6 ms·
> If users buy a Windows Phone expecting to have a YouTube app, when one is not legally available, it is their problem. The problem is when you extrapolate thi
by wslh 13y ago
> If users buy a Windows Phone expecting to have a YouTube app, when one is not legally available, it is their problem.
The problem is when you extrapolate this reasoning:
- Do you want support for nvidia cards on Linux?
- Do you want to connect to a windows share from Linux or OSX?
- Do you want to print to a windows share from Linux or OSX?
And so on. I think Microsoft is more open than Google in a broader sense. My mantra is: you can't reverse engineer the cloud.
- beagle3 13y agoYour arguments are nonsensical: - Yes, I do want to view SilverLight videos on Linux. But I can't. Because Microsoft won't let me (or Xamarin or Ximian) implement the DRM parts. - Yes, I do check that an nvidia card is supported on Linux before I buy it; That's why, for example, I avoid AMD, and it IS my problem if I buy an AMD card for which there is no good driver on Linux > I think Microsoft is more open than Google in a broader sense. My mantra is: you can't reverse engineer the cloud. The implied argument (Microsoft is more open because you CAN reverse engineer their products) is complete bullsh*t. Evidence: http://www.advogato.org/article/101.html http://www.advogato.org/article/101.html
- wslh 13y agoYour arguments are nonsensical I am neither trying to write a formal proof here nor defending Microsoft in all their battles. I tried to argue against pervasive double standards: we love free software but Google business is not harmed publishing Chrome source code like Microsoft business is publishing the code of Microsoft Windows. Google is harmed if everyone install AdBlock (you can read something along these lines in their investor reports) or connects to their search engine without showing any ad.
- jorgecastillo 13y agoEven Apple has published plenty of open source code (non GUI stuff). Microsoft doesn't make significant open source contributions, because they don't get open source or because the only thing that makes them valuable is their huge desktop market share.
- wslh 13y agoI am not defending Microsoft actions (even if they make some few open source contributions). I just said that Google Achilles' heel is in another place and because we have a bias in favor of free software we are not seeing the big picture clearly.
- jorgecastillo 13y agoI have no bias in favor of free software. I do think open source is awesome. I do think open source UNIX-like systems are awesome. I do think open source programming languages are awesome. With all this said I use whatever software I like and can afford. I don't think open source software is inherently better, it is inherently more awesome but not necessarily better. My favorite desktop OSes are OpenBSD, OS X & Linux, I am only using Linux currently. My favorite GUIs are Cocoa & KDE.
- kvb 13y agoEven at Microsoft there are several open source projects (though maybe fewer than you'd hope for a company their size). See F# for one compelling (IMO) example. And it's not the same thing, but Microsoft publishes way more research than the other tech giants.
- mncolinlee 13y ago- Samba and Wine were both created using reverse engineering. Microsoft frequently made changes that broke both products. Don't get me started on Microsoft's PPTP and Kerberos. - Nvidia produced their own closed drivers on Linux. How does that involve Microsoft? Are you really making the argument that if your application doesn't encrypt its interfaces, then you're open?
- asterix9 13y agoOne difference is that Microsoft and Nvidia are considered evil and are derided for it and they don't pretend that SMB or graphics drivers are open. While Google has a 'do no evil' official policy which many folks seem to think they comply with. Similarly, with regards to openness.
- moutarde 13y agoGoogle has obligations (both legal and moral) to both the content providers of YouTube and to the organisations who buy adverts on it. In order to 'not be evil' they have to take actions that respect these obligations. Microsoft's original version of the app either: a) deprived YouTube partners of their share of the revenue from adversing b) caused advertisers to be charged for adverts that were not shown The download feature also posed a problem to content providers who only hold a streaming licence to their content. If it didn't respect YouTube's no mobile flag (I'm unsure about this but it seems possible) it would also have caused issues for content providers who only held non-mobile streaming rights. Microsoft now has a new version of the software that supposedly corrects these problems and is whining about openness and anti-trust. But why should Google now trust them? They treated not only Google, but also their partners and advertisers, like dirt. Now they want special treatment. It's like walking into someone's shop, insulting both their sales staff and their customers, then next week coming back and asking for discount. How is Google being evil by imposing restrictions on a known bad actor in order to protect their partners?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- baddox 13y ago> - Do you want support for nvidia cards on Linux? Yes, but if I install Linux expecting to have support for nvidia cards, it is my problem. > - Do you want to connect to a windows share from Linux or OSX? Yes, but if I install Linux or OS X expecting to connect to a Windows share, it is my problem. > - Do you want to print to a windows share from Linux or OSX? Yes, but if I install Linux or OS X expecting to print to a windows share, it is my problem. There is no problem when you extrapolate this reasoning.
- wslh 13y agoNo, it's not only your problem. If Google is a monopoly and this is probed in some court (EU/US) the issue will crystallize in another way. Meanwhile, it can be analyzed in an ethical way and some people think that the problem extends beyond you.
- Mikeb85 13y agoThis has to be a joke.... Microsoft has tried their best to prevent Linux from working or even existing... The fact that Linux hackers are smarter than them doesn't make them open...