4 ms·
I have said this on HN several times, and I will say this again. Dragnet surveillance of private digital correspondence by the US and other governments is wrong
by pron 13y ago
I have said this on HN several times, and I will say this again. Dragnet surveillance of private digital correspondence by the US and other governments is wrong, and a gross, unjustified, overreaction to the real threat of terrorism.
And yet, when taken as part of the whole picture that is the internet, government surveillance is little more than a drop in the ocean. While governments may collect a possibly significant amount of correspondence and analyze some of it, almost all online data, e-mail correspondence as well as photos and documents, search history, browsing history, our physical location, the driving, running and cycling routes we take, the busses we use and more, is constantly collected, analyzed monitored and used, all day every day, by private corporations. These corporations are even less subject to oversight than any democratically elected institution, and their employees are less carefully screened.
Government surveillance is wrong, but at least it raises an outrage that, in time, is almost certain to bring about change. Corporate surveillance is a more dangerous beast. It employs manipulation and deceit rather than plain-old secrecy, and worst of all – it causes little outrage.
Some have compared the current state of things to George Orwell's Big Brother government, but those who've read the book know that Big Brother does not rule through secrecy and intimidation. Big Brother is never mistrusted, never hated, and never feared or suspected. People subject themselves to his control willingly. Big Brother is loved. That is how absolute power is gained. And that is why a democratic institution has little hope of ever attaining Big Brother status, especially in America where any government is automatically suspect. The real danger to our privacy and our freedom, the true potential Big Brother and the danger that dwarfs any government surveillance online, is Google, Facebook and their ilk.
- route66 13y ago> ... Google, Facebook and their ilk ... usually don't destroy hard drives of journalists or don't detain people as a matter of harrassment just to name two recent actions undertaken by governments who use their introspective powers to take conclusions ("we have to have this Miranda guy") and act upon them ("we know he's in Berlin. Check the flight records") The point is that the control of the governments does not seem to work anymore OR, at the same time addressing that "Big Brother is loved": nobody cares, because governmental agencies do the right thing. (That is my impression until now, living in Europe)
- pron 13y ago> ... usually don't destroy hard drives of journalists or don't detain people as a matter of harrassment I actually remember a similar action taken by Apple (though through the use of a government agency). But bear in mind that corporations' rights to employ violence have been taken from them, but only after they'd been put to good use. They had a long history of terrorizing and killing people (in the US it was during the days of the Pinkertons), and Google is already more powerful today than the robber barons ever were. If government is weakened enough, corporations will gladly fill the void.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoA purely quantitative comparison between governments and corporations is completely pointless. Governments have a monopoly on the use of force, on law making and on many other things that we all depend on. Governments have much greater powers than any particular corporation, and hence the abuse of that power is a lot more dangerous.
- pron 13y ago> Governments have a monopoly on the use of force... They do now, but that was not always the case: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_Government_Services http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_Government_Services > ... on law making How elected representatives vote is public record. How corporations and lobbyists sway them, however, is not. > Governments have much greater powers than any particular corporation Yes, but unfortunately this may be changing. I don't think any government in the history of mankind has ever had as much information about people as Google does.
- TWAndrews 13y agoCorporations can't put me in jail.
- BudVVeezer 13y agoNot directly, but who do you think runs the jails and lobbies for stricter laws to fill those jails?
- vdaniuk 13y ago"Corporations" are not a single entity. Some are more aligned with the development of society, some hinder it. It is harmful to lump all corporations in one group.
- aclevernickname 13y agoTitle 28 of United States Code, Section 3002, subsection 15 (A) states that United States is a Federal Corporation [1] So yes, corporations can indeed put you in jail. [1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/3002 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/3002
- jcromartie 13y agoPeople must understand that every interaction with an Internet service means voluntarily sending your data to them. These companies don't just "vacuum it up", the data is simply sent directly to them. Maybe you don't see it that way, but that is why the perception needs to change. When you use Gmail you are sending your mail to Google, first, and then it is relayed to the recipients. When you search for driving directions to an address, you are sending data to Google that says "I want to know how to drive/cycle/walk to X location right now". When you search for some phrase you are sending a request to Google that says "I want to know about this". There is no reason why they wouldn't hold onto that data. You sent it to them, because you want the response that they can provide. It's an exchange.
- nullc 13y ago> People your you you you your you you you they You them you they People who do not understand technology to the depth and detail that you do are not halfwits or children. They know what they intend to accomplish and giving up their most personal information for perpetual archival is seldom a property they are asking for. If the technological tools they possess do not faithfully obey their intentions with a minimum of unintended side effects then the problem is with the technology or the services not the user. Technology is neat and important, but it exists to serve the user. Faithfulness to the users needs and intentions are the only criteria by which we can judge technology.
- jcromartie 13y agoPutting users' needs first is a great ideal, but ultimately any exchange with a company in a private market context is an economic one. I don't think anybody is an idiot just because they don't understand this. They've come to see Internet services as something like public utilities. There is very little to reinforce the idea that you are indeed giving the provider something for the service, since what you are giving is invisible/intangible.