3 ms·
I don't know if Medium cares that much about their own content discovery/cliquing/etc. Sure, the content has to be accessible from the site in some fashion so w
by derefr 13y ago
I don't know if Medium cares that much about their own content discovery/cliquing/etc. Sure, the content has to be accessible from the site in some fashion so web spiders can reach it--but really, as far as I can tell, Medium blogs seem built for the generation of standalone post pages that get shared via their authors self-promoting them on their Twitter feeds and Facebook pages, and then other people putting them up on social bookmarking websites like Reddit and HN. (Or at least, anecdotally, that's where I've found all the Medium articles I've ever read.)
You don't really visit someone's Medium blog. I've never seen anyone say, on their profile somewhere else, "here's a direct link to my blog; it's on Medium." It looks the same as every other Medium blog, after all; that's a strong disincentive to people promoting links their blog root, since they can't brand it--and I think that's intentional on Medium's part.
Instead, you just find someone's Medium posts shared in your feed on some sharing service, because someone you know linked to them. Which is really what the web has needed for a while, I think: a nice, clean, "here is a long standalone essay" hosting service which is ancillary to your more usual blogging, which occurs on FB/G+/Twitter/Tumblr/etc.
A geeky comparison, that might explain their value proposition, as I see it: FB/G+/Twitter/Tumblr/etc. are like a VM stack: you want to only hold tiny little objects on it, because reading those objects (scrolling past them) takes time and "processing cycles" for the reader. You don't want to pass huge ones around, because they'll take up a lot of space everywhere they go, and you have to copy them piece by piece (there have been novels written over Twitter, but they're a bitch to read or quote or export, etc.)
Medium, then, is a VM heap to stick large objects on, and then pass them by reference on the stack (FB/G+/Twitter/Tumblr/etc.) In effect, it's a pastebin with really nice styling, feed generation, and collaborative editorial features, not a "blogging service" per se. Make sense?
- mathattack 13y agoI agree with you. Medium isn't trying to be the next blogspot. It's not all things for all people. Medium is a place to read recommended essays. Having a group of more influential writers emerge who happen to read and recommend each other more doesn't kill this. I think the analogy is Time magazine versus Foreign Policy. I may subscribe to Time and read every issue cover to cover on the subway to get a broad view on what's going on. I'll only buy Foreign Policy from the newspaper stand if there's a long article that specifically interests me. In that case I'll look it over and give it a deeper read. My recommendation system for what to read in Medium isn't Medium. It's HN.
- derefr 13y ago> My recommendation system for what to read in Medium isn't Medium. It's HN. Exactly. I would suggest Medium run with this idea, actually: detect your referrer, then wire a single "like this" button to that service's equivalent of an upvote, and "comment on this" to that service's equivalent of either a reblog/retweet mechanism, or a comments page. Don't try to keep users on Medium, in other words; instead, make Medium a seamless part of whatever site they were already using.
- mathattack 13y agoThat may be a tough thing for them to monetize. Generally websites do better owning the customer experience and then farming the users out for content after they're already engaged. (Think Facebook) But I concur - being the recipient of the referral does seem to be the way for Medium to go. They're run by people who understand social media and viral behavior, so I do believe they have a master plan of some kind.
- taude 13y agoYeup, I don't go to Medium, except when articles are posted here, or the couple other sites I visit where I let either editorial or community selected content drift up into my consciousness. I will add that a lot of the stuff on Medium seems pretty 'self aggrandizing' (not the best word I'm looking for, but the gist is close enough). I'm not sure why it feels that way compared to people's blogs that they maintain themselves....maybe it's the whole 'OMG, I got a Medium account, I'm going to promote the @!#%$ out of myself." Anyway, that's sort of the stigma I give to content on Medium when I click through to read something there...
- smacktoward 13y ago> I've never seen anyone say, on their profile somewhere else, "here's a direct link to my blog; it's on Medium." There is at least one example of this that I'm aware of: defense writer David Axe and his "War Is Boring" blog. http://www.warisboring.com/2013/06/04/war-is-boring-is-moving/ http://www.warisboring.com/2013/06/04/war-is-boring-is-movin...