5 ms·
TL;DR: it wasn't fulfilling I don't really feel like I ought be a critic of anyone's writing (given that I am not one myself) but college boyfriends, wandering
by untog 13y ago
TL;DR: it wasn't fulfilling
I don't really feel like I ought be a critic of anyone's writing (given that I am not one myself) but college boyfriends, wandering away from the campfire to look at the stars... it seems like the author takes a really long route to get to the point.
- toyg 13y agoYeah, for somebody so bright and talented (she can't help mentioning her spotless cursus honorum), her writing is incredibly dull. I expected useful insights in what Google was doing wrong, losing such acclaimed talent, but... nothing. It's all about her wanting to fuck up for once, after a life of unmitigated success. I guess this means Google is actually doing something right by losing her, lest she fucks up the company just because.
- meowface 13y agoThe writing is pretty dull, but I think that's because of the nature of the situation. She had a vague dissatisfaction with her time at the company, and she tried to walk people through how she gradually discovered what it was she didn't like. The whole point of it is that there wasn't any specific thing about Google she didn't really like; that's what makes it interesting (yet also boring and confusing) to read about.
- benesch 13y agoThat's a silly argument. She's not looking to maliciously screw something up. She's looking to take a risk—to make a decision that, for once, doesn't lead her down the "safe" path to success of good grades, good college, good internship, good job.
- toyg 13y agoFrom TFA: If I wanted to do nothing, I should. If I wanted to fuck up for once, I should. Wanted means conscious will: she craves the freedom to do everything she wants, including fucking up. I guess an account manager at Google doesn't get that sort of freedom, which might be a good thing after all.
- null_ptr 13y agoWe've all read and re-read all the reasons why corporate work can be unfulfilling. In my opinion this short essay wasn't about that, it was about the personal implications of this unfulfillment. Lacking confidence in social interactions, feeling the overburdening need to belong, the realization that it gets harder to steer your life as you age, and the strong will required to turn the wheel.
- haberman 13y agoYou're disappointed because you expected the article to be about X, but it was actually about Y, where both X and Y are words in the article's title. (X=Google, Y=I) Not a great reason to get so unkind.
- toyg 13y agoI probably resent the fact that she leveraged the Google brand in order to make me read lots of words about a perfectly-normal midlife crisis I had no interest in. I clearly put too much trust in the upvoting masses on HN to weed out this sort of stuff. I apologize if her (or anyone's) feelings were hurt by my comments.
- haberman 13y agoI can see where you're coming from. The people who are upvoting it are probably doing so because they can relate to her struggles and her journey. But for you it's a disappointment because you expected insight about Google and this article does not deliver any.
- nostrademons 13y agoThere's a certain irony between your comment and her article. Her article was about how you shouldn't care what other people desire, you should figure out what you desire and go after that. After all, they're not the one living your life. Your comment is about how you read the article because of the Google brand, and that you trusted the upvoting masses on HN to weed this out. Notice the language. "Google brand" - why does the fact that this has the word "Google" in it make you want to read it? "upvoting masses" - you trust the masses of HN more than your own judgment? Perhaps there was something in this article that's worth reading after all, and you glossed over it? (FWIW, it was my upvote that put this article on the front page - it had 2 upvotes on the New page and was 10 minutes old when I saw it, and I liked it, and so gave it the 3rd upvote.)
- toyg 13y ago> you trust the masses of HN more than your own judgment? I trust the HN hivemind to do (most of) the filtering for me, absolutely. Otherwise I wouldn't read HN, I'd just subscribe to the gazillion feeds out there and read through each and every headline. Despite evidence to the contrary (the number of replies I've written in this thread clearly show that I don't have a highly-driven, high-achieving life similar to TFA's author), I can't dedicate an infinite amount of time to reading stuff on the internet. Past that, I trust my own judgement in defining what is actually interesting to me by skimming headlines. Finally, once I've read an article, I'm not doubting my inner-self's ability to judge whether the material is actually interesting or not. This is one of those few times where the two-level filter (HN + me skimming headlines) failed to weed out uninteresting material, and I assign part of the responsibility to the linkbaiting title. I don't think that's unreasonable on my part.
- arcatek 13y agoYou talk about this like if it was easy. I don't think it is. For a single person which choose to resign from his / her benefits to pursue a distant dream, how many will not have this courage ? Of course we're on hn, so there is here a lot more people prepared to this than anywere else but still. I like this kind of post, which reminds us that we should be able to focus on what really motivates us. Of course I'm still pretty young, it could seems obvious to you or others, but if it's in frontpage I assume that I'm not the only one inspired by these posts.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 13y agoIt actually doesn't take all that much courage for a single person with no other responsibilities to quit her job. What's the worst that could happen? She has to get a job again eventually.
- Sirenos 13y agoNote the overloaded use of "courage". It isn't so much the lack of responsibilities as it is overcoming the inner voices that judge your every action much more than any outsider does. But that's just what I think he meant.
- ryanobjc 13y agoThe real bottom line here is that the author doesn't really know why she left Google yet. She is still discovering this. I really strongly believe as a left-coast culture put a lot of emphasis on amazing out of the ordinary experiences as THE ONLY WAY to get "perspective". But the reality is if we learned more about how our brains work, we'd be able to get that sense of perspective in daily life on a regular basis. This is why I'm more impressed by people who meditate every day while maintaining their previous life, over people who attend a yearly meditation retreat but don't do anything different. The hardest part is changing your daily life without going highly radical. Because to make society better, having everyone defect and leave to a monastery is not going to be a good idea. We still need people doing their "normal" jobs and getting things done. I need lunch damnit!
- haberman 13y agoIf it feels like she took too long to get to the point, maybe it's because you missed it. Her point (as I took it) was that she had such a strong habit of living her life entirely in terms of her accomplishments that she was living her life inauthentically without even realizing it. And it took a whole lot of space away from her life just to become aware of it. Not everything can be reduced down to a three-word "TL;DR."
- merryandrew 13y agoAgreed.
- ulisesrmzroche 13y agoIt's the same cliche that gets repeated ad-naseum in HN. "Why I left X to build Y". Yes. YOLO. We know. You're pitching your startup. Is it not ok to offer critique? Taking too long to get to the point is a cardinal sin in writing and it's kinda lame to just label it as "haters gonna hate".
- thedufer 13y agoWas this a pitch for her startup? She named it once, without a link. And it's a name that isn't easy to search for. If this is pitching, she's not very good at it. Edit: It's http://letsmend.com/ http://letsmend.com/ - you can find a domain registration page if you search her name and the name of the startup.
- saiko-chriskun 13y agoYeah I was curious when it was mentioned in the article but I can't even find it by googling :P.
- ulisesrmzroche 13y agoThat's what I got out of it. It's all pretty vague, so maybe it's just a post about how you should eschew the rat-race, go do your own thing, build your startup, and find happiness. Which is even more meh, honestly. Another key of good writing is to leave your reader with just one point in mind, one that never occurred to them before.
- StandardFuture 13y agoWhat point?
- libria 13y agoAgreed, the conclusion was somewhat nebulous to me (and I'm probably a bit dense as well) but the tl;dr I got was that the author left to "[build] a start up that is risky and deeply personal (Mend)". We all have to subsist, and how she chooses to do it is a large part of how many of us will define her identity. I feel like the authenticity she refers to is very much a 1st world problem (though I'm sure she's worked hard for her success). Most of us work to pay the bills and don't feel like charlatans if our industry doesn't happen to be our life's dream if we even have one. BTW, anyone have a link to this authentic startup she's referring to?
- Daniel_Newby 13y ago> I feel like the authenticity she refers to is very much a 1st world problem ... Ancient writers of many cultures wrote about living well and how to move towards it. The cultivation of the spirit is neither expensive nor new.
- pnathan 13y agoTry reading 1800s literature. It'll awaken a certain appreciation for modern writing in you. But the point is that there's a certain box smart people today in the 1975-1990 generation are put in. * Get good grades * Go to college * Get job at company (alternatively, start your own company. That's pretty trendy today.) * Find spouse * Buy house * Have kids ...etc. Why bother? That's a good question. Why not simply drop out and go surfing? What's the point of the job? What's the point of having the money to buy stuff? Why use your intelligence, this intelligence that so many people have complimented, in the same way every other person like you has been doing? It's a variant on the age old question - who are you, really? Why bother being you as you are now? Maybe that explains it better. But the article really resonated with me.
- decasteve 13y ago"We must do away with the absolutely specious notion that everybody has to earn a living. It is a fact today that one in ten thousand of us can make a technological breakthrough capable of supporting all the rest. The youth of today are absolutely right in recognizing this nonsense of earning a living. We keep inventing jobs because of this false idea that everybody has to be employed at some kind of drudgery because, according to Malthusian-Darwinian theory, he must justify his right to exist. So we have inspectors of inspectors and people making instruments for inspectors to inspect inspectors. The true business of people should be to go back to school and think about whatever it was they were thinking about before somebody came along and told them they had to earn a living." --Bucky Fuller
- pnathan 13y agoInteresting quote. Where is it from? Do you agree that we need to do more school? Lots of people indicate that much of American school really isn't about learning to think, it's more about passing the class, fitting in, mixed in with a heap of credentialism.
- ramchip 13y agoI don't see what's specifically American about that. It's far worse in Asia, for one. I imagine it may have been better in Fuller's younger days.
- vph 13y agoYour "TL;DR" is well deserved.
- altoz 13y agoHere's why I think it's such a frustrating article... It's ultimately an immature sentiment expressed by an immature person enclosed in a veneer of maturity. The subtle thing here is that she's blaming being at Google for her lack of fulfillment when a mature person would look inward first. I'd bet dollars to donuts that a similar thing happened to her ex-boyfriend. No rationale, vague sentiments, very little actual introspection, except what might make her happy. Real maturity is about character, finding how to be a better person and not what the world can do for you. That said, I'm sure she'll go far in life. I sincerely hope she lerans to improve herself as a person in order that she can be a fulfilled human being.
- ricardobeat 13y agoChanging environments can help immensely with changing your state of mind. I didn't get the feeling that she blames Google; she blames being at a place in life that doesn't fulfill her, coincidentally she works at Google. It's pretty clear from the text that she has goals in mind other than a good 9-5 job.
- altoz 13y agoThat's why I said "being at Google" not Google itself. Again, she's looking at things from a very immature perspective, that of life owing her a fulfilling career without actually doing what she's claiming to be doing. Introspecting.
- ricardobeat 13y agoI'm really curious, how did you get that impression? I see her realizing she is unhappy, that the reasons keeping her in place weren't relevant (status, etc), and taking action to correct that. We don't even know the details of what she decided to do, or her goals, to make any judgements.
- Keyframe 13y agoAutomaton rising - that's what I would call it and that's there was a long route to the point. She was waking up, reliving her rising through writing.
- khalidmbajwa 13y agoThat's because she wanted you to get a feel of the process she went through. The frustrations that she felt and how exactly the AHA moment happened. Even the 'Staring at the stars' story you scoffed at has a message. When you are stuck and having trouble figuring things out, stop for a moment, get a change of scenery, that just might do the trick. Clearing out your head like this, as cliched as it sounds, is a remarkably effective way of figuring out the tangled web of choices ahead of you. I guess you just got bored and missed the point entirely. Pity !