4 ms·
For those who missed other criticisms, see also: Musk's Hyperloop math doesn't add up https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6232573 https://news.ycombinator.co
by acqq 13y ago
For those who missed other criticisms, see also:
Musk's Hyperloop math doesn't add up
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6232573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6232573
Musk's proposal won't actually get riders to the downtowns of Los Angeles or San Francisco. It can only carry around 10% of the capacity of the California High-Speed Rail. Additionally, it will bypass other population centers, like Bakersfield, Fresno, and San Jose. Building a truly workable Hyperloop, if it's feasible at all, will be significantly more expensive than Musk claims. It might even be more expensive than the California HSR project. And Musk's proposal leaves a lot of questions unanswered.
And:
Loopy Ideas Are Fine, If You’re an Entrepreneur
http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy-ideas-are-fine-if-youre-an-entrepreneur/ http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy...
The proposed relationship between curve radius and speed in the Hyperloop standards is for a lateral acceleration much greater than 4.9 m/s^2 in the horizontal plane: 480 km/h at 1,600 meters is 11.1 m/s^2. This only drops to 5 m/s^2 after perfectly canting the track, converting the downward 9.8 m/s^2 gravity and the sideways acceleration into a single 14.8 m/s^2 acceleration vector downward in the plane of the capsule floor, or 5 m/s^2 more than passengers are used to. This is worse than sideways acceleration: track standards for vertical acceleration are tighter than for horizontal acceleration, about 0.5-0.67 m/s^2, one tenth to one seventh what Musk wants to subject his passengers to. It’s not transportation; it’s a barf ride.
The barf ride that is as expensive as California HSR and takes as long door-to-door is also very low-capacity.(...) The proposed headway is 30 seconds, for 3,360 passengers per direction per hour. (...) HSR can do 12,000 passengers per direction per hour: 12 trains per hour is possible (...)
But even 30 seconds appears well beyond the limit of emergency braking.
And also:
Hyperloop proposal: Bad joke or attempt to sabotage California HSR project?
http://stopandmove.blogspot.fr/2013/08/hyperloop-proposal-bad-joke-or-attempt.html http://stopandmove.blogspot.fr/2013/08/hyperloop-proposal-ba...
High Speed Rail between downtown LA and downtown SF:
2 hours, 28 minutes
Hyperloop trip between downtown LA and downtown SF:
1 hour from LA to Sylmar via Metrolink
20 minute transfer
35 minutes to Dublin
20 minute transfer
1 hour 10 minutes from Dublin to SF via BART
Total: 3 hours 25 minutes
The project also doesn't even attempt to price the connection into LA or SF. That's where the high costs are.
Amusingly enough, the California HSR budget for the Central Valley is under $10 billion. Ie, in the same ball-park as this proposal. The reason the HSR project is going to cost $60 billion is because it has to face an uncomfortable truth; actually getting to LA and SF is expensive. Very expensive.
Is Elon Musk's s mega-announcement really just a last-ditch attempt to sabotage the California High Speed Rail (HSR) project, rather than a serious proposal to revolution travel? Something smells very fishy.
- dragonwriter 13y agoYeah, I always thought the fact that the route essentially ignored the mass transit equivalent of the last-mile problem (rendering it useless as mass transit) and that virtually all of the cost savings vs. HSR came from that (to put it generously) oversight was the most important criticism. But it doesn't surprise me to see that the civil engineering end may have equally basic problems, as well.
- acqq 13y agoAs I've read the proposal, I've felt like witnessing the real life Monty Python's "The Architects Sketch," the one where Cleese demonstrates his project of a residential block of flats: This is a twelwe-storey block combining classical neo-Georgian features with the efficiency of modern techniques. The tenants arrive in the entrance hall here, and are carried along the corridor on a conveyor belt in extreme comfort and past murals depicting Mediterranean scenes, towards the rotating knives... The tolerances a trained astronaut can accept and be prepared for one single trip aren't something you can subject normal travelers to, even with the promise of "only 30 minutes." Riding the high speed train is pleasurable experience. You can walk to the toilet, stroll between the seats. Riding Hyperloop: once you enter the capsule, you can't even stand up from your seat. Stay put there, don't try anything for the next 30 minutes. You feel sick in the first minute? Too bad, just don't move in your seat. You can't anyway, you're in a small capsule in the same position you are while at your dentist. Only 29 minutes to go. What, you don't have your astronaut's diapers? Too bad. You can't move from your seat. Only 29 minutes to go. Enjoy the ride.
- aryastark 13y ago> Riding Hyperloop: once you enter the capsule, you can't even stand up from your seat. Stay put there, don't try anything for the next 30 minutes. I kinda wish we'd get off this bullshit argument for once. To even get to the HSR or Hyperloop, you're going to be sitting in at least 30 minutes of LA or SF traffic. In a small capsule. And I know your next comment. "You can pull over in a car!" Yeah, you don't live in LA then. Get stuck on any of the freeways and you're not pulling over and not getting out. Or did you really plan on taking a shit on the side of the freeway? Does everyone on HN get explosive projectile diarrhea every time they step outside? Maybe Musk is missing a market for you dysfunctional people.