4 ms·
Whereas, that was long and detailed, I am still not entirely sure what security and stability risks it is supposed to address.
by im3w1l 13y ago
Whereas, that was long and detailed, I am still not entirely sure what security and stability risks it is supposed to address.
- kijeda 13y agoThe IAB put out a statement “Dotless Domains Considered Harmful” that explains some of the risks if ICANN changed the rules to allow them. As it stands, they were already prohibited and this resolution reaffirms that. http://www.iab.org/documents/correspondence-reports-documents/2013-2/iab-statement-dotless-domains-considered-harmful/ http://www.iab.org/documents/correspondence-reports-document...
- SimHacker 13y agoBut I thought "* Considered Harmful" was considered harmful?
- itafroma 13y ago> As it stands, they were already prohibited and this resolution reaffirms that. Slight nitpick: they were prohibited only without prior ICANN approval (second whereas). Companies like Google attempted to get that approval (Google wanted "search"), which spurred ICANN into making a decision about what circumstances they would allow them. This decision essentially states ICANN won't approve any dotless domains.
- derefr 13y agoPresumably to stop someone from registering a new top-level TLD "reports", putting an A record on it, and then your attempt to access an intranet site http://reports/ http://reports/ suddenly going somewhere you didn't expect.
- thecodeore 13y agoif your internal systems where set up correctly that would not happen,. your local DNS should override any external records. If I added an A record for google.com to bing.com's ip address on my internal dns no one would see google.com
- derefr 13y agoIn some intranets, users might be relying on mDNS (Bonjour) or WINS (SMB/CIFS) name resolution, rather than static DNS; both of those mechanisms, by default, get resolved at lower-priority than DNS (because they're quite slow, so you don't want your computer checking them first every time), so if there's a real DNS entry it'll get used.
- X-Istence 13y agomDNS is actually in the list FIRST in at least Ubuntu, check /etc/nsswitch.conf.
- derefr 13y agoLinux's mDNS support is split into two parts--mDNS presence (which uses cached/recently broadcast-announced values), and mDNS resolution (which doesn't.) If you don't have a name cached, the first part won't know about it, so you'll hit DNS lookup before failing back to full mDNS resolution. Basically, it becomes a race condition of when you last brought the machine up.
- marshray 13y agoUntil your user takes the company laptop to the coffee shop.
- threeseed 13y agoOr another common scenario. User takes laptop home and forgets to enable the company VPN.
- meric 13y agoThere's also the case when someone is googling "restaurants" and there happened to be a malicious http://restaurants http://restaurants. website.
- testing12341234 13y agoThe SSAC report on dotless domains[0] has information on possible security related risks that might occur for these types of domains. Additionally, this informational Network Working Group draft has information on the status of existing dotless domains, without expressing an opinion on security or stability[1] [0] - http://www.icann.org/en/news/public-comment/sac053-dotless-domains-24aug12-en.htm http://www.icann.org/en/news/public-comment/sac053-dotless-d... [1] - http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-hoffine-already-dotless-02 http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-hoffine-already-dotless-02
- paraxisi 13y agoPage 7 of the report gets into the details a bit, from what I understand things like localhost where it's assumed that it's internal, and other assumptions made previously with regards to MX records/CAs.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- walid 13y agoI don't find it necessary for security. One way of safeguarding security across the board is to use reserved words like "intranet" for the intranet (duh) and "localhost" for the same machine. THE END
- bitexploder 13y agoThat alone won't address all of the concerns. Another study they did, related just to their gTLD stuff, was to see which dotless name queries get leaked to the root servers. This name collision report is quite interesting and addresses the question of which names are probably in common use: http://www.icann.org/en/about/staff/security/ssr/name-collision-02aug13-en.pdf http://www.icann.org/en/about/staff/security/ssr/name-collis... Anyhow, our research and testing (I am one of authors of one of the studies mentioned in the posted article) found that the issues found with SAC 053 have the potential to be much more wide spread. There is also a scary problem called universal XSS. There were no real smoking gun security issues, so you can make a pretty decent argument about the security impact not being too great (we had many such debates internally), but we are talking a core Internet system. The namespace collision issue is huge.
- walid 13y agoI see what you mean regarding namespace collision, but if we always set a standard based on the lowest common denominator we'll end up being stuck with practices that were followed because there was no reason not to. As for the universal XSS, this can be solved at the browser and page level. First the gTLD as any other level should be explicitly declared in the script URL from the open page and second the browser blocks all the rest.
- bitexploder 13y agoHi. I am one of the authors of (http://www.icann.org/en/groups/ssac/documents/dotless-domain-study-29jul13-en.pdf http://www.icann.org/en/groups/ssac/documents/dotless-domain...) this report mentioned in there. Our study included a much broader scope than SAC 053 mentioned in the article. The idea was to take a very broad, holistic, view of the key infrastructure and systems on the Internet and determine the risks dotless names may pose. How would behavior be different with dotless names, etc. Our report basically answers your question, I think, so I won't answer it here :)
- marshray 13y agoHow are you actually going to prevent someone from returning an A record? (possibly as part of a targeted attack)
- A1kmm 13y agoI suspect ICANN are thinking about the long game - if, as a matter of policy, there are no valid dotless domains, then developers of user agent software are unlikely to attempt to resolve them (other than using a search list or hosts file) in the first place.
- marshray 13y agoBut current clients all handle single label names via normal DNS resolution. This is how many office PCs find their file servers. People are not going to give up the habit of using single label names on the LAN just so ICANN can start collecting rent on that namespace.