3 ms·
I'd be very surprised to learn that this argument was never brought forward before this case. I'd be even more surprised to learn that any judge ever went alon
by toyg 13y ago
I'd be very surprised to learn that this argument was never brought forward before this case.
I'd be even more surprised to learn that any judge ever went along with it as presented. You do business in the UK, you better obey UK laws. Google is not (yet) a State entity granted diplomatic immunity or enjoying some other special arrangement, so the judge will likely laugh in their face.
This said, I can see why Google would try to pull a fast one: there is now a real risk that they'll be sued in every single country with a half-decent privacy law, and some of them won't have a £500K penalty limit. As much as they can, they have to try and claim that the US settlement covers all users, including non-US ones. It's the only alternative to a long list of expensive settlements across Europe.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> You do business in the UK, you better obey UK laws Those laws include contract laws, which allow parties to agree on where to settle any disputes. Such clauses are very common. Open any T&C, any EULA, any developer agreement, any copyright assignment. Scroll to near the bottom. You will probably find such a clause.
- teamonkey 13y agoYou can write anything you like in a EULA, doesn't make it legal.
- jacques_chester 13y agoIt's rare that courts won't honour agreements to hear disputes in a stated place under stated laws.
- toyg 13y agoDisputes about the contract, yeah. Disputes about parties' conduct which would include a breach of law, no. E.g. if you and me sign a contract stating you'll kill somebody for me with a sledgehammer, and you kill him with a chainsaw, an argument regarding the weapon mismatch will be resolved in whichever jurisdiction we specified in the actual contract, but arguments about the, ahem, nature of the activity will follow different rules (ok this is criminal rather than civil law, but i believe the reasoning is the same.)
- jacques_chester 13y agoSuch a dispute would not be heard in any court, because it's not a contract. That is, the Common Law does not recognise as a contract agreements with illegal objectives. I'd be amazed, truly amazed, if this weren't true of every common law jurisdiction. Civil wrongs are less clear-cut, because what constitutes a civil wrong is heavily dependent on local statues. That's part of why most Giganticorp Inc. contracts include clauses about settlement venues.
- toyg 13y agoI was obviously exaggerating to illustrate the point, but I think we agree that, if one's conduct is breaking civil law in a country, a contract clause alone won't be enough to get him out of trouble.