6 ms·
Murder is intentional killing, this guy appears to have only said "I'm going to drive really fast" not "I'm going to run over that particular woman". There is
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
Murder is intentional killing, this guy appears to have only said "I'm going to drive really fast" not "I'm going to run over that particular woman".
There is a difference between shooting your neighbour because you disagree over loud music and standing in your garden and firing up to celebrate the superbowl win and the bullet comes down killing your neighbour. You should do time for both yes, but they are different crimes.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe mens rea requirement for common law murder could be satisfied by reckless indifference to risk to human life (among other things) as well as intent to kill; this is reflected in most murder statutes in US jurisdictions.
- icpmacdo 13y agoWhich seems a little ridiculous in this situation.
- jrockway 13y agoYou think it's ridiculous that it's considered reckless to drive twice the speed limit? If he was driving 40mph, it would be an accident. At 80mph, it's murder. He made the premeditated decision to kill when he threw everything he knew about driving safely out the window and put the pedal to the metal. It's that simple.
- pfisch 13y agoHe was only 18 years old and he was speeding. Murder is a bit of a stretch.
- jrockway 13y agoActions have consequences. 18 year-olds can understand that. This wasn't a freeway where he was going 80 in a 75 zone. It was a normal road with intersections and many other road users going the speed limit or below. It's simply idiotic to drive 80 there, and it's very easy to accidentally kill someone when you're going that fast. (You have no time to react.) Driver's Ed is 6 months of you being told this every single day. He knew it was dangerous. He did it anyway. He killed someone. That's murder. (Personally, I think 40mph is way too high of a speed limit for roads like this. 20mph would be a much better. Car/pedestrian collisions are much more survivable at that speed, and cyclists can move in and out of traffic freely. But 80mph is just fucking insane.)
- jlgreco 13y agoHe's not saying that actions don't have consequences. He isn't saying that speeding wasn't idiotic. He isn't saying that he was never provided with the opportunity to know better. He is saying that murder is a stretch.
- James_Duval 13y agoIf you acknowledge that actions have consequences, it follows that if you commit an action which has a high chance of causing a certain outcome (in this case, death), you are responsible for the outcome. In this case, I would say that the responsibility which this teenager has can only be called "murder".
- tptacek 13y agoAgain, it's only a stretch if you don't know about depraved-indifference murder. This isn't a weird loophole; it comes from common law.
- lutusp 13y ago> He was only 18 years old and he was speeding. Murder is a bit of a stretch. The reason it became murder is because he was found to be boasting about his speeding behavior online, i.e. it wasn't episodic or unintended. He meant to go fast, he planned to go fast, and an 18-year-old is an adult with adult responsibilities -- whether or not he is ready for them.
- te 13y agoIf youth reduces culpability, the driving age is too low.
- rosser 13y agoNo, it's not. Knowingly engaging in behavior that risky — driving faster than any posted speed limit in the entire United States of America on residential streets is egregiously risky — and thereby causing someone's death is textbook murder. EDIT: phrasing.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoI think it's ridiculous that he gets charged with murder and other people who commit similar offences, which by nothing more than luck happen not to kill people, don't. If intent's what matters then you've got to be consistent in that regard. Otherwise it's not justice, it's just doing someone because they were unlucky. -shrug- Not that I'd particularly mind if that was resolved in favour of providing reasonably long prison sentences to people who commit truly awful driving offences. But either way.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I think it's ridiculous that he gets charged with murder and other people who commit similar offences, which by nothing more than luck happen not to kill people, don't. I, on the other hand, don't think its ridiculous that homicide is, in fact, an element of the offense of murder. > If intent's what matters then you've got to be consistent in that regard. Intent isn't "what matters" in the sense of "the only thing that matters". Both the mental state and prohibited substantive act/result of a crime are parts of "what matters."
- 6d0debc071 13y ago> I, on the other hand, don't think its ridiculous that homicide is, in fact, an element of the offense of murder. > Intent isn't "what matters" in the sense of "the only thing that matters". Both the mental state and prohibited substantive act/result of a crime are parts of "what matters." I suspect we might just have an irreconcilable difference of framework in that respect: I view the purpose of law to be to minimise the maximise the public good while causing the minimum restriction of freedoms. That being inherently a balancing act, freedom/security, the exact value of which is responsible for a lot of the problems with the actual application of law. In that framework whether someone's acts resulted in death is dramatically less important than whether they were likely to, and whether the person who did it is likely to do so again unless restrained. (That their acts actually did lead to the death is evidence in favour of that class of act being more likely to lead to deaths than it would be without that bit of evidence, so in that sense it matters.) Beyond that, whether someone dies or not, the drink driver and the speeder who didn't kill anyone but committed equally dangerous offences - they're all guilty of murder in the sense that matters to me. To borrow the way of phrasing it from the Christians: They've all already killed people in their hearts. It's just luck that no-one's dead for them, and luck's not a property of people, it's a property of limited knowledge; you can't rely on it. In so far as we have knowledge, under such a system, if you lock the guy who actually killed people up, the rest should be locked up too.
- dragonwriter 13y agoIn what way? The article doesn't specify the details of either the Tweets or the driving record that justified the decision to charge it as murder, so are you arguing: 1. It is per se ridiculous to consider driving at 40mph above (or double) the speed limit as an act involving reckless indifference to human life, regardless of the evidence supporting that, or 2. Evidence in the form of driving records and pre-offense statements by the driver could never suffice to support the consideration of such driving as involving reckless indifference to human life, or 3. That you have additional information about the specifics that is not in the article, and that information leads you to to conclusion that in this specific case, reckless indifference in unsupportable, or 4. It is per se ridiculous to consider reckless indifference sufficient mental state for murder, or 5. Something else. Simply asserting that it is ridiculous is not an argument, and its the kind of contention that really needs an argument.
- bdcravens 13y agoIf the cyclists had gotten out of the way, could he have been charged with Attempted Murder?
- DannyBee 13y agoNo, but only because in most jurisdictions, attempted murder requires the specific intent to kill, while as others have mentioned, murder requires malice (which is not the same). In general, attempt requires specific intent, even if the attempted crime does not. Murder is one of the few "common law crimes" where this matters, because most of them are already specific intent crimes anyway.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago"they are different crimes." Indeed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manslaughter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manslaughter
- DannyBee 13y agoIt's actually saner in most cases to look at it like this (at least in common law terms): Killing -> misdemeanor manslaughter OR criminal negligence OR no malice -> involuntary manslaughter Killing -> with malice -> no mitigation/justification/excuse -> murder Killing -> with malice -> mitigation -> voluntary manslaughter Killing -> justification/excuse -> nothing I'm skipping felony murder for the sake of this post :)
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I'm skipping felony murder for the sake of this post You aren't really. You refer to malice. The four forms of malice in common law murder are: 1. Intent to kill, 2. Intent to cause grievous bodily harm, 3. Acting with reckless indifference to human life, 4. Commission of a felony
- DannyBee 13y agoI did though, because there are other things, like it has to be a dangerous felony, or a normal felony committed in a dangerous way, and it has to be during the commission of the felony, and .... You are right that it is malice, but i didn't explain that part.
- awjr 13y agoThink your analogy is wrong. He had a gun and knew there was a chance a bullet would come down and hit somebody. He still fired the shot. There really is no excuse for speeding. I think the figure of 30% of fatal car crashes are down to speeding.
- cgag 13y agoI agree, I think we should be charging all speeders with attempted murder.
- awjr 13y agoI know you are joking, but I do think there is a certain argument to be made that should it be proven that the reason the crash fatality happened was due to speeding, then I don't see why somebody should not be done for a form of murder. Speed limits are there for a reason.
- PieSquared 13y agoAlthough I agree with the general sentiment, I think I have to disagree with the sentence, "There really is no excuse for speeding." In particular, speeding is a norm in many places in the United States. If you are not going five to ten miles above the speed limit, people are likely to be actively passing you or driving too close behind you. I suspect it's safer to go five miles above the speed limit than have people constantly passing you because you're going slower than everyone else. (That said... I do wish speed limits were limits, and everyone followed them perfectly.)
- tptacek 13y agoCan we all stay clear on the fact that he was doing 80mph on residential streets? That's not ticketable-speeding; it's criminal.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lutusp 13y ago> Murder is intentional killing ... No, that's not how murder is defined. Murder can include the result of a reckless indifference to the safety of others. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/murder http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/murder Quote: "The precise definition of murder varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Under the Common Law, or law made by courts, murder was the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought. The term malice aforethought did not necessarily mean that the killer planned or premeditated on the killing, or that he or she felt malice toward the victim. Generally, malice aforethought referred to a level of intent or recklessness that separated murder from other killings and warranted stiffer punishment." I draw your attention to "to a level of intent or recklessness", evidence for which which the defendant provided to the prosecution by boasting about his speeding behavior online.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI see the point, but it seems like recklessness is a loophole you could swing corporate manslaughter to murder.
- dragonwriter 13y agoIts not a loophole, and I don't see making much death-resulting-from-corporate-malfeasance chargeable as murder as an undesirable effect.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 13y agoWould a reasonable person have foreseen the possibility that driving 80mph down a residential street might kill someone? Yes. It's easy to kill someone with a car even when driving the speed limit. Far easier when treating a residential street like a dragway. Did the person consciously choose to drive 80? Yes. The gas pedal didn't get stuck. They didn't have a micro-stroke or go into diabetic shock. We know that they consciously chose to drive unsafely because they bragged about it. Reasonably foreseeable outcome. Conscious, deliberate choice. Ergo: recklessness.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]