7 ms·
Interesting. But still seems to miss all the human elements in the equation. What about if someone is seriously sick can they be evacuated in a reasonable mann
by threeseed 13y ago
Interesting.
But still seems to miss all the human elements in the equation. What about if someone is seriously sick can they be evacuated in a reasonable manner ? Likewise what about the inevitable "I need to use the toilet" scenario ?
- dojomouse 13y agoThey were pretty well done over in the threads for the original posting of the Tesla/SpaceX team's Hyperloop concept on here. I tend to agree with the "it's not that big a deal" sentiment. Usually you're not allowed to go to the toilet for 30min before landing on a commercial jet either. And on a smaller regional jet it's unlikely there's any serious medical help available. Help is only 30min away, and that's assuming you got sick right at the very START of the trip. I think allergic reactions and choking are probably the biggest risks. One to think about, but probably not a reason to write off a game changing transport method! I do think it's funny that the most common question when someone proposes a super efficient super fast transport solution is "How will people go to the toilet?". I guess people who have real trouble can still take the bus or a plane. I'll go before departure, and cross my legs if need be :-)
- vxNsr 13y agoOr do what children do: wear a diaper :P Honestly though, if they would ever expand it to cross country, or like CHI-LA, which would probably be an hour long trip, they better have a break somewhere in Kansas, just because I can't stand to be in such a small enclosed space for very long, trains are great, airplanes, also fine, but something without windows and where I can't stand (if the renders are any indication) is gonna cause problems.
- dojomouse 13y agoI guess that'd be a good way to drive demand for physically isolated Hyperloop seating modules...
- loceng 13y agoI think it could be quite a lovely nap for an hour, or chat with the person next to you, or what not. Just make sure you're not feeling sick beforehand / are in good health..
- RyanZAG 13y agoEvacuation seems a very strange problem. You certainly can't be evacuated in under 30 mins when you're half way across the Atlantic ocean in a plane, or half way between SF and LA in a car. Also, max 30 mins is a very short time for medical evacuations which often run into the 2+ hour range for most transport scenarios. Toilet is a minor worry and if it really is such a big deal to you (and other crazies who can't wait 30 minutes), reducing the passenger capacity of a car by 1/3rd so that a toilet can be added is a very simple and obvious solution that just means your ticket price goes up a bit. The toilet's waste could be emptied automatically at each stop in the station. With how much people bring this issue up however, I'm incredibly surprised we have no toilets in buses! You'd think this was the biggest issue to ever hit public transport... No doubt it was left out of the original spec because nobody even considered it worth including. EDIT: Feels like a debate someone must have had when they first started riding horses. "I'm not going to ride up on that horse, what happens if I need to use the toilet? When I'm just walking I just need to bend down in the bushes! Nobody will ever want to ride horses - consider the human implications of being up in the air!"
- anonymouz 13y ago> With how much people bring this issue up however, I'm incredibly surprised we have no toilets in buses! You don't? Pretty much all long distance buses (many hours ride; very few stops, usually clustered at the beginning and the end of the journey) have had toilets on board. Where you can get away without toilets is public transport in cities, and to some degree overland if there are enough stops (though that can be a problem). With a bus there's also always the option of just asking the driver to stop for a couple of minutes if it's really urgent.
- RyanZAG 13y agoSounds good. When the hyperloop starts being used for many hours long rides, we can add in toilets then. Maybe we can have an option - double ticket price with toilet, or half price without? I have a feeling the double ticket price cars will be empty.
- 13y ago
- reneherse 13y agoWell if people are really worried about the bathroom issue, they can just wear the specially designed, pneumatically sealed "HyperDiaper". Damned if I can't find the link to the appendix of Musk's document where he discussed those specs... Anyway, what's likely more of an issue than either pod or bodily evacuation, is the possibility of motion sickness owing to the lack of a visible steady horizon from inside the capsule (no windows, no transparent aluminum pipes). I suspect this is one of the reasons Musk mentions something about landscape images being displayed on the pod interiors. Some kind of projected artificial horizon, always steady no matter what the orientation of the pod, would likely keep people from getting too loopy. Similarly, the very first subway in NYC (pneumatic, no less) [1] had cars without windows, but the line was only a few hundred feet long, so it's doubtful motion sickness was an issue. [1] http://freetoursbyfoot-nyc.blogspot.com/2013/02/today-in-1870-nycs-first-subway-line.html http://freetoursbyfoot-nyc.blogspot.com/2013/02/today-in-187...
- tptacek 13y agoA bigger human problem with the proposal is, apparently, motion sickness. This isn't an abstract issue, like the diaper requirements. The vehicles in this proposal travel 3x faster than HSR; it thus can't use the exact same path as HSR; for instance, it might need much wider curves, which in the mountains might involve substantially more tunneling. Motion sickness is a pragmatic concern for air travel too; it dictates that you want to run routes above the weather.
- batbomb 13y agoIt's a in a cylinder. On curves, the acceleration would tilt the cars sideways and acceleration would be, from the viewpoint of a rider, down towards the floor, like gravity (like when a plane banks). Unlike a banking plane, you would maintain vertical acceleration down and have even less weird accelerations than you would in that instance. Your head would experience less jerking around than you would in a fast car ride.
- tptacek 13y agoHere's a mathematician's skeptical take on this issue (just CMD-F "jerk").
- dojomouse 13y agoI think jerk could be kept much lower than in an aircraft though - in the hyperloop jerk would be basically 100% deterministic. You could design to keep it within reasonable limits. Sure, there might be minor imperfections in the tube surface, but there's suspension in the air skis to isolate that. I think the main thing needed to prevent motion sickness would be a virtual 'view' with horizon, which isn't hard to create.