3 ms·
As opposed to the responsible, bread-winner man who is left to pay for "her" credit cards .. WTF is one supposed to glean from this gross generalization? How a
by mahmud 17y ago
As opposed to the responsible, bread-winner man who is left to pay for "her" credit cards ..
WTF is one supposed to glean from this gross generalization? How about "In recession, consumerist people who have been programmed by marketing superpowers and learned shopping binges, outside their means, splurge as if addicted. However, we only sampled the female population, in one country, and only 700 of them (the ones free to answer our poll questions, i.e. not juggling work, life and family.) Therefore our 'study' aught to serve as a blanket indictment of all women on the planet."
Do these morons realize the entire third-world is pretty much matriarchal and women are responsible for feeding not only their children and themselves, but their men and adults in their family who are often out of work, sick, not to mention several generations of elders?
Please do not let your experience with Fifth Avenue divas color your perception of all women.
- axod 17y ago>>"WTF is one supposed to glean from this gross generalization?" It's a survey :/ Data...
- mahmud 17y agoStatistics is an effective tool for reinforcing stereotypes. Just because someone took the time to conduct a survey does not mean we should accept it blindly. This particular "survey" lacks the male control group :-) The article references a second survey, conducted in 2006 which proves my point: "The problem is likely not confined to women. A 2006 study in the United States found 6 percent of women have it so bad they are labeled compulsive buyers, but so are 5.5 percent of men." 0.5% difference between the compulsive shopping habits of men and women, smaller than any margin of error for a survey of this type. Yet women's "deviant" behavior merits a whole article.
- CodeMage 17y agoCould you give some examples of contemporary matriarchal societies? Unless you're using a non-standard definition of "matriarchal", I believe you are either mistaken or misintepreting facts.
- mahmud 17y agoYou are right, my definition is non-standard and has an economic implication. In societies with large and extended families in one household, the women are often responsible for feeding everyone, even if the men are tasked with the generation of income. To use an extreme example of a patriarchal society, in the arab world, even if women are largely out of the workforce, they're still responsible for the household budget and they often generate secondary income on the side. It's very common for them to save money, shaving pennies from the grocery shopping and saving it for a rainy day. Hardly the binge-shopping desperate housewives alluded to in that article. Also missing from the article is what women are buying. If you're left to feed a whole family, your purchasing habits are hardly the same as someone who has to worry about his cigarettes and a few other personal necessities ;-) Read up on the work of Muhammad Yunus of Grameen Bank to understand this better.