4 ms·
Does anyone really take unscreened "review" sites like Yelp seriously? I never even bother looking at them.
by ams6110 13y ago
Does anyone really take unscreened "review" sites like Yelp seriously? I never even bother looking at them.
- jrockway 13y agoYes, some people take them seriously. What do you use instead?
- ams6110 13y agoThat's the trouble. Consumer reviews are just not credible to me. They are anecdotes. I find the entire concept to be unworkable.
- smtddr 13y agoAnecdotes maybe, but supposedly all anecdotes from the same source. Instead of stuff that's like "my friend" or "I know lots of people that...", which is different from person to person, a bunch of people reviewing the exact same location is a bit more accurate. Also, after awhile you can usually separate the quality comments from the noise. Kinda like we all do on HN or any other forum. I think I can mostly tell when someone is just pushing an agenda/cherry-picking facts to support a particular claim, versus a comment giving a mostly objective review. Particularly when they point at facts & actual events rather than vague feelings.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIf I am in an unfamiliar town, sometimes I use "sites like Yelp". I definitely take reviews with a grain of salt. Sometimes it [might be] better than nothing.
- pseut 13y ago"I don't normally like [style of restaurant] but this one was fantastic!" is usually informative but not as intended.
- smsm42 13y agoI do. Usually reviews work pretty well, especially if you actually read them and don't just look at stars. Fake ones usually are easy to spot, and for sites with a lot of reviews there's usually a pattern. Of course, the system can be and is abused, and you have to take it with a gain of salt, but it's helpful, especially if you don't know much about the place or the area.
- Killah911 13y agoI work with Dentists in their online marketing. Guess what: nothing, in our measurement, has quite and impact on their bottom line and new customer acquisition as Yelp & maybe a little bit of Google Plus Reviews. So, the answer to your question from a quantitative point of view would be HELL YEAH THEY DO!
- ben1040 13y agoI find Yelp reviews to be pretty unreliable, because you giving "5 stars" for a single specific business is not necessarily a predictor of me doing the same. You and I are different people with different tastes. I've gone to restaurants based on their 5-star Yelp average, and ended up not enjoying my experience. I've gone to places with 2 and 3 star averages ("Yelpers say it sucks, but I'll still take a chance"), and loved them. I wish Yelp had a prediction/discovery engine for restaurants along the lines of what Netflix has for movies.
- pbreit 13y agoI do. I think there's lots of good information on Yelp.