7 ms·
The sad thing is that even among the people willing to admit that the majority of the developed world's problems are political, most of them are under the delus
by baddox 13y ago
The sad thing is that even among the people willing to admit that the majority of the developed world's problems are political, most of them are under the delusion that more/better/different politics is the solution.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoSo you're an anarchist? Because if you're going to pretend that anarchy or proprietarianism is somehow not politics, then I've got some news for you.
- pessimizer 13y agoOr a libertarian, pretending that a police state enforcing a total ordering of property and any contract that can be conceived of isn't politics.
- baddox 13y agoNot all libertarians advocate anything resembling a "police state enforcing a total ordering of property and any contract that can be conceived of."
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoI already said "proprietarian". Please use the proper terminology rather than Applause Light words like "libertarian", which imply that "liberty" and "This Specific Ideology" are equivalent.
- pessimizer 13y agoI don't know what proprietarian means, and I tend to call people what they want to be called.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoI wouldn't call any person who advocates an oppressive police state a libertarian.
- baddox 13y agopessimizer's point is that he believes the very institution of property requires something he calls a state. I would disagree, and point to the fact that territorialism in the animal kingdom is an institution of private property without anything most people would call a state.
- baddox 13y agoThere's no point in arguing semantics without being clear on the definitions I'm using. I use "politics" to refer to the practice of participating in an organization that governs. By "governs," I mean has the legal authority to exercise physical control over a region or group of people. In the context of modern Western nation-states, I use "politics" to refer only to participation which is condoned by the government. So I consider voting, running for office, helping with election campaigns, lobbying, etc. to be political acts. I don't consider other attempts to influence governments to be inherently political acts, like civil disobedience, participating in black markets, and other forms of counter-economics. Obviously, in the broadest sense, anarchism is relevant to political philosophy because it is the suggestion that governments and therefore politics shouldn't exist. Analogously, atheism is relevant to religion because it is the suggestion that religion is incorrect. And yet, with the definitions I'm explicitly using, anarchism is not politics and atheism is not religion. And to be clear, there are certainly anarchists (and, much more commonly, minarchists) who blatantly use political methods to achieve their desired results. A prominent example would be Ron Paul, who is arguably an anarchist, but seems to believe that using the condoned political methods to move the USA toward a smaller and more constitutional government is useful. I disagree with these people.
- mayanksinghal 13y ago> I don't consider other attempts to influence governments to be inherently political acts, like civil disobedience, participating in black markets, and other forms of counter-economics. Then your definition of politics satisfies you assumption of what politics means but that doesn't mean that those acts are not political as understood by many if not most others. By your understanding of politics, only governments and those participating to elect/support them are political entities. Even if we take that definition, whatever system theoretical (or in some parallel universe, practical) society you envision there are going to be small pockets of political governance that sets rules and enforces them. It could be as small as a family or a pack of 15 travelers, or as large as a village. There will be pack leaders who will enforce the minimal rules that you have set up, probably using physical force and there will be rules to avoid physical force unless necessary. There will be clashes between packs, which is just going to be a decentralized version of current international politics and there is going to be protection money taken from the physically weak likes of me, so that I don't get killed in such clashes. I prefer better politics (your definition of politics) than no politics.
- yafujifide 13y agoThat's absolutely true. Although I find myself a agreeing with many normal people that government is riddled with problems in practice, they get hostile when I suggest that maybe there shouldn't be an organization with a monopoly on force that is funded by theft.
- igravious 13y agoOk. I'll bite. For argument's sake let's consider me normal. Also for the sake of argument let's assume I will _not_ get hostile ;-) 1) It appears that there is a reduction in violence when one entity (usually the state) achieves a monopoly on law and force. This is because a) individuals when wronged (victims) have an avenue of redress and no longer can take matters into their own hands and perpetuate cycles of violence and b) if an individual trangresses against another's person or property they can be assured of at least some response from a well-resourced state rather than a weak individual. That's the theory anyway but it appears borne out by the stats. I would direct you to read the very excellent Better Angels of Our Natures[1] by Stephen Pinker which changed my thinking on this issue. There's a ton of convincing researched data to back up my position contained within its pages. 2) With 'funded by theft' you of course mean taxation. This is probably where you encounter most hostility. Most people will obviously prefer less taxes (for them) as opposed to more because they'll have more money in their pocket, right? Never mind the fact that barring corruption their taxes go into a common pool to be used for public services and infrastructure and that a higher rate of taxation might improve their lot -- witness the oft touted Scandinavian model. Now to the logical conclusion of this train of thought is, "why not desire zero taxes!" (ie. less and less and less taxes until you reach zero.) You could argue for this. It's quite _another_ thing to argue that taxation is thus theft. That, frankly, makes you sound like an extremist and usually signifies that arguing with you will be a futile experience. Like it or not you live in a society that has public services and infrastructure, money is a consensual public tool -- you gain enormous benefit from this system, you wouldn't even have money to steal if there wasn't the agreement that we'll use this money thing is a exchange mechanism in the first place. I'll be honest, this position exasperates me -- I see it often on HN but rarely respond because what's the point, you won't change your mind. But I'm putting it out there this time, I _strongly_ disagree with your position and I would _not_ like to live in the society you envisage. Over to you :) [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Better-Angels-Our-Nature/dp/0141034645 http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Better-Angels-Our-Nature/dp/0141...
- pnathan 13y agoThe choice to go full anarchist/minarchist is also a political choice. Any sort of (non-)governance/agreement of/with other people is a political choice.
- baddox 13y agoIt's a political choice in the sense that it's the choice to refrain from politics. It's analogous to atheism being the choice to refrain from believing in theism. Anarchism isn't politics, and atheism isn't religion.
- coldtea 13y agoPolitics is how people agree between them (or are forced by others) to go about their lives. You cannot "refrain from politics" anymore that you can "refrain from life" or "refrain from society". As long as you are subject to law, for example, you are participating in politics (as a passive subject at least). Or as long as you need to use any common infrastructure, from roads to water, you are participating in politics. Anarchism itself is very much politics, and has a long history of political involvement that takes 200 volumes to recount, from the International to the Spanish Civil War and on. The only alternative to politics is to go to some cabin in the woods and hunt for your food, but I don't think that's what you have in mind.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- redblacktree 13y agoThat, and you'll still be required to pay property tax.
- baddox 13y ago> Politics is how people agree between them (or are forced by others) to go about their lives. I want to be clear about my definitions to avoid semantic arguments. Sure, in a casual context the word is used that way (e.g. "office politics"). I mean to use the more specific definition, which refers to the organization of government, so I don't refer to all social organization as "politics." For another usage similar to mine, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-politics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-politics.
- scarmig 13y agoPolitics is about how we structure our economic and social order: it's inevitable. What you mean to rail against, I believe, is electoral politics, which is a different beast altogether. And oddly apolitical.
- baddox 13y agoNot exactly. I use the term "politics" to refer to participation in government. I don't consider opposition to governance to be inherently "politics" even though it is obviously relevant to politics, in the same way that I don't consider atheism to be a religion even though atheism is obviously relevant to religion.
- jlgreco 13y agoSort of like how ordering a pizza is not "making dinner", though obviously it is operating in the same space on the same thing (hunger in the evening). The approaches are related through shared objective, but have substantially different methodologies.
- rayiner 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_of_the_Flies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_of_the_Flies
- TeMPOraL 13y agoI agree. Attacking politics directly (i.e. more politics) will do what it always did - that is, nothing. Politics of all kind has two ultimate goals - to keep (and gain more) power and to keep (and gain more) riches. In western democracies this corresponds to being popular (thus maximizing the chance of reelection) and passing laws in favour of those with money, respectively. All the political discussion on top of it seems to be nothing more than something to keep people busy. I think that's why many here think about technological solutions first - they have direct effects and are bullshit free. But as many noted, just technological is not enough. Technology is just a tool. What we need to do is to hit the popularity and the money angle, which means a) PR solutions and b) business solutions. I have a feeling that people want to see only purely technological and political solutions because neither cost that people money personally. It's one thing to run away from Google services; it's another to say to client, "we won't work with you because of your privacy practices". It's hard to notice financial decisions we could make, because they'll hurt us personally in short term. No political change will be introduced by few individuals; that's why we are all encouraged to take action. But I propose that if, instead or along with, we all take the business angle and refuse to give money to people destroying the Internet and our civilization, much more will be achieved. ETA: there's a quote from pg's "The Acceleration of Addictiveness" [0] I particularly like: As knowledge spread about the dangers of smoking, customs changed. In the last 20 years, smoking has been transformed from something that seemed totally normal into a rather seedy habit: from something movie stars did in publicity shots to something small huddles of addicts do outside the doors of office buildings. A lot of the change was due to legislation, of course, but the legislation couldn't have happened if customs hadn't already changed. Note the last sentence. [0] - http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html
- parasubvert 13y agoThat's completely cynical and defeatist, IMO. Politics does achieve positive change. We are witnessing the gradual collapse in support for legal discrimination against gay people. The civil rights revolution did happen. Women did get suffrage. Prohibition was repealed. Many of these things take a lot longer than we seem to be patient for.