2 ms·
I'm not up on mobile devices, but I have to believe that they also use frequently changing, dynamically assigned IP addresses. I believe that's correct, yes. I
by pdonis 13y ago
I'm not up on mobile devices, but I have to believe that they also use frequently changing, dynamically assigned IP addresses.
I believe that's correct, yes. If they are using wifi, they will appear to be connecting using the wifi router's public IP address, which will certainly be different for each wifi router. If they are using the cell phone network to connect, I'm pretty sure they get assigned a public IP address based on which cell tower they are using to connect, so that will change as well.
I don't like the idea that there is screen scraping as something different from ordinary usage; it's not.
In terms of the data itself, you're right, screen scraping is just pulling the data, the same as a web browser does.
However, since screen scraping can be automated, it can potentially use a lot more bandwidth, since it can request multiple pages from a site much faster than a human driving a browser can. That's why sites are allowed to restrict what automated search bots can do on their sites, for example with a robots.txt file. A service like 3Taps would be expected to respect these types of restrictions just like Google does.
That said, I don't think the issue in this case was the screen scraping per se; I think the issue was that Craigslist asserted copyright over their data, so that they had the right to say that 3Taps could not use the data the way they were using it.
- graycat 13y agoFor screen scraping, it appears that some people want to say that, because some software in effect provided the browser keystrokes or mouse clicks, something was wrong. Once I wrote a little program that gets Web pages from a Web site; if I handled all the details correctly, then there is no way for the Web site to know that it is sending the data to my program instead of a Web browser. Indeed, essentially I wrote a Web browser. That my Web browser just wrote data to files and did not provide a graphical user interface on my screen is none of the business of the Web site. It can't be illegal to write a Web browser, especially a very simple one. For getting pages too fast, just write the software to get the pages more slowly. Done. Or if want to use one computer to get 100 pages from each of 10,000 sites, then then get one page from each of the 10,000 sites, 100 times. Done. > I think the issue was that Craigslist asserted copyright over their data, Fine. But there is an issue: Just how the heck is Craigslist to know who got the data? Not from IP address -- that's terrible evidence. Then how's Craigslist to know just what the heck the data was used for? Even it it's clear that the data was from Craigslist originally, if the person using or misusing the data might have gotten the data from someone else and not directly from Craigslist. So, to me, for Craigslist to run around with lawyers and C&D letters attacking Internet users looks like a bummer. If a user does something obvious and blatant with Craigslist data, or is dumb enough to admit getting the data after a C&D letter, then okay. But mostly the legal effort is a loose cannon on the deck that can hurt a lot of people based on really poor evidence.
- pdonis 13y agothere is no way for the Web site to know that it is sending the data to my program instead of a Web browser. Except through your User-Agent string. Which can, of course, be faked, but if you are actually running a scraper or other automated tool, you're not supposed to use a browser User-Agent string. For getting pages too fast, just write the software to get the pages more slowly. Done. Yes, agreed; all search bots and other automated tools are supposed to do this. But there is an issue: Just how the heck is Craigslist to know who got the data? I don't know how Craigslist found out in this specific case; but the point was moot anyway because 3Taps admitted they had obtained the data; there was no dispute about that. The dispute was entirely over whether what 3Taps was doing with the data once they got it was "authorized". how's Craigslist to know just what the heck the data was used for? Because 3Taps admitted what they were using it for. There was no dispute about that either, only about whether that use was authorized. for Craigslist to run around with lawyers and C&D letters attacking Internet users looks like a bummer. Have they been doing that? In this particular case, as I said above, there was no dispute at all about the facts, only about the legal rights involved. I don't see any evidence that Craigslist is indiscriminately banning people and then suing them based on disputed facts; the only dispute I see is over whether Craigslist should be able to assert the rights it's asserting over its data.
- graycat 13y ago> your User-Agent string Sure, my software sends a nice, simple, vanilla pure, good looking string for the user agent string. I agree with you about essentially all the details of this specific case. As seemingly hinted in the OP, my concern is with the more general situation -- could a Web site use lawyers, C&D letters, and IP addresses to make big legal problems for Internet users who download an unusually large number of Web pages? I hope not. Then there's the suggestion that for a user to get a new IP address is somehow nefarious -- it's not. And there's calling getting Web pages screen scraping as if it is different, unusual, and nefarious -- it's not. Then there's the suggestion that what the user did that was bad was getting the data when the real problem was that the user republished the copyrighted data.
- 13y ago