3 ms·
I thought the anecdote about 1st class trains in London being socially unacceptable was an interesting cultural anecdote. I've ridden Amtrak in the US both ste
by VLM 13y ago
I thought the anecdote about 1st class trains in London being socially unacceptable was an interesting cultural anecdote. I've ridden Amtrak in the US both steerage class and first class and no one thought it was overly interesting or revolutionary. Perhaps because it was like an art deco day dream rather than decorated like an "Edwardian-era New Orleans brothel" per the article. Hmm, that gives me an idea about instituting a "mile long train" club... which would be pretty easy to implement in the 1st class cabins, not so easy for steerage.
One interesting experience WRT 1st class trains is unlike the authors strange ideas about sitting on spikes in a bus, the primary difference between steerage and 1st class on Amtrak trains was privacy. My own bathroom, my own closed cabin, etc. Same food as everyone else (although it was "free" with the ticket price). Same view out the window, we didn't get there any sooner than anyone else...
Oh and the 1st class only lounge in the Chicago station has to be seen to be believed. That alone might be worth the ticket price. Even impatient me, in luxurious enough surroundings, didn't mind waiting an extra hour or so. Its not like any airport waiting room I've ever seen.
- plorkyeran 13y agoAmtrak's more similar to planes than the London Underground, though, since it falls into the category of long-distance transportation rather than daily travel. Why first-class is acceptable for the former but not the latter is an interesting question, though.
- mason55 13y ago> I thought the anecdote about 1st class trains in London being socially unacceptable was an interesting cultural anecdote. I've ridden Amtrak in the US both steerage class and first class and no one thought it was overly interesting or revolutionary People view long distance travel differently than their daily commute when it comes to economic segregation. I imagine there would be an uproar in NYC if the MTA talked about a plan to create a first class car on the subway however no one bats an eyelash about Amtrak. However, I bet you could find a price point where people wouldn't complain if you added a first class car to the London Underground or NYC subway system. I think there's a psychological effect in play where if it's a price that you could pay if you cut into your budget then it stings but if it's a price that seems ludicrous to you then you don't mind as much. I personally would feel more ok with a first class car if it was $100/trip vs. $10 (regular ride is $2.25).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- AlisdairSH 13y agoFunny, I feel the opposite. $100/trip for a subway ride? Preposterous, and the economic system is somehow broken that such an income disparity exists. $10/trip? Eh, if I cut out the Starbucks latte, I could do that. But, I really prefer flavor coffee to sumptuous subway seating. I guess I'm really a socialist at heart.
- VLM 13y agoAs a thought experiment, assuming the transit system was a non-corrupt non-profit, a rich dude paying $100 for a ticket means a heck of a lot of poor people will continue to pay $2.25 today instead of having to pay $2.50. Or insert similar argument. Maybe instead it would mean some employee gets health insurance this month, etc. In the real world of course, corruption would eat all $100 and then the poor would be stuck paying $2.75 once budgets get used to $100 tickets from rich dudes.
- lucaspiller 13y agoPretty much all long distance trains going through London have first class sections. Most commuter trains (the Underground included) don't though, but I guess it is more because they are crammed enough as it is, not because people wouldn't pay. However, the metro in Dubai has both a woman's section and a gold class section (it's the same as normal, but you need to pay more), so it can work in places.
- notahacker 13y ago1st class trains are actually pretty common on medium-distance train services into London (in contrast with the author's examples, first class on British trains is often barely distinguishable in terms of comfort from standard class to the point where you wonder why anyone would bother to pay for it) 1st class trains on the London Underground would be hugely unpopular because deliberately running overcrowded services below maximum capacity to skim a bit more money off the top is seldom popular, especially when no commuter is naive enough to believe they'll be compensated for the extra wait and crush with reduced fares.