6 ms·
Here's the really insidious thing about the whole situation, and something that I don't think has gotten enough airtime: We are all at the mercy of the people
by angersock 13y ago
Here's the really insidious thing about the whole situation, and something that I don't think has gotten enough airtime:
We are all at the mercy of the people in our social graphs who don't keep things secret. I might stay off of Facebook, encrypt all my email, and avoid using smart phones, but anybody I'm in contact with who doesn't is being continually mined. Shadow profiles of me are showing up on services I'd never use willingly because my friend shared their address book with Facebook.
We really only have three groups to hold responsible: ourselves (for developing these technologies), our government (for using these technologies to oppress us), and every other citizen (for voting the government into power and playing along when we ask to mine their data).
The core issue we're seeing is that it is no longer really possible to ignore the fact that most consumers are liabilities to our privacy, and that they'll gladly sell out their fellow man for the dullest of shiny trinkets.
Honestly, the most insidious part of all this isn't our loss of privacy or our trust in some beneficial Big Brother: it's the distressing fact that we can't trust anyone else anymore, and that we've shown that democracy is impossible with such an unworthy populace.
Make no mistake--that's the real tragedy here.
- themodelplumber 13y ago> Shadow profiles of me are showing up on services I'd never use willingly because my friend shared their address book with Facebook. Is that really so bad? The worst I've seen is "this is a picture of John" which is not an abuse that's limited to social networks. And if this happens really often, you can complain to your friend about it. And if you can't complain to your friend, you can complain to abuse. And if abuse doesn't do anything (not likely) you can send a legal notice. To jump from "a friend can mention me, talk about me, etc." to "there is no privacy anymore" is...well, I just can't get there, sorry. Do we have privacy problems? Yes. Are these examples really selling that? No. I can't remember any case in which a friend sold me out for a trinket; if you do have a common example, cite it. That would really help us all here.
- jasonkolb 13y agoHow about "I was having an argument with my friend John who is all paranoid about the government spying on him. Maybe he's a closet terrorist." Maybe your friends are more intelligent than average, but I wouldn't lump most of humanity in that category.
- crpatino 13y agoJust assume each one of your friends is a raving moron until you observe evidence that contradicts that fact. Half jokingly, my alibi for getting out of FB was "On moral grounds, I cannot offer my support to a company that was started through borderline fraud and is known to change its privacy-policies/terms-of-use without notice".
- nathancahill 13y agoYou're missing the point. The fact is, even if you decide to not use any online accounts, host your own email, run your own server and VPN, etc. profiles of you are being created of you anyway AS IF you had an account! These are called "shadow profiles".. Facebook is the easiest example because it's already been demonstrated to do this. I'm sure most other online services work similarly. https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-security/important-message-from-facebooks-white-hat-program/10151437074840766 https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-security/important-m...
- ctdonath 13y agoIs that really so bad? The worst I've seen is "this is a picture of John" Yes, it is - when there are a bunch of "this is a picture of John" posts mostly by identifiably pro-1st/2nd/4th/10th Amendment[1] types, facilitated by face recognition software confirming it's the same John, whereby data mining can determine that there is an un-tracked person named John who is most likely a pro-1st/2nd/4th/10th Amendment type and, because of his pointed absence from social media, likely rather hardcore about it and worth tracking with particular interest. Tom Brown (famous tracker) tells a story of his tutor telling him "go to the grandfather tree." He scoured the woods for the curious plant, and found nothing. Standing in a clearing wondering what was meant, he realized that the space he was standing in - an unusually empty space in an otherwise dense forest - must have been created by a very large and very old tree that had subsequently fallen and rotted away, leaving a space other trees had been unable to grow in. Moral: an apparent absence can, coupled with identifiable effects, be indicative of something very interesting; to wit if there's a lot of pictures of someone but nothing from that someone he's probably hiding something. [1] - terms for various passionately-defended civil rights here
- MisterWebz 13y agoIt's really scary that we're at a point where not using social media can reveal something about you. If they somehow manage to get an IP address associated with the shadow profile, they can use XKeyScore to see which websites you've visited. If they see you've been reading a lot of articles about the NSA ordeal, browsing wikipedia a lot, visiting websites related to cryptography and visiting a website called hacker news, they'll target you as 'politically dangerous' and you'll be put in the 'nihilist, anarchist, hasn't talked to the opposite sex in 5 years'-list.
- ctdonath 13y agoIt's the ones that, after such activity, post a final "oh shit" message and promptly fall off the 'net that may very well get special attention.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoYou really think they have a special state-security list for nerds?
- swamp40 13y agoIt's sad to see valid opposing arguments down-voted into grayness.
- AsymetricCom 13y ago>Are these examples really selling that? http://money.cnn.com/2013/01/28/technology/social/facebook-class-action/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2013/01/28/technology/social/facebook-c...
- angersock 13y agoTrello asks for your friend's emails so you can recommend the service, even going so far as to have a friendly little puppy you can 'feed' the emails to. Facebook is well-documented in scraping your address book on your phone if you use their app, and many other games will do the same. I get LinkedIn spam all the time from friends who gave them my email account so I could join. This is really common, least of all because of the push for high viral coefficients in startups. The reason I find it so repugnant is that I want to trust my friends and family, and I want to be able to enjoy my privacy (such as it is). That these companies go out of their way to make it so so easy for my friends to betray that trust is unforgivable.
- stonemetal 13y agoway to make it so so easy for my friends to betray that trust is unforgivable. Did your friends sign some sort of friendship agreement that prohibits them talking about you without your permission?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWell they're his friends, so yes.
- bloaf 13y agoDo you remember this from not so long ago? http://www.digitaltrends.com/social-media/what-exactly-is-a-facebook-shadow-profile/ http://www.digitaltrends.com/social-media/what-exactly-is-a-...
- hyperventilator 13y ago> democracy is impossible with such an unworthy populace Not impossible but imperfect, and it always will be so get used to it.
- gyom 13y agoJacob Appelbaum likes to call this to the attention of people by comparing it to safe sex practices. When you engage someone online, you'd like to know a few things about how that person with handle your personal data. If you know someone to be incapable/unwilling to secure your data (analogous to someone indulging in risky sexual behaviour), then you can refrain from interacting with that person on a deeper level (i.e. don't have sex with them). Pretty hard to do in practice, but if everyone understood this concept it'd be easier to make it work.
- angersock 13y agoA fantastic analogy, but unfortunately it fails to capture the secondary effects of people you know volunteering information that is "yours" by accident or on-purpose.
- ctdonath 13y agoThe difference is that you don't worry about contracting STDs just because the two of you are in the same room.
- forgotAgain 13y agoI think you're trying really hard to find a reason why you aren't responsible for yourself. You're on Facebook because you put yourself on Facebook. If there's a problem why are you still there? The core issue we're seeing is that it is no longer really possible to ignore the fact that most consumers are liabilities to our privacy, and that they'll gladly sell out their fellow man for the dullest of shiny trinkets. I think you have this backward. You can take yourself out of the relationship or you can work towards changes in government. what you're feeling here is the breakdown in society. People think they're fighting alone. They're not. You're not. The biggest fault I'm seeing in discussions is that the blame isn't being placed where it belongs: the government. We have a right to privacy. The US Constitution says we have the right to privacy, It's not something that the government provides or can take away. If they do take it away it is our collective fault. Honestly, the most insidious part of all this isn't our loss of privacy or our trust in some beneficial Big Brother: it's the distressing fact that we can't trust anyone else anymore, and that we've shown that democracy is impossible with such an unworthy populace. That's what being brutalized does to you. It takes away your hope. People without hope can't support a society. If people aren't organized in a society it is much easier for an authoritarian government to take over.
- angersock 13y ago"You're on Facebook because you put yourself on Facebook." We know that that's not true. As for the rest, again, as tempting as it is to blame the evil gubberment for this, the problem at the end of the day is that our own friends and family are ratting us out, because companies make it so goddamn easy and attractive to do so. Look, we've all genuflected at the altar of lean growth and advertising and all the rest, and the price for that is the complete loss of our privacy. You don't get large viral coefficients without targeted advertising and email collection and exploitation--you don't become sticky by being anti-social. This is the naked truth of it, and that's what's so goddamn depressing. The government didn't do this to us by itself, or even mostly itself--it's been done by our friends, families, and founders.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- anigbrowl 13y agoWe really only have three groups to hold responsible: ourselves (for developing these technologies), our government (for using these technologies to oppress us), and every other citizen (for voting the government into power and playing along when we ask to mine their data). Oh nonsense. Technologies like Facebook were developed by people who wanted to make money out of them. On a practical level the huge amount of data held by private industry - over which I have no real control in the US - affects me far more on a day-to-day basis. There are huge information asymmetries between consumers and businesses, and many businesses which depend on exploiting those asymmetries. I've said before that the US needs an explicit Constitutional amendment to create a right to privacy and control over one's data. If I want to know what data the government has on me, I can make an FOIA request - the response may be evasive in the case of some agencies, or redacted, and as such the mechanism is imperfect - but it exists, and is useful enough to be a first resort in many legal cases. Americans in general enjoy no such right with regard to data held by private firms, which they can disclose or not at their whim. democracy is impossible with such an unworthy populace. It has always been like this. IT's a consistent theme of the Federalist Papers that men are not, in fact, angels and need to be governed because they do such a poor job of governing themselves.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoHow is the populace unworthy because they haven't immediately caught up to the tech community - who ourselves have not caught up to the privacy experts - in solving a problem nobody has ever seen before?