3 ms·
There's no point in arguing semantics without being clear on the definitions I'm using. I use "politics" to refer to the practice of participating in an organiz
by baddox 13y ago
There's no point in arguing semantics without being clear on the definitions I'm using. I use "politics" to refer to the practice of participating in an organization that governs. By "governs," I mean has the legal authority to exercise physical control over a region or group of people. In the context of modern Western nation-states, I use "politics" to refer only to participation which is condoned by the government. So I consider voting, running for office, helping with election campaigns, lobbying, etc. to be political acts. I don't consider other attempts to influence governments to be inherently political acts, like civil disobedience, participating in black markets, and other forms of counter-economics.
Obviously, in the broadest sense, anarchism is relevant to political philosophy because it is the suggestion that governments and therefore politics shouldn't exist. Analogously, atheism is relevant to religion because it is the suggestion that religion is incorrect. And yet, with the definitions I'm explicitly using, anarchism is not politics and atheism is not religion.
And to be clear, there are certainly anarchists (and, much more commonly, minarchists) who blatantly use political methods to achieve their desired results. A prominent example would be Ron Paul, who is arguably an anarchist, but seems to believe that using the condoned political methods to move the USA toward a smaller and more constitutional government is useful. I disagree with these people.
- mayanksinghal 13y ago> I don't consider other attempts to influence governments to be inherently political acts, like civil disobedience, participating in black markets, and other forms of counter-economics. Then your definition of politics satisfies you assumption of what politics means but that doesn't mean that those acts are not political as understood by many if not most others. By your understanding of politics, only governments and those participating to elect/support them are political entities. Even if we take that definition, whatever system theoretical (or in some parallel universe, practical) society you envision there are going to be small pockets of political governance that sets rules and enforces them. It could be as small as a family or a pack of 15 travelers, or as large as a village. There will be pack leaders who will enforce the minimal rules that you have set up, probably using physical force and there will be rules to avoid physical force unless necessary. There will be clashes between packs, which is just going to be a decentralized version of current international politics and there is going to be protection money taken from the physically weak likes of me, so that I don't get killed in such clashes. I prefer better politics (your definition of politics) than no politics.
- baddox 13y ago> Then your definition of politics satisfies you assumption of what politics means but that doesn't mean that those acts are not political as understood by many if not most others. I believed that it was quite clear from context what I meant by "politics." It should be obvious that I was not talking about all forms of social organization, as in "office politics." I don't believe it's reasonable to believe I meant that all social interaction should be avoided, but when several people claimed to take this interpretation, I was very clear about the definitions I was using. > By your understanding of politics, only governments and those participating to elect/support them are political entities. Yes, that is correct. This is also, to my knowledge, the standard definition of the term outside of obvious casual adaptations of the term like "office politics."
- mayanksinghal 13y ago> the standard definition of the term outside of obvious casual adaptations of the term like "office politics." From my limited reading about the topic, that is not the case. According to wikipedia, politics is the practice and theory of influencing other people on a civic or individual level[1]. I have taken just one, very 101 like course on Governance and the most prominent theories that were discussed used politics in the broader sense (but detailed from a narrower perspective due to the scope of the class). Group theory[2], for instance, calls nearly all interactions between interest groups as political. Elite Theory [3], also used similar connotations. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pluralism_(political_theory) [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory
- baddox 13y agoI previously skimmed the Wikipedia article on politics, and it does mention companies once and "individual level" once. And yet, everything else I can find in the article assumes that the state is the topic of discussion. The same goes for http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_science. I also did a quick Google search for political science curriculums, and everything seems to deal with governments.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoRon Paul is a proprietarian, not an anarchist. http://www.infoshop.org/AnarchistFAQAppendix1 http://www.infoshop.org/AnarchistFAQAppendix1