3 ms·
I understand your position in this, and after reading the full story, I even agree... but I also know a few independent security researchers (i.e. people who do
by falcolas 13y ago
I understand your position in this, and after reading the full story, I even agree... but I also know a few independent security researchers (i.e. people who don't do this professionally) who do not.
They, rightfully or not, see an independent who was ignored and then persecuted for trying to responsibly report a bug. It's given Facebook a black eye to more than just the HN crowd, and people will probably be thinking twice about disclosing security bugs, particularly if they get "working as intended" as their initial response.
Also, consider the guidelines that go into developing a UI. The more roadblocks you put in someone's way to register for your site, the fewer people will register. Apply that to this, and the more roadblocks you put into reporting a bug correctly (requesting special accounts, fighting to convince staff that your bug is an actual issue), the fewer bug reports you're going to get. That's not a good thing for Facebook in the long run.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't see how you get from the facts of what happened to "persecution". Could you go a little further into that?
- falcolas 13y agoDisabling his Facebook account, and deciding not to pay Khalil Shreateh (though the account was later re-enabled after further emails between himself and Facebook).