5 ms·
Why does every government agency dealing with business have an obsession with "detailed business plans"? The key to regulating companies is clearly to require
by dmix 13y ago
Why does every government agency dealing with business have an obsession with "detailed business plans"?
The key to regulating companies is clearly to require them to write 30 pages of creative writing detached from the reality of how the business will operate a few months later.
How about a few page summary of the business with profiles of the team members, or pitch deck, without all the useless detail.
- MoreConsiderate 13y agoThey want people with assets with something to lose, an aspect of the AML logic.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VMG 13y agoWhy should it be the responsibility of the government to filter out the crap? The market does that pretty well. I think they just want to filter so that there are fewer companies to regulate, disregarding the fact that this kind of regulation affects small businesses disproportionately.
- jpswade 13y agoI'm just giving you the reason. I'm sorry, I don't have all the answers.
- rayiner 13y agoGovernments think of the financial system the way ATT or VZN think of their cellular networks. Nobody is going to let you plug in your new cellular device with just a pitch deck about how it works. Also: to filter out ponzi schemes and the like.
- oleganza 13y ago"Ponzi schemes" are like "pornodrugterrorists" - just a pseudo-reason to protect the monopoly in the eyes of the voters at their own expense. Maybe if people were allowed to decide whether they want to pay for "protecting" them from ponzi schemes, we would know how these problems could be solved most efficiently. However, the taxes are not paid, but extracted, so we cannot really find out what is the better way to protect ourselves.
- rayiner 13y agoFinancial fraud duping people is extremely common. You can argue about whether people should protect themselves, but at the end of the day, these laws were demanded as a response to people getting robbed.
- dmix 13y agoIn the 1920s, before you could google "[company name] + scam".
- raverbashing 13y agoIt would be so great if this was the case Today, people will still put their money on companies that return a result from that query. That is, most of the MLM companies
- oleganza 13y agoIs it a proof of government inefficiency at fighting fraud? Or a call for more regulation? We would never know that until people are allowed to decide for themselves how they want to protect themselves. Right now we have two problems: 1) we are forced to allocate huge amounts of money for various "protection" of dubious quality, so we don't have much money left for extra protection that we ourselves may choose; 2) various business models that might explore alternative ways to protect people are either prohibited or kept away from existing monopoly markets protected by the state. In short: while there are state guns, we cannot know if they do us any good. And I very much suspect that any person who constantly coerces you "for your own good" without a good proof is always an evil sadist. (Parents may force children to take a medicine because they can then demonstrate that it was actually helping. Like you may drag me by force from under a running bus and then tell me why you did it. But constant abuse without a proof and religious brainwashing is pure sadism.)