3 ms·
"Some of the best solutions for problems come from people who have not yet become indoctrinated in the "standard" methodology." Is that really true, or a hypot
by dalke 13y ago
"Some of the best solutions for problems come from people who have not yet become indoctrinated in the "standard" methodology."
Is that really true, or a hypothesis? How was it tested, and what are the numbers? For example, do 5% of the solutions come from people in their first year and the other 95% come from those with between 1 year and 40 years? Or is it more like 80% and 20%?
Knowing those numbers helps determine strategy. The former suggests that novel solutions are hard, and inspiration is only weakly connected to experience, while the latter suggests that people should move to new fields every year or two, in order to take advantage of this effect.
For that matter, if the numbers are 1% and 99% then it implies that while 'some of the best solutions' come from new people, the overwhelming majority do not, in which case your observation, while still true, has a different interpretation.
In my own research, I came up with a novel and useful implementation for a multiple-graph maximum common subgraph isomorphism. It's a problem that I worked on when I first entered this field, when I was in my late 20s, but with 10+ years of experience in the field I was able to come up with a faster, more efficient and more general purpose method.
(FWIW, it's based on the observation that in practice, for
the types of graphs I work with, a certain NP-hard method - pairwise subgraph isomorphism - is actually very fast. New people to the field assume 'NP-hard' means 'avoid at all costs', so avoid use this method.)
Is my story anecdotal? Absolutely. Which is why I'm curious to see the evidence you used to form your statement.
- DRMacIver 13y agoI think "best solutions come from new people" is an over-simplification of what actually happens. New people force you to re-examine your assumptions and blind spots. Sometimes this is useful, sometimes it isn't. This doesn't mean that new people solve more problems, but sometimes an influx of new people can help the experts to solve more problems because they realise something they assumed to be true/OK wasn't.
- molbioguy 13y agoMy statement is based on personal experiences -- it's an observation and not an authoritative fact; I don't have formal studies to back this up. A really great solution from a new perspective is admittedly rare when you take into account all tasks. However, when there's a problem that's been giving a group some difficulty, I've had many occasions where the new person who was coming from a different background, provided a key advance. It was usually along the lines of something we all thought was either too simple to try, "known" to not work, or just went against all the standard methods we had been taught (like the anecdotal example you provided). In the context of the article, having minimal knowledge (just enough to understand the problem), also affords you with the opportunity to learn more on your own and develop your own views before someone tells you how to think. While I can't back it up with level of evidence you're asking for, in my experience it's still a good strategy to go with. I realize this is drifting away from the original topic. Sorry about that.
- dalke 13y agoAs I pointed out though, without some sense of what "many" means, it's not possible to make an effective planning decision based on this hypothesis. For example, what's the bias error? How many new problems are solved daily by people with expertise in the field, which would take someone without that expertise a long time? This is also different than the class of problems I think you're referring to, which are cases where the experts in the fields are already stymied. Even then, you might not notice the ones where someone with 15 years of experience figures it out, because you expect that to happen, while if an intern solves it then it's notable. At the point where the group is stuck, dead in the water on a problem, then it's definitely useful to have others look on it, if only because there isn't much to lose by doing so.
- molbioguy 13y agoNot quite sure what you mean by "planning decision". Do mean actively recruiting people with backgrounds and knowledge that are substantially different from your existing group? Do you mean from the individual's point of view whether or not to learn as much information as possible and become an "expert" before contributing? I'm assuming you have minimally sufficient knowledge of your field, otherwise you wouldn't have been hired in the first place. I'm just saying that it can sometimes be advantageous not to spend all your time learning as much as possible about the way things are normally done at your new job/activity and approach the job from your own strengths and knowledge. In that way you may surprise yourself and others with solutions that they hadn't thought of because they couldn't see outside their box. You will become an expert eventually (if you want), but you may delay contributing if you wait until you reach that status before trying. And although you may look foolish or stupid if your naive idea was wrong, in my experience you don't get fired for trying. You just get embarrassed and then spend your time steeping yourself in the field's dogma :) It's just an observation ...
- dalke 13y agoBy "planning decision" I mean to use this knowledge to make a decision which is more likely to lead to a successful project. Consider the converse to your statement: It can sometimes be advantageous to spend all your time learning as much as possible about the way things are normally done while approaching the job from your own strengths and knowledge. It seems that that converse statement is equally true. If a statement and its converse seem equally true, then how useful of a statement is it? "you may delay contributing if you wait until you reach that status before trying" Certainly. However, contributing is also an important part of learning, and you are unlikely to get to expert status if you delay in contributing.