3 ms·
>the first is not. If you are not doing research efficiently, then you should not be doing research. My point, and perhaps I could have been clearer, is that f
by epistasis 13y ago
>the first is not. If you are not doing research efficiently, then you should not be doing research.
My point, and perhaps I could have been clearer, is that funding is shrinking, while the quality of proposals is increasing or getting better. Funding rates for grants are now in the 5-10% rate, which means that even excellent, efficient, outstanding labs that are leaders in their fields can starve due to random chance.
It ha nothing to do with being entitled to research money. It has everything to do with the US spending research money efficiently and not capriciously. A research lab is not like a startup in that the intial time investment is quite long, and cutting that off inappropriately is wasteful. Additionally, it is incredibly inefficient to spend most of a researchers time churn through good proposal after good proposal, and no let them do research.
US science is shrinking dramatically right now, and rebuilding it will be a slow and long process, an if we lose the crown to China in the interim, the US may never be the bastion it once was.
- dnautics 13y agoI disagree. The quality of proposals is getting worse. There's a horrifying cycle of cronyism, lack of managerial skill that is going into science. People are promoted into research positions based on the impact factor of the journals they publish in, not the quality of their work. High impact factor journals publish things that are more likely to be scandalous than solid. The most important aspects of scientific success (versus excellence) is "were you your PI's golden child", and "just how lucky did you get"?... etc. etc. etc. These trends are reflected in the proposals that I see getting pitched. 1) Who cares if "we" "lose the crown" to china? 2) I'm not worried about china, anyways, the scientific culture there is miserable and dastardly, and deeply entangled with the cultural value of "face" (I'm east asian, I think this applies to Korea and Japan, and troubling - increasingly in the US - see Hellinga, for example) and values Feynman's "extra integrity" less. If you claim it has nothing to do with being entitled to money, then perhaps you should rephrase. Cutting and pasting what you said, "First, the researcher has run out of funding ... the first is a travesty" Which implies that a researcher running out of funding is a travesty. In the general case, as implied by your use of the indefinite article, that is not true.
- OvidNaso 13y agoDo you claim that 90% of proposals are not worthy of funding? Because it it was not an extremely high number, we could significantly increase spending and still only fund the best. You stated: " It can be debated if grant reviewers are actually doing a good job (versus being a whitewashed version of cronyism)" If they are already evaluating research and researchers the way the rest of profession does, I don't see how cutting funds would help. It would not drive better proposal writing. And if the cronies are already getting their money anyway, the added batch might have a higher percent of high quality. I understand the desire to punish the undeserving of your profession, but when weighed against the advancement of science (even if artificially inefficient)...I don't care. And cutting funding won't make a significant dent in the problems you describe.
- dnautics 13y agoI'd claim that a lion's share of the top 10% of proposals are not worthy of funding. The best proposals are probably usually rated in the 70-80% range, depending on the funding agency (NSF, NIH, DOE), but most of it is utter embarassment. "when weighed against the advancement of science (even if artificially inefficient)...I don't care." Well, no, we're talking about funding here. What if the structure of funding was causing a net regression in the advancement of science? Is it a safe assumption that funding directly correlates to advancement? "And cutting funding won't make a significant dent in the problems you describe." If I had my druthers, I'd cut science funding to zero (there would be other ways to raise money for science - endowments, 501(c)(3)s, foundations, bake sales, etc. Keep in mind Peter Mitchell validated the chemiosmotic effect, a cornerstone of basic biochemistry and cell biology, by launching his own completely independent science research foundation) That would make a significant dent in the problems I describe.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoWhat about the medical funding for stuff like cancer, where the vast bulk is in the public sector? Also, while I agree with Theodore Sturgeon that 90% of everything is crap, in science it is especially hard to tell what that 90% is going to be in advance, so I think it is better to overfund and then concentrate on the improvement of quality in the review process to filter out the crap.