6 ms·
Assange's seldom mentioned manifesto[1] talks about the goal of making secrecy impossible by making the secret systems either completely disconnected from the r
by nl 13y ago
Assange's seldom mentioned manifesto[1] talks about the goal of making secrecy impossible by making the secret systems either completely disconnected from the real world, or so liable to leaking that they are no longer secret.
It's difficult imagining that goal being completely achieved, but it is interesting how closely the Snowden story matched Assange's thoughts.
Note that Assange's writing is pretty.. umm.. dense. It is worth reading the commentary at [2] at the same time.
This analysis is excellent:
[Assange] decides, instead, that the most effective way to attack this kind of organization would be to make “leaks” a fundamental part of the conspiracy’s information environment.... the idea is that increasing the porousness of the conspiracy’s information system will impede its functioning, that the conspiracy will turn against itself in self-defense, clamping down on its own information flows in ways that will then impede its own cognitive function. You destroy the conspiracy, in other words, by making it so paranoid of itself that it can no longer conspire
[1] http://cryptome.org/0002/ja-conspiracies.pdf http://cryptome.org/0002/ja-conspiracies.pdf
[2] http://zunguzungu.wordpress.com/2010/11/29/julian-assange-and-the-computer-conspiracy-%E2%80%9Cto-destroy-this-invisible-government%E2%80%9D/ http://zunguzungu.wordpress.com/2010/11/29/julian-assange-an...
- cstross 13y agoYup. I note that Assange, aged 42, is a Gen-Xer. (I left him out of the essay because (a) mentioning his name would invite derailing discussion of other personality-related issues, and (b) his being an X-er would obscure the key message in the closing paragraphs.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- igravious 13y agoOh I see. Gotcha. Thx.
- in2liberty 13y agoFirst, I'm a big fan... but: I'm struggling with why you don't open arms embrace the Gen-X / Gen Y's actual attitude towards a government that can grab any of them and shame them into compliance is the moral voting decision. There is an actual synthesis available, the state collects all kinds of data, but it cannot be used against its citizens. Using any that data to help solve ANY domestic crime becomes the greater crime - it is traitorous for any public employee to do so. We have a long legal history or fruit of the poisoned tree, Gen X / Gen Y can simply ensure PRISM and its ilk - we save and extend that, and harshly punish a few civil servants. Lesson taught. Its similar to the militarization of the police. Why not expect and cheer Gen Y / Gen X to say out loud, "we don't care if more cops die because they have only a vest"? Why not expect and cheer, the total destruction of the bureaucracy your work pillories? Why valorize the near criminal firm behavior the 40 year s and a watch created? I'm Gen X and I'm totally comfy with the idea of a state that has to rebuild itself around 1M Snowdens ready to heroically crush state malfeasance for $, fame, or patriotism. It dawns on me you aren't a fan of Nassim Taleb. I prefer my sci-fi writers to be dedicated libertarians. So maybe, if you aren't, don't publicize it.
- unalone 13y agoThe government is not a monolithic entity. The evils of intrusive surveillance doesn't make, say, social programs, or economic regulation, evil just because they're other large government programs. Libertarianism is great if you're already wealthy; it's... problematic... if you're starting off from a position of relatively little power. > I prefer my sci-fi writers to be dedicated libertarians. So maybe, if you aren't, don't publicize it. This is astonishingly condescending of you.
- in2liberty 13y agoI'm not insisting we throw out the state because of PRISM. It seems like you basically agree with my question of CSTROSS. The last bit, was just me letting him know, putting his politics in front of his art means some won't make it to his art. I like keanu reeves bc he doesn't let me know what he thinks. I'm weird that way.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoThere is a third way: stop conspiring, then there's nothing to leak. In other words, Assange is conceiving an environment that asymmetrically favors transparent power over clandestine. Which probably also means good, or at least normative power. (Bad things can be normative eg: segregation, but most bad things are not.)
- EthanHeilman 13y ago>an environment that asymmetrically favors transparent power over clandestine This asymmetry only exists as organisations scale. Keep your Clandestine organisations small and your transparent organisations big. But there are two problems with making Clandestine organisations small: 1. it is dangerous: smaller Clandestine organisations would by necessary concentrate more power in fewer hands, combined with secrecy that actually works and you have the perfect breeding ground for a coup, 2. it is politically sensitive: managers in organisations grow in status as they hire more people below them/lose status as they lose people below them, any budget or size cuts will be used as a way to past the blame after the next intelligence failure (consider how the NSA/CIA would've reacted to the post-9-11 review if Clinton had reduced their size to 0.1%).
- ianterrell 13y ago> smaller Clandestine organisations would by necessary [sic] concentrate more power in fewer hands I think that "by necessity" is not true here. A smaller organization can not do as much as a larger organization. Ok, a handful of people could stage a coup. Then what? They still need bodies for tax collecting, law enforcement, jailers for the secret prisons, whatever. Those people need information to do their jobs, which increases the circle size, etc, and we're back where we started. Assange's insight into clandestine organizations as information networks that can be disrupted is profound. You get the choice between large, effective, and open; or small, ineffective, and clandestine.
- EthanHeilman 13y ago>A smaller organization can not do as much as a larger organization. See 'The Mythical Man Month', SpaceX vs other aerospace companies or the writings of R. V. Jones on the advantages of keeping intelligence agencies small. >Ok, a handful of people could stage a coup. Then what? I agree staging a coup is not the same as running a government. Not sure what you point here is. >You get the choice between large, effective, and open; or small, ineffective, and clandestine. The current choice is between: large, ineffective and semi-transparent or large, even more ineffective and semi-opaque. I agree with Assange on this. The danger is that we could get small, effective and truly-opaque, but it is unlikely to happen due to political concerns.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> the idea is that increasing the porousness of the conspiracy’s information system will impede its functioning, that the conspiracy will turn against itself in self-defense, clamping down on its own information flows in ways that will then impede its own cognitive function. Consider this in that light: "NSA to cut system administrators by 90 percent to limit data access" http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/08/09/us-usa-security-nsa-leaks-idUSBRE97801020130809 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/08/09/us-usa-security-ns...
- hedgie13 13y ago> "that the conspiracy will turn against itself in self-defense, clamping down on its own information flows in ways that will then impede its own cognitive function. You destroy the conspiracy, in other words, by making it so paranoid of itself that it can no longer conspire" This was probably one of the big reasons USSR fell apart. The attempt to make everything secret made discussing real problems very difficult. This may work.... Of course, the other serious question if nation states as we know can exist without conspiracies and if we would be better without them.
- malandrew 13y agoTotes. The recent news that they would be reducing their outside sysadmin workforce by 90% I think may be the most interesting example of shooting themselves in the foot. Look at it this way: One sysadmin leaves with a lot of information and then leaks it to the press. In an effort to plug that hole, you announce that at some point in the future you are going to eliminate 90% of the people who did the job of that person. Now everyone who is currently doing this job looks around and thinks to themselves "Gee, I'm probably going to lose my job in a couple of months. I have two choices: try to apply for a direct employment role in the agency I was contracting for or I can choose not to utilize my top secret clearance and change jobs." Now I would bet that those 90% comprise thousands of people, some of which may have the same technical prowess as Snowden and who may also be as disillusioned with the corruption of the current system they are whoring themselves out to. I can only imagine that this reduction in force will lead to a lot of new juicy details of wrongdoing being leaked.