4 ms·
OpenID’s Tipping Point
- csbrooks 18y agoSo if you're making a small site as a side project, is it worth integrating Openid? I'm assuming here you can't get away with the StackOverflow approach of requiring all users to use it, so you still have to manage passwords for some users, anyway. As an end-user, I think I'm at the point where I'd prefer to use something like OpenID for new accounts. (I wasn't using it for HN, and I lost my password about a month ago, so now I have this account linked to gmail.)
- mtrichardson 18y agoDepends on how easily it is to integrate into your project. For instance, for Django applications, there's django-openid-auth (see http://blogs.gnome.org/jamesh/2009/04/14/django-openid-auth/ http://blogs.gnome.org/jamesh/2009/04/14/django-openid-auth/ and https://launchpad.net/django-openid-auth https://launchpad.net/django-openid-auth ) and Simon Willison is almost ready with his new plugin at http://github.com/simonw/django-openid/tree/master http://github.com/simonw/django-openid/tree/master . These plugins are just drop in and go for the most part. When you have tools like this, seems worthwhile to do so.
- wmf 18y agoI think OpenID is great for small sites because you probably can't afford to do password security correctly so using OpenID is probably easier and more secure.
- evgen 18y agoSince both OpenID and secure logins for small sites are but a plugin away for the frameworks that such sites will inevitably use this assertion just does not hold water. Given the fact that the two are roughly equivalent for the server provider (albeit with an increased number of potential failure points for the OpenID system due to reliance upon third-parties for authentication) the determining factor should probably be usability. On this point OpenID fails miserably.
- wvenable 18y agoThere isn't enough utility for me to bother with OpenID. This should really be integrated into browsers rather than some crazy web service scheme.
- theBobMcCormick 18y agoWith Mozilla Weave, it (supposedly) will be integrated into the browser http://labs.mozilla.com/2009/05/identity-in-the-browser/ http://labs.mozilla.com/2009/05/identity-in-the-browser/
- jasonkester 18y agoOpenID needs to go away so that something good can replace it. It's a terrible implentation of a good idea, and the longer it limps along, alienating people, the harder it will be to get its replacement accepted. OpenID's contribution to the Single Signon Quest has been to prove beyond a doubt that nobody wants to remember a URL for their username. Yes, we all know it's the same amount of typing as an email address, but at the end of the day, people are trained to type their email repeatedly and are thus good at it (and remember it). So please, OpenID, hurry up go away. The thing that takes your place will probably be pretty good because of you.
- TomOfTTB 18y agoI'm not sure I agree with you. I don't deny OpenID's problems. But to me the issue is whether OpenID is completely unredeemable. Which I think it's far from being. If nothing else it already has two things going for it. The first is positive press and the second is a legion of fans (some of which border on sycophants) So the question is wouldn't it be better to fix the problems in this spec rather than make another. I think so. In fact I think trying to create a new spec can be a disaster. If you need proof of why this is ture look at all the people who continue to use RSS over Atom because of a standards fight that happened years ago.
- jasonkester 18y agoYou're right that redesigning it from scratch will probably make it even more complicated. I guess that's a point against. The tough part of modifying the existing implementation will be the URLs-as-Usernames thing. They seem set on that and it just isn't flying.
- jmillikin 18y agoOpenID allows you to use an email as an ID, assuming your email provider supports it. e: see http://eaut.org/example/ http://eaut.org/example/ to find out if your email provider supports OpenID resolution.
- indiejade 18y agoOpenID is an okay thing to have around as an alternate "backup" type of sign-in option. It seems to be most useful for people whose set default MO is to use the same username and password for most of their online accounts; typical users. But OpenID does have its issues. Obviously trusting one provider with all of your username and password credentials isn't the best idea. I think, however, that having an OpenID URL is a good idea. But the better idea is to give new users their own unique ID on your site, and to allow them the option to link it to some other previously established online ID. Not by default. In fact, information auditing doesn't really work without the rule of three: which (at some level) includes the separation of power from control.
- vicaya 18y agoUbiquitous browser support so that the sign on interface is uniform and that phishing is impossible would go a long way for OpenID.