where a dumb, but results-driven perspective can get people into trouble. It doesn't matter what they are winning, so long as they have won. This strikes me as just as wrong headed as not caring about results at all.
- grandalf 17y agoI totally agree with you, actually. I was not meaning to make a value judgment. However I think that it would be nice if everyone thought about what they really wanted,... such that they became more self-actualized, not necessarily better able to pursue the various gold stars that society offers.