5 ms·
> I hope very much the industry can improve electrical safety over time. With regard to the electrical aspects, isn't the safety record on these cars perfect o
by justin66 13y ago
> I hope very much the industry can improve electrical safety over time.
With regard to the electrical aspects, isn't the safety record on these cars perfect or close to perfect up until this date? That means it's only going to get worse. That does not mean electrical cars are unsafe, it just means there isn't much of a record yet.
My expectation is that there will over time be a small number of electricity-related accidents involving first responders and passengers and that they will be enough to fuel concern trolls until the end of time. That the electrical problems will be so enormous that they dwarf the massive safety gains from better passenger protection of the sort NHTSA is interested in (and frankly, anyone who is about to get hit by an oncoming SUV is interested in) seems awfully counterintuitive.
- abalone 13y agoWish I had your crystal ball. With improvement, I was referring to the complexity of cutting someone out of a Tesla and all the no-cut zones that could electrocute passengers, emergency responders, even guys towing wrecks. You're right, there is no real safety record yet.
- lutusp 13y ago> With improvement, I was referring to the complexity of cutting someone out of a Tesla and all the no-cut zones that could electrocute passengers, emergency responders, even guys towing wrecks. As an electrical engineer with spacecraft experience, I can say that a car like the Model S isn't likely to electrocute anyone. While extracting someone from a wreck, emergency workers use tools like the "jaws of life", strong metal pliers meant to quickly snip a car's body apart. When a tool like this cuts into an electric car, if it should slice through a power cable, in most cases the tool would short the cable to the car's chassis, thus grounding it and tripping the safety links that are integral to the battery pack. This means the car will become inoperative, but it doesn't mean anyone will get electrocuted. I think the above will be the outcome in the vast majority of cases. Compare this to the plight of someone sitting in a wrecked gasoline-fueled car.
- abalone 13y agoHi there. Go ahead and watch this video from Tesla about how to cut someone out of a Tesla. The very first step is to cut the circuit like you say, but there are a few things you overlooked. Much of the video is concerned with instructing responders how to cut around components that may remain electrified such as the converter and capacitors which, in Tesla's own words, present a "serious hazard of shock" because "they can release up to 400 volts in just an instant." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntK3rvVl2Qw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntK3rvVl2Qw
- ash 13y agoDo other car manufactures provide such videos?
- goatforce5 13y agoI know a paramedic in rural Australia. They get taken to local car dealers to get safety training with electric cars. As I understand it it's done on a per-model basis, but that wont really work as an increasing number of electric car models end up on the roads. I'm not sure if this is done all over the state/country, or if it's the one local dealer being friendly with the local emergency services.
- sergiosgc 13y agoNitpicking, I know, but releasing 400 volts means nothing. Current kills, tension does not. It all hinges on the internal resistance of the power source.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoThat and time. You could get hit with high volts and current, but still be fine if the exposure is short. I have had a few 240v mains shocks on high current fuses, but they were all pretty quick and I had nothing but very slight burns and sore muscles for about ten minutes. However, there is definitely a risk here, albeit what appears to be a manageable one. Perhaps there could be some use in building volt meters that glow into gloves for emergency responders to help mitigate some of the risk.
- outworlder 13y agoAren't those the same concerns people had when gasoline cars were introduced? It was considered to be too dangerous to use. Fast forward to today, cars are not exploding. Battery safety issues will be dealt with. Considering the fact that Tesla batteries are made for lots of really tiny cells, I can't imagine it is impossible to disconnect them from each other in the case of a crash.
- abalone 13y agoI don't know about individually disconnecting each cell, but there is a loop that emergency responders are supposed to manually cut to disconnect the battery. However there are still components that retain power and remain hazardous such as the converter and capacitors. Firefighters need to take great care to cut around them. Plus there's the possibility of the battery compartment being compromised in an accident as well. Tesla's training video covers all this. Nobody's arguing that Teslas are unsafe, just that the "safest car" claim sidesteps the electrical safety issue. You can't really argue that everything's fine because nothing bad has happened yet, because there are so few Teslas on the road. And it should be noted, a lot of people were hurt along the path to making gasoline cars as safe as they are today. Look at Ralph Nader's work on automobile safety for example. I actually believe progress demands that we work through electrical car safety. But what irks me is it's just a little premature to be trumpeting "SAFEST CAR EVAR" when you've got a novel set of serious safety issues that the test suite doesn't even try to target.