11 ms·
Reshaping New York
- Game_Ender 13y agoAnother great web piece by the New York Times. The other two I know of are Snow Fall [1] and the Riding the New Silk Road [2]. 1 - http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall/ http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall/ 2 - http://www.nytimes.com/newsgraphics/2013/07/21/silk-road/ http://www.nytimes.com/newsgraphics/2013/07/21/silk-road/
- nhebb 13y agoI didn't like this one as much as Snow Fall and Silk Road. The before and after image presentations would be better side by side instead of in series form. I had to toggle back and forth. Then, midway through the article, the page froze and I wasn't able to scroll up or down.
- wallflower 13y agoAbout the making of Snow Fall: http://source.mozillaopennews.org/en-US/articles/how-we-made-snow-fall/ http://source.mozillaopennews.org/en-US/articles/how-we-made... See also: http://www.interactivenarratives.org http://www.interactivenarratives.org
- y0ink 13y agoThank you for posting Snow Fall. Simply stunning, both the story itself and how superbly presented it was.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoIt's so obvious he is preparing and advertising himself to run for president. And it's about time. He has something few other presidents have. Success in both Private and Public office.
- sbarre 13y agoDoes he need to go through a stint in the senate/congress first, or could he run directly for nomination? I don't mean "need" as in legal, but just as a path to it? Has anyone ever done that before? Run for president without being a governor or a senator/congressman? (Asking as a Canadian who isn't super familiar with historical presidential politics in the US).
- dbarlett 13y agoYes, although they usually quit early. 2012: Herman Cain (businessman) 2008: Alan Keyes (author/diplomat) 2004: Wesley Clark (Army General), Al Sharpton (reverend/civil rights activist)
- teddyh 13y agoI'm thinking that most simply don't have the intelligence connections to endure the blackmail game.
- endianswap 13y agoAccording to a Wikipedia article, it would be likely be in his best interest to start somewhere bigger: Every President of the United States has served as either: Vice President of the United States a U.S. Senator a Congressman a Governor of a state a Cabinet Secretary a General of the United States Army
- ams6110 13y agoMayor of NYC is probably a better executive experience that many (most?) state governorships. Bloomberg isn't my cup of tea, politically, but he's certainly qualified to run if he decides to do it.
- mikeash 13y agoFor example, as mayor of NYC, Bloomberg governs about three times as many people as Bill Clinton did as governor of Arkansas.
- potatolicious 13y agoI don't think it'll work. He's neither Republican nor Democrat (and in fact has been both at one point or another) - even someone as well-known as Bloomberg I don't think can capture the Presidency as an independent candidate. Not to mention his stance on things is too complicated for modern American politics. He's socially liberal (supports heavy social programs, large-scale public education, gay rights, pro-choice), but also largely anti-civil liberties (stop and frisk, crackdowns on demonstrations, pro-surveillance). He's the exact sort of candidate New Yorkers vote for, but I don't think the rest of the country would go for it.
- hyperbovine 13y agoI've thought for a long time that the US political system will someday realign along the lines of urban vs. everything else. The "tough on crime / livable cities / pro environment / social programs" platform resonates with a huge swath of urban America, be it in Pittsburgh, Dallas, Detroit or New York. Bloomberg could well be our first urban candidate for president, and I think he would have broad appeal beyond NYC.
- simonebrunozzi 13y agoI agree. He's a remarkable man. Not sure he's powerful enough to win the race for US President.
- protomyth 13y agoHe won't make it out of the primaries for either party. The state setup at the start works against him, as he has received a lot of "the crazy NYC Mayor banning something else" pieces.
- epc 13y agoBloomberg will never run for President. He's too protective of his private life to subject himself to the circus. Plus he's too conservative to run as a Democrat, and he's a communist compared to the current national GOP.
- sebkomianos 13y agoI am neither from nor do I live in New York so I can't talk about validity and range but that was a very enjoyable presentation of the city.
- wallflower 13y agoOT: Kudos to the interactive team. I think it would be an interesting job to work for the NYTimes interactive/mobile/media lab just based on the work they have been producing. I hope that they will continue to push the envelope and start to open source more or blog more about the process (which is the interesting part) of creating.
- dpeck 13y agoGood news, they do http://chartsnthings.tumblr.com/ http://chartsnthings.tumblr.com/, though tends to come in bursts and looks like they haven't put up much since July.
- everyone 13y agoAnyone else find this really buggy/broken + A horribly non-intuitive awkward way of presenting information even if it worked?
- dmra 13y agoThe UX of this site is pretty bad. There's nothing to tell you what you should click on or what clicking on those elements do. I found myself clicking on random things, ending up in places that weren't related to what I clicked on, and not sure how to get back.
- everyone 13y agoMy first reaction was to scroll down the page, as the scroll bar was indicating there was more below. Apparently I was not supposed to do this as it basically flips out. This is your typical 'fancy flash website' syndrome
- burntsushi 13y agoScrolling worked just fine for me. It moved between the pieces of the visualization quite smoothly.
- everyone 13y agoOn websites it is not customary or to be expected for scrolling to bring you to essentially another page. This thing is a slideshow fitting badly into webpage format.
- burntsushi 13y ago...... I don't contest that ...... You said it "flipped out", which I took to mean that it didn't function at all. I replied saying that it worked for me. That's it.
- 13y ago
- HaloZero 13y agoWhat are residents of NYC opinion on Bloomberg? Is this reshaping good or worse for the city? It seems that he won his most recent re-election but barely, from what i know he is a socially liberal, environmentally friendly, fiscal conservative.
- belowlightsblue 13y agoThe NYT is doing alot of coverage about him with the elections coming up and all: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/nyregion/what-new-yorkers-think-of-mayor-bloomberg.html?hp&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/nyregion/what-new-yorkers-... I think jobs and the economy matter most to people and since Bloomberg was mayor during the 2008 recession, that's going to make him seem worse than he might have though he may not have been able to affect the worst of the economical situation in any way. In the story linked to above, it says less than half of surveyed think that crime has improved under BLoomberg. That is just plain absurd no matter how you look at the stats...Bloomberg's (arguably too strong) law policies have made the city safer than it was in 2002. IT just shows how hard it is for people to remember what things were like a decade ago, due to nostalgia, etc. Also you say he won his re-election "just barely" but that's because he bent the term limit rules for what most people considered in an illegitimate way
- busterarm 13y agoI remember very well what New York was like 10 years ago. And 20 and 30. I can't say that Bloomberg's policies have made the city any safer than it was 10 years ago. That is, I can't say that his policies are responsible for the reduction in (certain type of) crime. (Some types of crime are actually on the rise in NY). What I can say is that violent crime statistics have been in severe decline nationally since the end of the 1970s. New York pretty much follows the trendline exactly and doesn't seem remarkably exceptional in this. Certain neighborhoods are still high crime. Yes, I would say that 99% of Manhattan is about as safe as Disneyland, but the policing has been especially disproportionate between the use and effectiveness of things like Stop & Frisks, constant & disruptive patrol car drills crosstown during rush hour, and "Show of Force" demonstrations of the ESU in full body armor and M4 rifles stationed outside popular tourist areas. Some see these things as safety and security and others see them as waste and symbols of a state abusing its power. A lot of the revitalization efforts for areas of the city have been in the works since the 1950s (pay attention in NY to how much is named after or dedicated to Robert Moses). Case in point, the Times Square Redevelopment Project (though that was completed under Giuliani). When I was a child growing up in this neighborhood, there were porn theaters, street prostitutes, hustlers, con men and pickpockets everywhere. People got mugged in my elevator or at the payphone on my corner regularly. Nearly 80% of the storefronts in Midtown were vacant. My mom was a corporate real estate broker in the 70s and had a listing on 57th street and 5th avenue going for $5/sqft (in what was later the Playboy Enterprises building). Let that figure sink in for a second. I'm not nostalgic for those times, but back then we also had a bit more community than now. I actually knew by name the homeless people and the street hustlers in my neighborhood. My mom took care of most of them in her nursing work at St. Luke's Roosevelt. That sense is totally gone. Nightlife and entertainment in the city is _dead_ (we'll see how the Space nightclub does when it opens though). You used to regularly have people playing music on the street without too much bother. I remember a lot more people just being in the street and friendly (for NY standards) all the time. Everything is much more conservative and elitist than it used to be, but that's just as much times changing and culture moving on as Bloomberg is lucky to be in the right place at the right time. I get really passionate about this topic and am being a bit rambly, but two years ago I left New York City. I'm likely returning next year, but I had to get away and it's no longer somewhere I could imagine living the rest of my life. It's just not that much fun a place to live anymore. Almost every NY-native I know in my age group either can't stand to live there anymore or has been priced out. Most of my friends have moved away or want to. We're going to places like Portland and New Orleans...or moving to Europe.
- pulakm 13y agoNew York Times has been killing it with their visualizations. It would have been nice to have 2013 pictures overlaid on the 2003 pictures though, to really understand what the changes were. In some pictures, like Times Square, I had to flip back and forth a couple of times and still wasn't sure what exactly the changes were (can't see any obvious bike lane in that image, which is supposedly what it's representing).
- potatolicious 13y agoA lot of the photos are aerial, I'd imagine it'd be nigh impossible to get them lined up so perfectly to overlay each other, but it would be very nice indeed. On the Times Square picture: the entirety of Broadway (the slanted street on the far right) has been closed to traffic and is now entirely a pedestrian mall. It's not just Times Square, large stretches of Broadway has been reconfigured for bikes and pedestrians. Interesting sidenote: they've been digging up Broadway in Times Square lately to put actual sidewalk in its place. My guess is that Bloomberg is doing this to cement his legacy and throw up additional barriers in case future mayors want to re-automobile-ize Times Square.
- pulakm 13y agoFair point. Perhaps some labels on the images, at least, would make it clear what they were trying to point out. The Times Square picture in particular was confusing because I saw the pedestrian mall, but thought that the point was about bike lanes which a pedestrian mall isn't.
- RDeckard 13y agoCan anyone count how many times "Mr. Bloomberg" is mentioned across all the slides? I lost count...
- johnpmayer 13y agoThis shouldn't be down voted. It's significant that it's not "Mayor Bloomberg". "Title Lastname" is the format that it used to refer to candidates.
- danso 13y agoNo, NYT style is to use Mr. and Ms. on second reference when using last names. This applies to even the President. It's a policy that makes sense when you consider the variety of titles (even just political) and the lack of corresponding well known abbreviations http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/world/middleeast/pressure-by-us-failed-to-sway-egypts-leaders.html?hp http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/world/middleeast/pressure-...
- krschultz 13y agoThat's the NYT editorial style. If I remember correctly, it was notable that they did not use Mr. for Osama Bin Laden's obituary. Short of that, you are getting a Mr.
- 001sky 13y agoWoud be interesting to see the backstory on how they got access to the data/subsamples. The visuals are well done, but the story is sort of interesting in terms of how its edited. It neglects any mention, for example, of the role of Finance in the building boom. And by extension, glosses over the Financial crisis spawned (under his tenure, in new york) by real-estate investment instruments and the general bubble-icous tendencies that follow from "free money". NYC basically skims the profits of wall street both directly (retail&real estate sails subsidized by incomes from the financial sector) and indirectly through double taxation of corporation (financial lagest sector) and city income taxes. So, there are a lot of grandmother's withs withered pensions and decimated savings outside of New York that are basically subsidizing all of this. Just worth thinking about.
- tryitnow 13y agoPretty good work. My thoughts on the visualization: Criticisms: 1) The moving around over the city skyline is slick and fun, but I doubt it conveys much useful information. I'd rather see the growth of new building over time. In visualization, motion should convey some meaning. Here it doesn't seem to. 2) It's important for visualizations to convey both anecdotal information (achieved through the before/after snapshots). But it's also important to convey quantitative information, magnitude and directions of changes. I don't detect anything like that here, even though there is quantitative information embedded in the text (e.g. "Population is up 2,000, but 600 poor people have left"). Numbers are good, visualizations that artfully convey the magnitude and direction of relevant numbers are even better. It's rare to have news narrative that can't be improved by conveying the quantities involved. Things they did right: 1) The before/after snapshots are useful and pack a punch. 2) Inclusive. The visualization includes a a variety of changes and doesn't get sucked down a narrowly focused rabbit hole. 3) Simplicity. It's not a data dump. The visualization does a decent job of conveying single themes without including unnecessary extra. It may go too far with this though (see criticism #2 above). Overall, I look forward to more visualizations like this from NYT and other media outlets.
- busterarm 13y agoI'm with you that it was mostly flashy without useful information. I actually hadn't really noticed just how much new construction had been going on in my neighborhood. I would have loved if the NYT provided something that I could actually interact with and form some conclusions of my own. It seems like good journalism has taken a back seat to flashy visualizations -- with most of these stories there hasn't really been much of a story. If they provided something like that, I would actually actively look at their site again, rather than follow the occasional linkbait there.
- benackles 13y agoHow do you qualify "good journalism"? Data visualization is a powerful tool for story telling and the NYT has been at the forefront of this revolution in news. "Good journalism" is telling a story accurately and in a format that people can understand. Your claim that "good journalism has taken a back seat to flashy visualizations" seems to denigrate the work of data scientists such as Mike Bostock who are transforming news in a very meaningful way. How does data visualization qualify as "link bait" in the derogatory sense of the word? [1] http://bost.ocks.org/mike/ http://bost.ocks.org/mike/
- tkiley 13y agoIt's interesting to contrast the evolution of NYC with the (lack of) evolution of SF. This article cites a net increase of 170,000 housing units from 2000 to 2010. I can't find an exact comparison for SF, but it looks like SF has less than 25k net increase from 2000 to 2012.
- aboodman 13y agoWell, given that NYC is ~10x the population of SF, SF is doing pretty well!
- gwern 13y agoSF is 1/10th the population of NYC in part because of those restrictions, so the comparison is more apt than it seems...
- guelo 13y agoNYC is also 10 times bigger land-wise, 470 sq miles compared to 47.
- nerfhammer 13y agoSF is also twice the size of manhattan
- mbesto 13y agoI'm trying to figure out where this discussion is going, haha. Let me simplify it - NYC continues to build up, SF doesn't.
- adviceadam 13y agoSan Francisco is currently in a building boom. Over the next 25 years, there is going to be approximately 92,000 more housing units. The population of San Francisco should reach 1 million by then. Here are some links: http://www.theatlanticcities.com/jobs-and-economy/2012/12/san-franciscos-surprising-building-boom/4213/ http://www.theatlanticcities.com/jobs-and-economy/2012/12/sa... http://www.spur.org/publications/library/article/san-francisco-boom-back http://www.spur.org/publications/library/article/san-francis... http://sf.streetsblog.org/2013/07/19/plan-bay-area-passes-in-a-room-full-of-paranoid-conservative-activists/ http://sf.streetsblog.org/2013/07/19/plan-bay-area-passes-in...
- sbierwagen 13y agoThat sure didn't like my 1200x1920 monitor. It also appears to depend on a codec that chromium on ubuntu doesn't have.
- rorrr2 13y agoBloomberg bloomberg bloomberg bloomberg. Sorry, but most of these changes, are the result of private businesses and taxpayers. Saying "you can now build a skyscraper in area X" is hardly an amazing achievement.
- krschultz 13y agoNegotiating the rezoning process was largely a political triumph. Same for the bike lanes, parks, and redevelopment of public land. Bloomberg has had a very visible impact on the city - but even more importantly most of his reforms are a ratchet. Plenty of politicians implement a program for a time, they can later be undone. Bloomberg has done a bunch things that can't be undone. There is no way to put the bike share program or more park land back in the bottle now.
- paddy_m 13y agoIt is an accomplishment when no one else has had the ability or interest in doing it.
- o0-0o 13y agoSeriously? Including the Freedom tower in this map is D-I-S-G-R-A-C-E-F-U-L. Shame on the NY Slimes.
- sirsar 13y agoHow is the camera panning done? It works on Windows Chrome but not Ubuntu or Mint Chromium.
- acqq 13y agoIt uses video tag and .mp4
- shalmanese 13y agoIronically, the mobile view is a MUCH more usable and navigable look at the data. The technical restrictions of mobile reined in a lot of the excess flashiness.
- CervezaPorFavor 13y agoWhy does the "Time Square, 2013" picture have markers for Hello Kitty, Elmo, Mario and Spider-man?
- tzury 13y agoThe central park remain the same! That's a reservation de-facto.