3 ms·
"Instead of thinking how different people were in the 1800s, it's much more useful to view mankind as basically the same species that came from the savannah eon
by edw519 17y ago
"Instead of thinking how different people were in the 1800s, it's much more useful to view mankind as basically the same species that came from the savannah eons ago."
Oddly, that's the biggest thing I've noticed when studying the Civil War. Even though our DNA hasn't changed much since then, we certainly have.
Life was so different then, it's hard to imagine. Most of the soldiers had never been more than 20 miles from home before serving. And without much technology, they only know a few dozen people before the war. This was supposed to be a great adventure for many of them. But...
Their sacrifice and suffering are unimaginable today. They marched through mud for days on end, eating only salt pork, hardtack, and coffee. They fought brutally with obsolete technology. The numbers are staggering (by American standards): 1/2 million casualties, Gettysburg 50,000 in 3 days, Antietam, 30,000 in one day.
Every American should visit at least one Civil War battlefield. As I walked down Bloody Lane in Antietam, I imagined the thousands who had died in the same spot, a very sobering experience.
Somehow I can't imagine something like that happening today. I don't think we Americans would put up with that much pain and suffering, for any cause.
We have it pretty good now in our air-conditioned homes with a table full of food and a broadband connection. It's easy to forget that we got that because of the sacrifice of so many others.
Great post, even for hackers, on Memorial Day. Thank you.
- grandalf 17y agoThanks for your big number statistics. Many other countries around the world abolished slavery without going to war. That makes our heroes seem like they were a bit foolish, doesn't it? Let's not get sentimental about it, war is ugly, and the civil war was about "good vs evil" about as much as the Iraq war is.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- anamax 17y ago> Many other countries around the world abolished slavery without going to war. That makes our heroes seem like they were a bit foolish, doesn't it? In other words, they waited until they could abolish slavery without going to war. While waiting was good for not-slaves, it wasn't much good for the folks who were slaves during that time.
- spectre 17y agoThe British Empire beat the US to abolishing slavery by nearly half a century (1807). The British forced many other countries to give up slavery soon after. If the US had lost the revolutionary war or the war of 1812 slavery probably would have been abolished much sooner.
- anamax 17y agoMaybe/probably after the war of 1812 but Britain didn't abolish slavery when it had the US. When it abolished slavery, Britain (proper) didn't have slavery and had lost the only colony with significant slavery, so abolishing slavery throughout the empire didn't cost much. Like I said, the US was willing to go to internal war to abolish slavery. Not many countries were. It's one thing to do good when it doesn't cost much, it's quite another to do said good when it costs a lot.