7 ms·
That's a perfectly valid opinion to have, but it's not very appropriate to call it compatible with freedom of speech.
by baddox 13y ago
That's a perfectly valid opinion to have, but it's not very appropriate to call it compatible with freedom of speech.
- revscat 13y agoI think that it is. There are limits to speech everywhere, whether it is the prototypical "fire in a theater" example, or making threats. It is simply another in that category.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoThe German constitution does not recognize freedom of speech; what it does recognize is freedom of political expression. There's a limit to this, though, when it is perceived to endanger public peace. Holocaust denial and suchlike has always been considered an assault on public peace. No public figure will be seen denying the holocaust or similar, the only purpose of that sort of statement can be to incite a mob. That's the background. Now consider this: the German constitution was commissioned in 1948 by the Allied Powers, there was much experience in the Commission that developed it with constitutions of democratic nations, and the Nazi experience was fresh in everyone's mind. I think the fact that Germany does not have "freedom of speech" written in its constitution wants to tell you something. TL;DR: Germany does not recognize freedom of speech. Germans consider this to be a Good Thing.
- justin66 13y ago> compatible with freedom of speech Which actually has little to do with prisoner of conscience status by itself. It's true enough that a prisoner of conscience has her freedom of speech violated in most cases. It doesn't follow that everyone whose freedom of speech is violated is a prisoner of conscience.