2 ms·
As I've read the proposal, I've felt like witnessing the real life Monty Python's "The Architects Sketch," the one where Cleese demonstrates his project of a re
by acqq 13y ago
As I've read the proposal, I've felt like witnessing the real life Monty Python's "The Architects Sketch," the one where Cleese demonstrates his project of a residential block of flats:
This is a twelwe-storey block combining classical neo-Georgian features with the efficiency of modern techniques. The tenants arrive in the entrance hall here, and are carried along the corridor on a conveyor belt in extreme comfort and past murals depicting Mediterranean scenes, towards the rotating knives...
The tolerances a trained astronaut can accept and be prepared for one single trip aren't something you can subject normal travelers to, even with the promise of "only 30 minutes."
Riding the high speed train is pleasurable experience. You can walk to the toilet, stroll between the seats. Riding Hyperloop: once you enter the capsule, you can't even stand up from your seat. Stay put there, don't try anything for the next 30 minutes. You feel sick in the first minute? Too bad, just don't move in your seat. You can't anyway, you're in a small capsule in the same position you are while at your dentist. Only 29 minutes to go. What, you don't have your astronaut's diapers? Too bad. You can't move from your seat. Only 29 minutes to go. Enjoy the ride.
- aryastark 13y ago> Riding Hyperloop: once you enter the capsule, you can't even stand up from your seat. Stay put there, don't try anything for the next 30 minutes. I kinda wish we'd get off this bullshit argument for once. To even get to the HSR or Hyperloop, you're going to be sitting in at least 30 minutes of LA or SF traffic. In a small capsule. And I know your next comment. "You can pull over in a car!" Yeah, you don't live in LA then. Get stuck on any of the freeways and you're not pulling over and not getting out. Or did you really plan on taking a shit on the side of the freeway? Does everyone on HN get explosive projectile diarrhea every time they step outside? Maybe Musk is missing a market for you dysfunctional people.
- acqq 13y agoFrom the PDF: Picture: http://www.rtcc.org/files/2013/08/Hyperloop-passenger-capsule-version-cutaway-with-passengers-onboard.jpg http://www.rtcc.org/files/2013/08/Hyperloop-passenger-capsul... Description: The maximum width is 4.43 ft (1.35 m) and maximum height is 6.11 ft (1.10 m). With rounded corners, this is equivalent to a 15 ft2 (1.4 m2) frontal area, not including any propulsion or suspension components. Note "6.11" feet is in fact a typo, he meant at most 3.38 feet as the multiplication with 4.43 gives 15 of frontal area, and it fits with the metric units. It's very low, much less comfortable than sitting in the car. And you can be serviced in the car in the case of accident -- emergency cars reach the people in need. You practically can't interrupt the 30 minutes of supersonic ride in the capsule. Imagine that I offer you to enter the non-moving capsule and stay there, knowing that absolutely no matter what happens to you, it won't be opened for 30 minutes. Would you enter? Would you let your grandparent enter it? Your kid? And finally: http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2013/08/hyperloop http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2013/08/hyperloop
- marze 13y agoNicely ranted.