3 ms·
That's nice to say. Get angry, be outraged. But what do we do, day-to-day, while things are still a mess? How do you organize a revolution under the noses of th
by derefr 13y ago
That's nice to say. Get angry, be outraged. But what do we do, day-to-day, while things are still a mess? How do you organize a revolution under the noses of the people you're revolting against?
The code still has a purpose, even if it's not the "right" solution, long-term.
- arkitaip 13y agoIt really comes down to lobbying lots and lots of politicians who can stop the NSA by significantly slashing its funding or by enforcing existing laws. The Occupy movement showed that revolutions don't work in a state where government and police will conspire against its citizens by infiltrating and undermining its civil rights movements.
- einhverfr 13y agoThe problem with Occupy was that there was no demanded reforms, only complaints and protests against things. Protests aren't ever enough though. It is telling how little credibility Occupy had with Washington when Obama, giving his jobs speech during the protests, called for the deregulation of Wall St.
- pdkl95 13y agoWhile Occupy DID make some demands; they were just made by the individual groups. It would be more correct, though, to say that "demands" weren't really the point of Occupy. They changed the national dialogue, and made a LOT of traditional euphamisms and arguments obsolete and useless by putting the core issue of class warfare back up in front where it belongs. "Cutting out decades of distraction an propaganda" may not have been an explicit "goal", but it was certainly a victory for the movement.
- einhverfr 13y agoRevolution is not what you think. It consists of the small actions of millions of people. The small actions are usually more revolutionary than the large. The NSA has just created a huge market for guaranteed secure communications infrastructures. The technology is there. It may need some extensions but it is there. Some ideas (again no time for a startup now and this is too important): 1. An email-like service based on TOR with content encrypted via public key encryption end to end. 2. The second is an encrypted voice network. This can't encrypt metadata a swell in a way that central offices can't see it, but the contents could be encrypted easily enough. The code is a means to an end. We can't code our way out of the problem. We can build businesses that get us out and code is supportive of that.
- perlpimp 13y agoEncoding your own mail means that you are playing by rules of the game NSA has set up. The only way is to make your own game and make them play by YOUR rules. If you encode your communications there is a barrier that they will break down directly by making you disclose the keys while threatening with Tax audits, jail time etc. Or by breaking down encryption commications. They are the largest employer of IT/Security/Cryptographers on the face of the earth. So the only way to do this is to make them not play their game. Frankly whole cancerous security apparatus has been fueled by privatized sector just like the one with privatized jail system. Sad to say this but there only way I can see this being resolved is political/etc. Start websites cover the stories. Find methods of figuring out whether they are listening to you or not. For example set up fake drug deals so you can draw them on fact of monitoring your communications. Sue them every instance you find them breaking down your doors. Yeah I know it is not pleasant. Just like OP said there is no easy way out of this. Also make working for contractors of NSA and being employee of NSA being a very unpatriotic and scummy thing to do - akin to digging around underwear drawer of your next door granny neighbor. My 2c.
- einhverfr 13y ago> Encoding your own mail means that you are playing by rules of the game NSA has set up. well, actually, I was talking about encoding other people's email, for a fee. The goal is to change the game and change the rules. The NSA has created this market. Let's use this to reshape the game. > If you encode your communications there is a barrier that they will break down directly by making you disclose the keys while threatening with Tax audits, jail time etc. This is true, so the game is not just to get your own keys taken care of but everyone else's and locate the business in a country that will be better interested and able to stand up to NSA interests here. > Or by breaking down encryption commications. They are the largest employer of IT/Security/Cryptographers on the face of the earth. Again true, which is why the game has to change. > So the only way to do this is to make them not play their game. So the new game is to make sure as much traffic as possible is encrypted. All of the above take time. They could bug the end points, they could break down the encryption with massively parallel supercomputers. They could threaten individual users of the service. So the game is to make sure that everyone encrypts everything every time (or at least that enough do to make individualized efforts prohibitive on a dragnet scale). We know they don't like that game. They've been trying to get control over all encryption since the days of Clinton but they haven't yet. > Frankly whole cancerous security apparatus has been fueled by privatized sector just like the one with privatized jail system. Very true. BTW, read "The Servile State" by Hilaire Belloc if you want a really depressing read.... > Sad to say this but there only way I can see this being resolved is political/etc. Start websites cover the stories. Find methods of figuring out whether they are listening to you or not. For example set up fake drug deals so you can draw them on fact of monitoring your communications. Sue them every instance you find them breaking down your doors. Yeah I know it is not pleasant. If someone wants to, great. I am not in the US at the moment so my options are more limited. > Also make working for contractors of NSA and being employee of NSA being a very unpatriotic and scummy thing to do - akin to digging around underwear drawer of your next door granny neighbor. How do we do that? How many of us know such contractors?
- davidw 13y ago> But what do we do Stop bothering with the articles here, and "get out of the building": * Call or write a real letter to your representatives in congress (assuming you're American). Hopefully that is something everyone has already done. * Coordinate - isn't there some place where people are organizing/coordinating this stuff? * Write a letter to the editor in your local newspaper. * If you're in the bay area, how about helping to organize a primary challenger for Nancy Pelosi? She did not vote to defund the NSA. People in SF have the money, the means, and the incentive to get someone in office who cares more about this stuff. * Donate money to politicians/groups opposing this stuff. The EFF, for instance.
- pdkl95 13y ago"I don't have to tell you things are bad. Everybody knows things are bad." I've taught more people about the Web Of Trust and how to use GPG in the last ~1.5 months than in the last ~1.5 decades. "...and we sit watching our TV's while some local newscaster tells us that today we had fifteen homicides and sixty-three violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed to be." Something about this current drama has made the whole concept of encryption and the realities of surveillance suddenly resonate with a LOT more people. It's not a majority yet, of course, but a change in perception this dramatic is a amazing. "We sit in the house, and slowly the world we are living in is getting smaller, and all we say is, 'Please, at least leave us alone in our living rooms.'" I have people emailing me encrypted email now, who just last year ignored the idea with the usual dismissal of it being "unnecessary" or "too complicated"[1]. "Well, I'm not going to leave you alone. I don't want you to protest. I don't want you riot. I don't want to write to your congressman because I wouldn't know what to tell your to write." So now that people are finally noticing the reality they live in, and are finally getting mad, I see this as what educators call a "teachable moment" to try and suggest a few broader concepts tan the gpg lessons they are asking for. "I'm as MAD AS HELL, and I'm NOT going to take this anymore!" A few things I've been trying to teach recently, now that there are actually people listening: * General education on the concept of data mining, and the power of a handful of JOIN clauses. The idea of grabbing all your phone calls is something most people already understand. Connecting a few random bits of entropy together to get a surprisingly reliable primary key is still not widely understood. * Web Of Trust - Starting small and local is good, just like in elections. It would be amazing if somehow the Key Signing Party could be worked into some traditional social ritual. * Stop supporting the feudal model of email, by tying your identity to an @company.com domain. Land is king IRL, and staking your claim on the internet is important for similar reasons. It would be nice if everybody could change their MX records and hosting service as easily as they change POTS long distance providers. * Stop using webmail - many of the benefits of encryption are lost if you don't keep the keys in your physical possession, as demonstrated by lavabit and elsewhere. This doesn't directly fix the problem[2], but it is stuff that can be done (and is being done) now, and these are certainly things that would help immediate problems faced when organizing a revolution. The NSA doesn't have the manpower or money to strong-arm their snooping routers into every last-mile endpoint. This kind of long-term cutting of the data the NSA can see is one of the better weapons we have against them. "Then we'll figure out what to do about the depression and the inflation and the oil crisis. But first get up out of your chairs, open the window, stick your head out, and yell..."[3] [1] You would think a Biology professor would understand an argument about how this isn't necessary about them, but about maintaining the "herd immunity" of the email ecosystem... [2]: It might in the long run, once a lot more software support is written, and it finally becomes possible for regular people to extend their web of trust as far as, e.g. groklaw. [3]: Incidentally, the lecture at the end of Network comes to mind every time the government panics about Snowden: "...and YOU have meddled with the primal forces of nature, and YOU...WIIL...ATONE!" edit; formatting