4 ms·
My opinion: You don't have to be loyal. Instead, be professional. That means you retain many of the qualities of loyalty -- dilligence and an eye for the adva
by jacques_chester 13y ago
My opinion:
You don't have to be loyal. Instead, be professional.
That means you retain many of the qualities of loyalty -- dilligence and an eye for the advantage of your client or employer -- without being afraid to ask for the going rate for your services.
A professional is also prepared to argue for the best interests of the client and to refuse to act unethically, even when the client doesn't want to hear it. Our cousin professions enjoy pretty strong legal support for the latter.
- afarrell 13y agoAnd if your loyalty to yourself and your professional ethics are in conflict with the wishes of your employer, it is far better to follow your true loyalties. Though it might come at great personal cost if you end up having to flee to Russia.
- dkuntz2 13y agoI'm sorry, but I can't let your aside at the end stand. From my point of view it had nothing to do with ethics, and everything to do with the possibility of fame. He revealed himself. He couldn't even wait, he had to let people know what he did. He practically bragged about it. The personal cost wasn't due his ethics, it was due to his inability to shut up.
- chrischen 13y agoYou should consider the possibility that the fame was necessary for his personal self-preservation. If he didn't make himself famous, the gov't could potentially do very bad things to him and no one would notice, or care. The publicity could have been his greatest and only weapon against the US.
- dkuntz2 13y agoHow was fame necessary for his self-preservation? If nobody knew who leaked how is revealing himself useful? Deep Throat never needed to reveal himself to the world. Things seemed to go fairly well for him. There are better ways to make sure people don't do bad things to you than tell the whole world that you were the leak. A simple program that requires daily interaction that sends an email to one of the people he leaked to if he doesn't interact with it, revealing himself at that point. It was not his "greatest and only weapon". He was someone who wanted his name to be remembered. Tangentially, the reveal made the conversation about him, and not the information.
- jrochkind1 13y agoBecause even if "nobody" knew who leaked, the US government would probably find out. And if "nobody" else knew, he'd be disappeared by now. Things have changed a lot since deep throat. As Daniel Ellsberg (from around the same era) wrote, they let him _out on bail_ while waiting for a trial. http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-leaker-snowden-made-the-right-call/2013/07/07/0b46d96c-e5b7-11e2-aef3-339619eab080_print.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-l... Back when the US government assassinating people without trial might actually outrage the public enough to cost politicians their jobs. Times have changed. The "he did it to be famous" thing is exactly the story the government is trying to tell about Manning too, and it's entirely incredible in both cases, just doens't make any sense. Who puts themselves at risk of life imprisonment or death (judicial or extrajudicial) just cause they want to be famous? It doesn't even make any sense.
- lelandbatey 13y agoThere are basically two ways that this information leaking game goes down: The first is to play it sneaky, being covert in your dealings and hoping against all Odds that you don't screw up and get silently caught. The second is to do everything in the extreme public eye, so that the accumulated eyes of the world are watching you, but also watching out for you. Both are totally legitimate paths, but the public one has a higher survival rate. It's what I would've done.
- chrischen 13y agoGiven the fact that Snowden knew the pervasiveness of the NSA spying programs, I'm guessing he knew that it wouldn't have been hard for the government to deduce that he was the leaker eventually. Plus, it was pretty likely the government kept track of its workers in a way that would have made it even easier to identify the leaker eventually. So he probably decided to just cut to the publicity part to protect himself. In either case, you don't really know he was in it for fame.
- coldtea 13y agoWhy is that some people trivialize any important political or societal question into BS pop psychology about the actor's motives? We could not care less about those. Perhaps the result of too many bad hollywood movies focusing on "character development", a legacy of puritanism, being conditioned by crap news coverage to turn everything into gossip. Oh, and inexperience with thinking politically. >The personal cost wasn't due his ethics, it was due to his inability to shut up. You just couldn't contain your disdain for the man, right? I see some projection in play here, if you allow me the same BS pop psychology.
- elihu 13y agoIf he had remained anonymous, the naysayers would have called him a coward. By revealing himself, he's labelled a narcissist.
- dalek_cannes 13y agoa) Loyalty is a sentiment meant for living beings, not corporations, and b) When a corporation knows you're "loyal", what they really know is that your threshold for leaving is higher than non-loyal employers of the same skill level, telling them that incentives are better spent on those high flight risk employees than you. You lose.
- vacri 13y agoYes, very much so. The other thing is that loyalty is not a binary; it really shouldn't be discussed as if it's an either/or.