4 ms·
Good for them. While I consider UK to be a sane country, I don't want US companies to be subject to the whims of local little kangaroo courts. Perhaps they shou
by kstrauser 13y ago
Good for them. While I consider UK to be a sane country, I don't want US companies to be subject to the whims of local little kangaroo courts. Perhaps they should be subject to billion dollar fines for not having Robert Mugabe's picture on their home page when viewed by Zimbabwean residents?
It's not my intent to compare UK to Zimbabwe, but to illustrate that holding local companies to foreign standards is kind of insane. Let's turn that around: you can bet that some UK companies are violating the US's insane IP laws. Should American companies be able to sue them for doing things that are legal in their own home country?
I'm not remotely a Google fanboy, but fair is fair. They're subject to US laws, but I don't think Google US should be liable for every regulation everywhere.
- adam-a 13y agoAs long as they are drawing profits internationally they should be subject to laws in those nations. If they don't like the law in a particular country then they shouldn't do business there. After all Google have .co.uk domains and offices in the UK, it's not like a bunch of foreigners just started using their services without their knowledge. Practically, if Google were to try to dodge UK law, there's now a set of tools in place to block websites. This is essentially what happened to the Pirate Bay. It's not likely it would ever come to that of course.
- phpnode 13y agoif they do business in the UK (which they do), they are subject to UK laws. Quite simple, no?
- drdaeman 13y agoCan an UK citizen sue an US citizen if the latter broke former's window? Not sure, but guess they can. If that's true, then UK citizens should be able to use US company (Google). I'm afraid the rulings may be somehow problematic to enforce, though. But I suspect all things change because there's Google UK Ltd.
- coolnow 13y agoI don't understand what you're getting at. If a US citizen broke my window (i live in the UK), i'd report it to the police and the criminal would be subject to UK law at all times while here (unless he has diplomatic immunity or something). What does that have to do anything with your 2nd point? Do you mean "sue", or do you really mean "use" like you wrote? If you meant sue, then of course we can, Google has a presence in the UK and thus is subject to UK law (not saying all of Google might be subject to UK law, but at least its UK arm).
- drdaeman 13y agoMy bad, I mistyped that word. Yes, I meant "sue", not "use".
- smtddr 13y ago>you can bet that some UK companies are violating the US's insane IP laws. Should American companies be able to sue them for doing things that are legal in their own home country? Yes. That's how it works if the UK company operates in the US. Like the other comments said, if there was no Google.co.uk & no Google UK offices then maybe they'd have some ground. But both of those exist, so... Just like China can't open this[1] store on American soil, Google can't have UK offices & Google.co.uk and somehow be immune to UK law, right? If companies can just enter other countries and do whatever is legal back home, I'm sure we can all think of a few examples where that would cause some significant issues. 1. http://www.tealeafnation.com/2013/06/chinas-copycat-phenomenon-fake-apple-stores-booming-in-southern-china/ http://www.tealeafnation.com/2013/06/chinas-copycat-phenomen...
- jacques_chester 13y agoLaws require "nexus" between the law and the party governed by the law. There needs to be some connection, some thing which can be gripped and used to obtain compliance -- because, as the Romans observed, without punishment there is no law. Google will have a British subsidiary for administrative purposes. That's a nexus. They might have some money in British banks, which is another nexus. And so on. More to the point, brother courts in different jurisdictions in the Common Law world will often respect and uphold each other's judgements where possible and where their laws are aligned. An order to pay a certain amount, made in Britain, might be upheld by an American court saying "yes, you broke their laws / performed a civil wrong / broke your contract; now pay the guy". Or instead there might be an inconsistency: "I'd love to help you out, but we just don't have that rule, sorry". The law is a sophisticated institution unto itself. Every time you think of a first-order or even second-order problem with a story (written by a non-lawyer), guess what? The lawyers thought of that. Probably decades ago. For example, the cases which cover the way ISPs are treated in defamation go back to a pair of cases about AOL and CompuServe. CompuServe, people. Lawyers think as hard and as far ahead about the law as we do about the web and software development.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoGoogle is more of a multinational than a US company and is nominally subject to the laws of all the countries it maintains business offices in.
- rgbrenner 13y agoSeriously? You're saying that Google, a company with offices in Manchester and London, should be able to operate in the UK, but be completely immune from their laws?!(!!!)
- Houshalter 13y agoWell then they aren't a purely American company, or at least they could be considered doing business there. I don't think OP knew that. If Google did exactly the same thing to the exact same people from those countries, but without having offices in the UK, it would have been fine? It's interesting that doing business in a country makes you liable to that country's laws, even for things that happen half way across the world on a web server. Though they very likely do have servers in the UK so that doesn't apply here. The internet is a weird place for the concept of "where" something happened. Though it would be nice if they could provide servers around the world and operate their street cars without making the entire company liable to every single government's laws.