3 ms·
Adam Smith might have been right about his era, but his reasoning does not apply in our era. It is illegal for employers to collude to lower wages, while union
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Adam Smith might have been right about his era, but his reasoning does not apply in our era.
It is illegal for employers to collude to lower wages, while unions gain legal privileges by doing so. Parliament and congress tend to be bought and paid for by unions. Similarly, due to a combination of high wages and welfare, most workmen can subsist for long periods without work.
(Most workers don't value stability, and choose consumption over savings. But this doesn't mean they lack the ability, they merely don't value it.)
- antihero 13y agoIn the UK, unions have been utterly castrated by the Thatcher government. > Similarly, due to a combination of high wages and welfare, most workmen can subsist for long periods without work. Nope, most workers here are living paycheck to paycheck. > (Most workers don't value stability, and choose consumption over savings. But this doesn't mean they lack the ability, they merely don't value it.) Savings? You must be joking. Let's see. Minimal level of enjoyment, a roof over one's head, food, heating, savings. Choose three, depending how skilled you are, for many, choose two.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIn the US, we have a GDP/capita of $50k/year. In the UK, it's just under $36k/year. In Poland it's $21k/year. If it's impossible for a Brit to save, since they must consume everything they earn to survive with a minimal level of enjoyment, then how do the Polish avoid death? Do the Polish simply not enjoy life at all? And surely you'd agree that Americans should be able to save, simply by reducing their consumption to British levels.
- ahh 13y agoWell, first, GDP/capita isn't a great measure for how the average (low quartile?) worker is doing. I'd think you'd have to look at actual wage levels. Second, cost of living is different in the UK, US, and Poland. If we ignore wage levels and just look at GDP/c, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity#OECD_comparative_price_levels http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity#OECD_co... tells us that after adjusting for costs, the effective numbers as compared to a US citizen's purchasing power are $50K US, $32K UK, $35K Poland. Mind you, I don't know I buy antihero's argument that the British are struggling to stay alive, but your argument isn't a particularly strong counter.
- antihero 13y agoHave you heard of cost of living?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe numbers I gave are adjusted for PPP, though using the world bank method rather than the OECD method given by ahh in his reply. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)...
- dredmorbius 13y agoAdam Smith might have been right about his era, but his reasoning does not apply in our era. I disagree profoundly. Much of the world still operates under conditions Smith would recognize quite readily. Even industrialized nations still have a fundamental set of circumstances as described by Smith which benefits employers. It is illegal for employers to collude to lower wages, while unions gain legal privileges by doing so. It isn't illegal to collude everywhere, and even where it is, this doesn't stop the practice. To put this in terms HN readers might appreciate, most of the major employers in Silicon Valley have been convicted or strongly implicated in anti-poaching hiring practices (another reason recruiting is as big a mess as it is): http://www.siliconvalley.com/companies/ci_22962030/apple-google-intel-likely-conspired-not-poach-workers http://www.siliconvalley.com/companies/ci_22962030/apple-goo... As I've noted: IT is a very largely non-unionized industry sector. For recent unionization rates by industry sector, this BLS 2007 report notes that even in the government rates are below 50%: 35% public sector, < 25% transporation and utilities, 15% construction, 12% information, 11% manufacturing. Most recent growth has been in service industries (housecleaning, janitor, etc.). http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2008/feb/wk2/art01.htm http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2008/feb/wk2/art01.htm Parliament and congress tend to be bought and paid for by unions. Campaign donations from corporations ($25.2m), trade associations ($15m), and individuals and organizations ($16m) all dwarf labor ($7.6m): http://www.project.org/info.php?recordID=28 http://www.project.org/info.php?recordID=28 While the largest _single_ donor sources are frequently labor organizations, these represent a large number of individuals across a large number of employers. Single corporate and PAC donors aren't far behind. Looking at recipients of contributions, the top Democrat and Republican in the US House of Representatives, it's individual contributions which make the lion's share of contributions in both cases: https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list.php https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list.php http://www.campaignmoney.com/political/campaigns/edward-j-markey.asp?cycle=14 http://www.campaignmoney.com/political/campaigns/edward-j-ma... http://www.campaignmoney.com/political/campaigns/john_a_boehner.asp?cycle=14 http://www.campaignmoney.com/political/campaigns/john_a_boeh... The remainder of your assertions without any backing data I simply dismiss as non-credible in light of reports that half of Americans have less than $800 in savings (less than a month's expenses in most cases), and less than $25k in retirement funds. http://blog.credit.com/2013/06/half-of-americans-have-less-than-800-in-savings/ http://blog.credit.com/2013/06/half-of-americans-have-less-t... http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/2013/0319/Most-Americans-retirement-savings-under-25-000 http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/2013/0319/Most-Americans-r... Nice counter-factual troll.