4 ms·
Why The American Civil War Is Important
- lucumo 17y agoWell, more like: Why the American Civil War is Important ... to Americans.
- access_denied 17y agoDefault setting is <America>, no qualifier needed. Also, <America> == <U.S.>, please learn to live in Ascii ;-)
- tokenadult 17y ago"When it was over, it was over" This is important and astonishing to people from other countries. I was an interpreter for some official visitors from China some years ago, and we took a day trip out from Washington, DC to a very near place in Virginia (Alexandria, if I remember correctly) where United States Highway 1 has a monument right in the middle of the highway to Robert E. Lee. And the monument, significantly, has Lee with his back turned to DC and facing the state of Virginia. My Chinese companions were AMAZED that such a monument would be allowed so near to the national capital. The United States allows a lot of expressions of dissent, so even actual civil wars can calm down over time so that people can get along. The contrasting situation in many other countries, where wars from hundreds of years ago are still the basis for grudges today, is a large part of what makes those countries less stable and less prosperous.
- handelaar 17y ago"When it was over, it was over" ...is also far from correct. The US political system subsequently basically mirrored the conflict, and it continued until both major political parties underwent profound changes in the 1970s. In much the same way (but more pronounced) Ireland had a civil war in 1922-23 and the two largest political parties today are the two opposing sides of that war. They really don't differ on any substantive matters of policy but each party loathes the other. Ring any bells?
- grandalf 17y agoExactly right. The themes of the civil war are still being fought out in the courts today.
- dkarl 17y agoThe difference between war and politics is trivial from certain theoretical points of view but very important to real people who have to live through one or the other. Besides, even the hatred between Democrats and Republicans is tame by most standards. Democrats and Republicans normally engage in fair, peaceful commerce with each other, and a Democrat plaintiff arguing in front of a Republican judge isn't doomed to lose -- in fact, the judge will not consider it essential to figure out the plaintiff's politics if the case has no personal political implications for himself. James Carville and Mary Matalin is just a cute story, not a shocking breach of loyalty. Hell, go on Match.com and see how many people describe themselves as "very conservative" or "very liberal" but are willing to meet someone from the other end of the spectrum. Street brawls? Violence? The most-publicized violence from the last election was imaginary -- the loony McCain worker who carved a "B" in her face and claimed an Obama supporter did it. Hutus and Tutsis it ain't, nor Northern Ireland or the Balkans. The biggest problems people have with partisanship in the United States is that it's embarrassingly stupid and it probably results in a lot of bad policy. Maybe it's inferior to multi-party coalition politics, or maybe it isn't, but the difference between two styles of peaceful democratic government is bupkus compared to the difference between peace and violence.
- joeyo 17y ago> "When it was over, it was over" > > ...is also far from correct Political grudges are one thing. But I think we were extremely fortunate that the American Civil war did not devolve into a protracted guerrilla war. I have always heard that Lee's leadership was a major factor that prevented that from happening.
- qw 17y ago"The contrasting situation in many other countries, where wars from hundreds of years ago are still the basis for grudges today" I don't think they can be compared. The U.S. was a very young country and the differences between the states were relatively small (mostly white christians from Europe, speaking the same language). In other countries, you can have two completely separate ethnic groups that look different, have separate languages and completely different religions. If you combine this with a history of territorial wars where one side has dominated the other, it's hard to let the war be over. In contrast, there was not much difference between the U.S. states. And when the war ended, all states could share the power in a democratic system.
- edw519 17y ago"Instead of thinking how different people were in the 1800s, it's much more useful to view mankind as basically the same species that came from the savannah eons ago." Oddly, that's the biggest thing I've noticed when studying the Civil War. Even though our DNA hasn't changed much since then, we certainly have. Life was so different then, it's hard to imagine. Most of the soldiers had never been more than 20 miles from home before serving. And without much technology, they only know a few dozen people before the war. This was supposed to be a great adventure for many of them. But... Their sacrifice and suffering are unimaginable today. They marched through mud for days on end, eating only salt pork, hardtack, and coffee. They fought brutally with obsolete technology. The numbers are staggering (by American standards): 1/2 million casualties, Gettysburg 50,000 in 3 days, Antietam, 30,000 in one day. Every American should visit at least one Civil War battlefield. As I walked down Bloody Lane in Antietam, I imagined the thousands who had died in the same spot, a very sobering experience. Somehow I can't imagine something like that happening today. I don't think we Americans would put up with that much pain and suffering, for any cause. We have it pretty good now in our air-conditioned homes with a table full of food and a broadband connection. It's easy to forget that we got that because of the sacrifice of so many others. Great post, even for hackers, on Memorial Day. Thank you.
- grandalf 17y agoThanks for your big number statistics. Many other countries around the world abolished slavery without going to war. That makes our heroes seem like they were a bit foolish, doesn't it? Let's not get sentimental about it, war is ugly, and the civil war was about "good vs evil" about as much as the Iraq war is.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- anamax 17y ago> Many other countries around the world abolished slavery without going to war. That makes our heroes seem like they were a bit foolish, doesn't it? In other words, they waited until they could abolish slavery without going to war. While waiting was good for not-slaves, it wasn't much good for the folks who were slaves during that time.
- grandalf 17y agoHere's a question for everyone to help exercise the critical thinking muscles: What makes you think that the civil war was any more about slavery than the Iraq war was about freedom? ... pause ... I'd argue that any political group waging war is well served by ideological window dressing that they can adopt so that the war can be sold as something other than humanity acting at its worst or the crude law of the jungle being realized. Meanwhile, the soldiers are systematically trained to stop thinking of the enemy as human beings. Occasionally there are incidents of extreme atrocity (massive rapes, massacres), which are not isolated incidents, they are simply a consequence of the standard training that arise under certain types of emotional duress. The idea of these broken people being heroes is absurd. They are at best pawns and at worst monsters. So if you are AT ALL skeptical of Bush's propaganda about the Iraq war, why are you not the least bit skeptical of the standard American propaganda about the civil war? Why do you think the Iraq war was about oil but the civil war was a grand ideological struggle of good vs evildoers?
- calambrac 17y agoThe idea that the Civil War was fought to free the slaves is dispensed with pretty early on - if not in middle school, then at least by high school, and in the worst case by freshman history in college. Thanks, though, that was dramatic.
- grandalf 17y agoOk, well what about the idea that WWII was fought to save the Jews from Hitler? You may have learned these things, but if you ask people to name a "just" war that the US has been in, those are the examples that come up. Even Obama makes frequent reference both to Lincoln and to modern European history in his rhetoric.
- calambrac 17y agoUm, what about it? That one's also taken care of pretty early in the curriculum (actually, I've never really heard that one). Are you just casting around to find something you can call someone stupid for thinking?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- swombat 17y agoWhy is it important to non-americans?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI think that's a great question. Quite honestly, my post should have been "Why the Civil War is Important to Me" The lessons about democracies under duress, the nature of war, effective management styles for large organizations, and history are applicable anywhere. In fact, I'd like to see somebody pick up Lee's management style and turn it into a business leadership book. There are lots of good analogies here. So yes, it's applicable, but the article is not slanted at an international audience, unfortunately.
- edw519 17y agohttp://www.amazon.com/Robert-Lee-Leadership-Executive-Character/dp/0761525548/ref=sr_1_6?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1243189112&sr=8-6 http://www.amazon.com/Robert-Lee-Leadership-Executive-Charac...
- aswanson 17y agoI wonder...do any of our compatriots in the UK or any other part of the world for that matter hold old wars and battles in reverence? Are there reenactors of prior battles and such in your parts of the world? I am partial to believing this is more of an American cultural phenomena.
- mblakele 17y agoIt's part of being human, I think. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reenactment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reenactment and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_reenactment_groups http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_reenactment_...
- queensnake 17y agoOh no. You've heard of the Protestant marches in Ireland commemorating some battle, that used to stir up trouble. Also, I was in Lexington MA on some round-number anniversary of the Revolutionary War, and re-enactors of the British side came over from Britain. All that way, to be on the losing side! Thanks guys.
- TriinT 17y agoQuoting Richard Feynman: "From a very long view of the history of mankind - seen from, say, ten thousand years from now - there can be little doubt that the most significant event of the 19th century will be judged as Maxwell's discovery of the laws of electrodynamics. The American Civil War will fade into provincial insignificance in comparison with this important scientific event of the same decade."
- edw519 17y agoProviding mankind is still around ten thousand years from now. Not a given thanks to another significant event of the 19th century: the discovery of how to harvest, refine, distribute, and use oil as an economic product.
- TriinT 17y agoWhy would mankind be at risk because of oil? Mankind may be at risk because of nuclear weapons, sure, but oil? When oil is over we may have to start riding horses again, but I don't see that as such a huge catastrophe.
- jibiki 17y agoI suspect that he is referring to the dreaded AGW (I have no idea whether burning oil contributes more to carbon levels than deforestation or burning coal. In the long run, I think coal reserves contain similar carbon mass to oil reserves, but it always seems like the data is changing.)
- TriinT 17y agoBut isn't oil carbon neutral? ;-) It's widely accepted that oil has a biological origin (some people dispute that). The carbon absorbed by plants millions of years ago had to come from somewhere, and that is the CO2 in the atmosphere. If oil is derived from those plants, then burning oil simply releases the CO2 that was sequestered underground for millions of years. If there was life before, I think there will be life despite AGW. The number of humans may drop dramatically, of course.
- ckinnan 17y ago"If you want to see American democracy under great stress, the Civil War is the prime example." Yet the author misses the best example-- that in the middle of the war, in 1864, the U.S. held an election for President, even though it looked (in the beginning of the race) that Lincoln might lose!
- javert 17y ago"This was the first time any nation held a national election in the midst of a civil war." -from Wikipedia.