4 ms·
> The author does make the point that it might also be the people themselves pushing for it, at least. I think the implication is that that is largely a form o
by vanderZwan 13y ago
> The author does make the point that it might also be the people themselves pushing for it, at least.
I think the implication is that that is largely a form of Stockholm syndrome.
> They'll probably go as far as to sabotage genuine useful production in an effort to prove their value.
How is this not an extra argument in favour of his claim that there are lots of bullshit jobs out there?
- RyanZAG 13y ago"How is this not an extra argument in favour of his claim that there are lots of bullshit jobs out there?" I was not arguing against the idea of bullshit jobs. It's not even possible to argue against that! I was arguing against the reason for having bullshit jobs. He attributes this to some plan by 'the man' to put people in these jobs. I'm arguing it is people putting themselves in these jobs by themselves.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- singingfish 13y agoThus "the man" influences the people to act against their own best interest. Happens all the time.
- JonnieCache 13y ago>He attributes this to some plan by 'the man' to put people in these jobs. I'm arguing it is people putting themselves in these jobs by themselves. Those two things are not mutually exclusive. See the last line of the article: "Clearly, the system was never consciously designed. It emerged from almost a century of trial and error." People in power make little daily nudges, those under the yoke follow the path of least resistance, and society wanders towards an equilibrium.
- RyanZAG 13y agoAlright, I understand the argument now, thank you. I still disagree that anybody is trying to make this occur through nudges, a plan or any sort of action - considered or not. I believe it is the result of human kind's base urge to find meaning in themselves and their lives. I'd say that even if people in power were to try and push people into jobs, the people being pushed out of jobs would seek to find any job they could do regardless of how useless it may be. Simply to be doing a job and satisfying themselves. I fully accept it's a plausible argument that people in control are pushing us, though.
- JonnieCache 13y agoIt's a bit more than a just plausible argument. There's a whole cabinet department devoted to it: http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/sep/09/cameron-nudge-unit-economic-behaviour?guni=Article:in%20body%20link http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/sep/09/cameron-nudge... https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/behavioural-insights-team https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/behavioural-insi...
- RyanZAG 13y agoI'm still not convinced. The attempt by one government to carry out 'economic nudging' does not mean that the nudging has had any real effect. There is also the problem that countries without such attempts (eh.. Sri Lanka?) are having any different results in people working bullshit jobs. Again, the argument is plausible but is a long way from being compelling, for me at least. The simplest answer - that people are doing what they do because it's how people work - is far more compelling for me. The right answer is usually the one that passes the 'least surprise' test the best. What would surprise you more? 1. A group of the government and wealththy individuals are managing to convince the entire population into working bullshit jobs. 2. People without jobs don't feel they have a purpose and try to create a purpose in any way they can, such as copying those who do appear to have a purpose.
- LOSindignados 13y agoRyanZAG, I suspect it's more a matter of it being convenient for those with entrenched wealth and power to let the masses struggle for the scraps they have left over. This situation leads most of us to compete for the bullshit jobs, to get angry at those who were fortunate enough to get real jobs (even if they are poorly compensated relative to their social value, e.g. teachers), and to generally be so distracted by the charade as to not notice the massive fraud taking place behind doors forever closed to their unwashed, foolish selves.