6 ms·
Colleges Consider 3-Year Degrees To Save Undergrads Time, Money
- yummyfajitas 18y agoFrom the article: Four-year degrees were designed in large part to provide a broad-based education that teaches young people to analyze and think critically, considered vital preparation to participate in the civic life of American democracy. From the undergraduate CS adviser at a major university (Paraphrased, this was a coffee hour conversation): I've actually never had a student come to me and tell me they wanted a broad education. Even very motivated students try to fill their gen-ed requirements with stuff they expect to be useful or easy. There is a fundamental disconnect here. College employees want to sell one product but college students wish to buy another. College admins want to keep the money flowing. I'd love it if new entrants take over the world here, but I don't see that happening. College is not a very competitive market.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agocollege markets are kept uncompetitive by high barriers to entry. One is the chicken and egg problem of attracting decent professors. The other is huge subsidies to existing institutions that make the tuition costs of a start-up college uncompetitive.
- tokenadult 18y agocollege markets are kept uncompetitive by high barriers to entry. Indeed. The United States looks bizarre to other countries because accreditation of colleges is done by associations of previously accredited colleges. You get to be in the club if the club admits you. http://www.ed.gov/admins/finaid/accred/index.html http://www.ed.gov/admins/finaid/accred/index.html But the clubs make one of the requirements of membership a substantial capital expense for certain kinds of facilities, so a new market entrant has to start out with a substantial supply of cash at the beginning. For colleges tha initially have no endowment income, starting out while relying mainly on student tuition payments for revenue is quite risky. http://www.maguireassoc.com/services/forecasting.html http://www.maguireassoc.com/services/forecasting.html
- yummyfajitas 18y agoWhat do you mean by "decent professors"? If you mean "quality teachers", then you'll have a very easy time of it. There is a huge oversupply of PhD's, and many are excellent teachers. You can get good teachers quite cheaply. Accredition and reputation are the main barriers.
- tokenadult 18y agoThere is a huge oversupply of PhD's, and many are excellent teachers. Agreeing with your first point that there are lots of Ph.D.s to go around to staff many colleges, how does one check your second point that a particular person is a good teacher? What is the best evidence for determining who is an effective teacher at the college level, and how is that evidence gathered at each college where Ph.D.s teach, and used at each college that has occasion to hire new faculty?
- yummyfajitas 18y agoDisclaimer: most of what I'm about to say is second hand info. I'm a research postdoc, so teaching matters very little to me (all I need to do is show up). However, I know several people who did go through this process. Current method: student evaluation. Treat it as a roughly equal mix of easiness, sympathy (1), clarity and charisma. The best method would be to measure outcomes on standardized exams. However, in all cases I've seen, the teacher doesn't affect this very much. Very few places do this. In practice, most teaching colleges hire mainly based on personal connections or random chance (whoever applied at the right time). So I didn't mean to imply that new entrants into the college market could do a good job of hiring teachers. Basically, they can do just as good a job as anyone else. (1) Fun fact: my teaching evaluations went down about 40% after I stopped acting sympathetic and started writing my own tests. "Sorry the test is so hard, I didn't write it. I'll try to help you pass it and see what I can do about a curve." -> good evaluations. "Stop whining, i'll curve it if it's too hard. And yes, I do expect you to understand the concepts rather than just do mindless calculations." -> bad evaluations. I could probably try harder to game the system, but I don't really want an academic job anymore.
- 18y ago
- tallanvor 18y agoThere are over 4000 colleges and universities in the U.S, ranging from low cost community colleges to very expensive private schools. That's a lot of options for people looking for an education. New schools are still started, although not as often as before, and they are usually public schools. Still, to claim that the college market is uncompetitive makes no sense.
- tokenadult 18y agoto claim that the college market is uncompetitive makes no sense. You've convinced me that to claim that the college market doesn't have a lot of participants makes no sense. But I don't think anyone was making that claim here. What would be good evidence that a college that wants to do something new and different (e.g., offer a three-year accredited degree at lower cost than a four-year degree) is in a strong competitive position in the current market? How do colleges compete one against another?
- nazgulnarsil 18y agothey compete by giving their students access to better jobs or academic positions than they would have had by attending a different school. college is a prestige and credentials game.
- Retric 18y agoHow do colleges compete one against another? They compete for new students / the parents of said students. The problem is even with all that competition schools don't grow and quickly grow and take over the market so students end up competing for them. Which is why schools focus on looking good from the outside and not really innovating in education.
- tallanvor 18y agoThey compete for students. They compete for professors (both those who will attract students and those who will attract grant money). They compete for peer recognition. If colleges believe they can offer a 3 year degree that will result in students who are able to compete against students with a 4 year degree, they will do so. And, to be honest, a couple will probably try. The format of higher education in America has been evolving for close to 400 years. During that time, many ideas have been tested, and you can still find a few colleges that are very different than the norm. However, the vast majority look similar in terms of how degrees are structured because that is what was found to be the most effective in preparing students for a career after they graduate. You can argue over whether or not whether the traditional methods are best, but at the end of the day they work for the majority of students here. And, of course, the quality of higher education in America is high enough to attract people from all over the world. At the end of the day, you don't have to take my word for it - just look into some of the research that's been done, both in terms of curriculum and general student development, and you'll get an idea as to just how much time is being put into determining the best ways to help students learn and grow.
- artlogic 18y agoEducational institutions aren't exactly the same as businesses. For instance, how many teenagers actually WANT to attend high school? Looking back I can honestly say I learned some important things in high school (but then again, I took every AP class available to me and then some). Colleges and universities have an interesting niche to fill. A broad-based liberal arts education isn't just a tradition - it's actually a useful tool that can help with whatever your main task is in life. I am a computer scientist by trade and by degree. My degree taught me very little I wasn't already aware of as far as computer science is concerned. The most mind blowing thing was learning Scheme, which led me to learn CL, and start looking at other functional languages. However, my degree also taught me about art (very important for a CS person IMHO), literature, history, philosophy, biology, mathematics, physics, and more... I have hobbies outside of CS mostly because of my degree. Most importantly, I can draw inspiration from other disciplines, because I understand the basics of many disciplines. Too many people expect colleges to provide only directly relevant instructional material. This is not what college is for. If you only want to learn a specific trade, go to trade school. College isn't going to get you a job, it isn't going to feel immediately useful, especially when you are young. I had the advantage of slowly getting a degree over 8 years while working full time. It was hard, and the first few years I whined like everyone else - but then I started to see how becoming more intellectual gave me a leg up in business and in CS. Colleges don't give the students what they want, because most of them haven't a clue what they want or need to prosper in the long term. College isn't job training.
- godDLL 18y ago> They got you by the balls. They spend billions of dollars every year lobbying... lobbying, to get what they want... Well, we know what they want. They want more for themselves and less for everybody else, but I’ll tell you what they don’t want... they don’t want a population of citizens capable of critical thinking. They don’t want well informed, well educated people capable of critical thinking. They’re not interested in that... that doesn’t help them. That’s against their interests. That’s right. > They don’t want people who are smart enough to sit around a kitchen table and think about how badly they’re getting fucked by a system that threw them overboard 30 fuckin' years ago. They don’t want that. You know what they want? They want obedient workers... Obedient workers, people who are just smart enough to run the machines and do the paperwork. -- George Carlin
- tophat02 18y agoExamples of classes I should not have had to take: - Kinesiology (fancy term for "PE" and/or "Health"): they had their chance in high school. By college, most people know whether they're going to be "physical" or not. I had to take FOUR of these, each for only 1 hour of credit - "Multi cultural studies": politically correct indoctrination course. By my observation, usually had the reverse effect of what was intended - Political Science I & II: Just replace with a poli sci survey course. Interested students could take more as elective or major in it - Economics and Accounting: Both of these classes are incredibly theoretical, dry, and boring - unless you happen to like the subjects, in which case you're probably majoring or minoring in them. Replace with ONE course about how not to screw up your personal financial life, since they can't be bothered to teach that in high school - Physics I & II: I don't need two full semesters of physics. Again, just give me a survey course (that's all I'll remember anyway). The interested students can go on to learn more - History I & II: We know, there's a lot of history to cover, but a whirlwind course would probably hold students' attentions more than two whole semesters Oh, and, for Computer Scientists: - The vast majority of people in computer science departments want to be programmers, NOT computer scientists. I recommend splitting this major into computer science and software engineering. Computer Science would be in the department of science and software engineering would be in the department of engineering. For software engineering students, I would collapse most of the computer science curriculum into one or two survey courses and use the rest of the time to teach solid, modern, software engineering concepts (configuration management, working in a team, requirements gathering, design patterns, methodologies, real-world programming, etc...)
- vaksel 18y agoForceful "PE" is pretty stupid, a person must come to the decision to work out on their own.
- rue 18y agoI think the idea is giving people the opportunity to work out, even a bit of a nudge, might set them on the right track. It could, for example, be a 20-minute jog and then trying out a different sport every "class."
- tsally 18y agoAm I the only person who actually wants a full and balanced education? I got enough advanced placement credit in high school to graduate with my CS degree in three years without any extra work, but I'm taking graduate courses and studying English instead. College isn't just vocational training, it's where you develop your interests and learn how to think. Honestly if all you want to do is learn how to hack well, you're better off not going to college at all. I agree, at the end of the day Universities are businesses. But don't use that as an excuse to be lazy about your education. If you are proactive and motivated, you can get your money's worth out of your school. The anti-college bias in the hacker community is really unfortunate, and ultimately it stems from a misunderstanding of what type of animal college actually is. I certainly agree that there are many talented people who do not need to go to or complete college. However there seems to be an assumption that it is the responsibly your college to stimulate your hacker ingenuity. Maybe that flew in your gifted classes in high school, but college is much more like the real world. In college it's your job to find your niche where you are intellectually simulated. EDIT: And as for the complaining about general education requirements, you need to take a look at University of Chicago. They have the strictest general education requirements out of any college and it seems to work for them. On the other hand, if you really are against general education requirements, you should have picked your college better. A college like Amherst, for example, has zero graduation requirements (besides a raw number of hours). In any case, there is always a way to work the system. Find online courses that transfer and take them. Take a class at your local community college one night a week over the summer. And so on... At the very worst, accept the fact that your technical GPA probably needs padding anyway, and use GenEds to boost your GPA so you can get interviews.
- callahad 18y agoA subtle distinction, but I don't think it's "a misunderstanding of what type of animal college actually is," but rather a misunderstanding of what type of animal college could be. The onus is upon the student to ensure he fits his school, and vice versa.
- tsally 18y agoThat's an excellent point, and very true. College is a very fluid and malleable experience. I think it's my belief that people (including myself initially) often overestimate the responsibly of the school, or ignore their own responsibility. I didn't really address the responsibility of the school though, which should not be ignored completely.
- rue 18y agoOne quite important factor that is easy to overlook is that a very significant number of people on the .eu side will not only do this 3-or-so-year bachelor's/licenciate/candidate degree, but also the additional 2-3 year master's degree. In many fields of study, Master's is the standard target, including the lower degree.
- maigret 18y agoWell in Germany & France, bachelor is already in 3 years, though most students do a master then. So the discussion is probably worth it. I have no strong opinion for 4 or 3 years personally
- dinkumthinkum 18y agoSo the answer is less education? There is already a two year program in the US. Problem solved. This is a bit much. You can already go to a diploma mill and save yourself the time. Why do in 2-3 years what can be done in a couple clicks and a laser printer? This is just lazy. Also, the idea that "people want education that will make them money do they need to skip traditional education" seems even more ridiculous in a time when very few are studying technical fields. Also the argument that many students take classes just because they are easy is stupid and I think those proferring that argument were probably the very same students. Many students are interested in an education.
- tokenadult 18y agoSo the answer is less education? Does school attendance invariably result in "education"? How might students gain what you and I could both agree is an education at less expense?
- dinkumthinkum 17y agoI'm not talking about time but unless you devise a learning pill or device such as used in the matrix, these things Still require time and course work. There are probably more tertiary expenses that could be trimmed before the actual education. Perhaps states could actually fund the education institutions.
- petercooper 18y agoThe three-year degree is the common model at the University of Cambridge and Oxford University in England Not only that but pretty much all British universities. I was surprised to learn that the US traditionally goes for four. Given the similarities of the final qualification, the extra year seems more like a money making opportunity than anything else, so I'd more expect the fourth year to appear in the UK than the US going to three ;-)
- wallflower 18y ago> a money-making opportunity more than anything else My lawyer friends complained that it is impossible to get a degree in less than the standard three years because of the way certain pre-requisite classes are scheduled. The influence of the American Board Association. Why? They said it was all for profit, no other reason. Which might say something about lawyering in the U.S. - if they're trying to profit off their own future lawyers.
- barry-cotter 18y agoNorthwestern has a two year J.D. programme. I forget the details but they have inter semester stuff for credit hours. IIRC they're really keen on work experience before letting you in though. Adam Smith Esq. had a good write up on it some time ago. You can practice in NY and possibly some other states with a UK or Irish law degree (undergrad, 3 or 4 years, cheaper).
- ShardPhoenix 18y agoMost Australian undergraduate degrees are 3 years, and more focused than the American style, without the "gen ed" requirements. You can take things like Medicine and Law directly as undergraduate degrees - there's no "pre-med" here. For most you can optionally take a further year to do honors, often research-focused. Ironically, Melbourne University, one of the most prestigious Australian universties, has recently been moving to an American-style system with more generalist degrees at the undergrad level (eg there's no undergrad medicine there anymore).
- dmharrison 18y agoThe UM change just seemed like revenue raising to me. The whole funding model of universities in aus now means you get funded on the number degrees granted and bums in seats. It seems like a way to game the system by lowering the quality bar. So I remain unconvinced that this is a better approach. Taking 5 years to do the same overall content, 3 year generalist and then 2 year masters just seems too long (may be experience bias though). I always though the generalist was things you should just be doing on your own. Bond university when it existed, allowed you to do law in 2-ish years I believe; no holidays and extremely small classes (< 15). Expensive though.
- pj 18y agoAnd cost the world an educated work force... Everyone I have spoken to, from computer science professors to employers are dismayed at the quality of computer science students and graduates. I don't see how this is going to make the problem better. Idiocracy is on its way...
- jlees 18y agoMy degree (in the UK) was 3 years and I feel I had a great education. I had plenty of time to attend whatever other courses/lectures I wanted, and when I elected to continue study into a 4th year, I got an extra degree -- and got paid to study -- that specialised me to the point I could start a PhD. (Though some in other CS fields went straight to PhD from the 3 years.)
- christofd 18y agoYeah, 3 years is better, cheaper, more effective. Then you can go back for a Masters when you need it. The extra year is not going to give you the extra kick. Only a Masters will do that. The Brits got it right. Of course this will kill the whole private school 4 year franchises, that make you believe they can change you as a person (the Yale/ Harvard/... man). 3 years is too short of an incubation time to mess with you IMHO. So much for dealing with the education priesthood.
- bowman 18y agoI come from a country where it is usual to offer 3 year degrees (NZ). It does come at a price of killing general ed requirements but I agree with this. Reasons: (1) It destroys the separation of compulsory secondary school and voluntary tertiary school. (2) Dumbs down core courses, as the general ed students flock to easy courses or convince lecturers to make the class easier.