4 ms·
How would that logic lead to detention under an anti-terrorism law?
by Zigurd 13y ago
How would that logic lead to detention under an anti-terrorism law?
- jusben1369 13y agoIt's a huge stretch of that law but not particularly new. Al Capone was finally put in jail for violations of the taxation code! It shows how creative people get when they want to get go after someone. The logic would be Snowden releases documentation that exposes methods used by the NSA to protect people from terrorism. So stopping that release reduces the chance of a terrorism attack. That would be how the mindset goes from folks who were behind targeting this detainment.
- greenyoda 13y ago"Al Capone was finally put in jail for violations of the taxation code!" Except that Al Capone actually was guilty of tax code violations (he didn't report the income from his criminal enterprises), whereas David Miranda is in no way a terrorist (at least under any rational definition of terrorism).
- pessimizer 13y agoViolation of the tax code is a crime, though, and Capone was prosecuted under those laws because he was violating the tax code. That's creative. Miranda was not detained under terrorism laws because he was suspected to be a terrorist, but because he was suspected to be a journalist. That's simple abuse of power.
- jusben1369 13y agoAs susi22 points out the laws here are deliberately very broad.
- denis1 13y agoI'm not 100% sure, but i think Al Capone actually broke the taxation code. This guy is most certainly not terrorist. I think your comparison is not a very good one.
- jusben1369 13y agoI'm now wishing I didn't use the Al Capone example because people keep pointing out David Miranda is not a terrorist! I agree! But he might be involved in aiding or abetting terrorism by helping to release documentation that's critical in the fight against terrorism. To be clear, I'm not supporting what they did! I'm just trying to point out what the thought process was behind these actions to try and add to the overall debate.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- susi22 13y agoToo bad Jusben1369 is getting downvoted. He made a point. It's also that the Terrorism Act of 2000 defines Terrorism very very broadly [1] (b) the use or threat is designed to influence the government [or an international governmental organisation] or to intimidate the public or a section of the public, and (c) the use or threat is made for the purpose of advancing a political, religious [, racial] or ideological cause. It looks like the officers in London did act according to law. If that law makes sense or not is an entirely other discussion. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_Act_2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_Act_2000
- grey-area 13y agoWhat has David Miranda done which violates that law? For that matter I can't see what Greenwald has done to violate it either, unless all journalists are on now co-conspirators with their sources if they report anything which the government would prefer to keep secret. It's an awful law, is far too broad, and should be repealed, but even accepting that law the regulator and many MPs have serious concerns that this was illegal.
- susi22 13y agoLaws are not black and white. If they were, judges had a far easier job. Laws are made by the legislative and are interpreted by not only the judiciary branch but also by the executive branch. What has David Miranda done which violates that law? Miranda was not charged with anything, he did not violate a law. He was brought in for questioning and seized of his property. This is allowed since the law is aweful and can be interpreted this way. If it was unlawful the prosecution could prosecute the police that did this. They likely won't since the law is fuzzy. Again, I'm not supporting any of this. I'm just trying to shed some light into this since most comments her on HN are simply complaining about UK/US without digging deeper and asking themselves why this is possible and why nobody has been charged with anything yet. Law are not black and white
- grey-area 13y agoHe was brought in for questioning and seized of his property. On what basis? The Home Office guidelines clearly state that questioning and seizure are to be used only in cases where terrorism is suspected. David Miranda is clearly not a terrorist, nor is he associated with terrorists. To quote the guidelines: Schedule 7 powers are to be used solely for the purpose of ascertaining if the person examined is or has been concerned in the commission, preparation or instigation of acts of terrorism. The powers must not be used to stop and question persons for any other purpose. An examination must cease and the examinee must be informed that it has ended once it has been ascertained that the person examined does not appear to be or to have been concerned in the commission, preparation or instigation of acts of terrorism. Does the law say somewhere that they can question anyone for any purpose? If not then this was clearly illegal.