4 ms·
What a joke. Please educate yourself about the history of successful social movements like labor rights, civil rights, environmental protection, etc. The priva
by snowwrestler 13y ago
What a joke. Please educate yourself about the history of successful social movements like labor rights, civil rights, environmental protection, etc.
The privacy movement has not even begun to begin what is necessary to change the law. For example: can you name the leading organization that works solely on privacy? There isn't one. The issue is only sort-of covered if you add up the partial work of a bunch of different orgs, like the EFF, ACLU, NRA, Emily's List, etc.
So: want to move the needle? Start an organization, raise many millions of dollars, collect thousands of contacts, and then run a big scary public and grassroots campaign. Give money to privacy-friendly politicians, and spend independent money to defeat opponents of privacy. Recruit privacy-friendly folks to run for local, state, or federal office. Take meetings with corporate, regulatory, and congressional staff to find folks who are sympathetic to the cause. Run privacy conferences. Pay people to write privacy blogs. Pick a nasty law and create a test case to get it into litigation. Etc, etc.
Now you might say "we shouldn't have to do that." And you're right. But: life isn't fair. Black people should not have had to risk lynchings in order to vote, but they did--and they did it. And they fought it.
- clebio 13y agogood suggestions (I'd add HRW), but you could leave the disrespectful attitude aside. Instead of your first paragraph, maybe mention the publications of the Albert Enstein Institute (http://www.aeinstein.org/ http://www.aeinstein.org/).
- lazyjones 13y agoI don't see the necessity to play exactly the same game our political establishment is playing (raising millions, spin-doctoring, bribery) in order to beat the system from within. It may be one way to do it, but it's costly and seems extremely inefficient. Hopefully there are other ways to achieve something. Frankly, I am unsure about your intentions for writing the above post. You insinuate that organizations like the EFF are not suitable to fight the fight for privacy. You make this look like a gargantuan effort to even get started. Are you trying to discourage people or have you just given up?
- snowwrestler 13y agoMy point is that it is, objectively, a gargantuan, costly, and difficult effort to make a significant change to U.S. federal law. Wishing it was easier does not make it so. My disrepectful tone was not nice and I apologize for that. I just get so frustrated when I see people who seem unwilling to face that reality. Your comment above read to me like a hopeful programmer saying "I've read a few books and done some coding exercises but none of that seemed to create the next Google." (And yes, I am saying it is that hard to make big changes in the law.)
- ataggart 13y ago>Please educate yourself about the history of successful social movements like labor rights, civil rights, environmental protection, etc. Given that the current context involves opposing government power, I'm not sure labour rights and environmental protection are relevant examples; both resulted in massive expansion of the effective scope government power. Civil rights would perhaps be a slightly better example simply because what was being fought against were largely government creations (e.g., legally compulsory discrimination). And even then the civil rights movement had a visible violent side[1]. [1] http://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/1ds5fa/a_march_on_washington_with_loaded_rifles/c9tg5ax http://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/1ds5fa/a_march_...
- pdonis 13y agoCivil rights would perhaps be a slightly better example simply because what was being fought against were largely government creations (e.g., legally compulsory discrimination). And the "solution" was to exchange these for other government creations, like the EEOC. Which on net resulted in a massive expansion of the effective scope of government power (not least because many of the previous government creations were at the state level, but what we have now is mostly federal).