3 ms·
He was brought in for questioning and seized of his property. On what basis? The Home Office guidelines clearly state that questioning and seizure are to be us
by grey-area 13y ago
He was brought in for questioning and seized of his property.
On what basis? The Home Office guidelines clearly state that questioning and seizure are to be used only in cases where terrorism is suspected. David Miranda is clearly not a terrorist, nor is he associated with terrorists. To quote the guidelines:
Schedule 7 powers are to be used solely for the purpose of ascertaining if the person examined is or has been concerned in the commission, preparation or instigation of acts of terrorism. The powers must not be used to stop and question persons for any other purpose. An examination must cease and the examinee must be informed that it has ended once it has been ascertained that the person examined does not appear to be or to have been concerned in the commission, preparation or instigation of acts of terrorism.
Does the law say somewhere that they can question anyone for any purpose? If not then this was clearly illegal.
- susi22 13y agoThe problem is that you have been ingrained the picture of terrorism to be a bomb blowing up, killing people or crashing planes. This is how probably 99% of all people would define terrorism (me too). However, laws cannot just talk about a common word without defining it. Everything needs to be made precise. That is what this law is doing in their very first sections. It defines what terrorism includes. And I quoted that in my first reply which you may re-read. It does define terrorism differently. As has been noted by others, Miranda had potentially national security related material which can be interpreted as (a) or (b) of above. This will be my last response.
- grey-area 13y agoYou misquoted that law by quoting only one section of two which define terrorism. Go back and read the rest of it and you will understand why you are wrong, or see the quote from symmetry below.