4 ms·
There is a difference between reality and academic physics. It is trivial to say engineering knowledge is derived from reality, and it's wrong to say it's deri
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
There is a difference between reality and academic physics. It is trivial to say engineering knowledge is derived from reality, and it's wrong to say it's derived/derivable from purely theoretical/academic knowledge of physics -- especially because good engineering requires knowledge of man-made safety standards and such.
Engineering is a corpus of knowledge that has been slowly and with great difficulty hewed from the raw rock of real experience over hundreds of years. It is not just a branch of math derivable from axioms. Show some respect.
- lutusp 13y ago> There is a difference between reality and academic physics. "Academic physics" describes reality. It is the closest thing to an accurate description of reality that we have. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theoretical_physics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theoretical_physics Quote: "A physical theory is a model of physical events. It is judged by the extent to which its predictions agree with empirical observations." Read the above carefully. What it says in essence is that a physical theory is judged by the degree to which it agrees with reality. Our best physical theories agree with reality to ten decimal places. Physical theory is a statement about reality. If reality disagrees, the theory is thrown out and replaced by a better one. > It is trivial to say engineering knowledge is derived from reality, and it's wrong to say it's derived/derivable from purely theoretical/academic knowledge of physics ... Engineering is applied science. Any engineering field for which this is not true has no right to exist, and doesn't deserve the public's trust. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Applied_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Applied_science Quote: "Applied science is typically engineering, which develops technology, although there might be feedback between basic science and applied science: research and development (R&D)." > Engineering is a corpus of knowledge that has been slowly and with great difficulty hewed from the raw rock of real experience over hundreds of years. It is not just a branch of math derivable from axioms. False, and you need to learn this topic. I hope you're not an engineer. > Show some respect. By correctly identifying engineering as applied science, I did. There is no higher praise than to say -- correctly -- that engineering is derived from scientific principles, from physics.