4 ms·
Is anyone aware of a well-articulated reasoning published by Kickstarter for this decision? It really does seem quite silly to arbitrarily disallow GMOs as some
by angersock 13y ago
Is anyone aware of a well-articulated reasoning published by Kickstarter for this decision? It really does seem quite silly to arbitrarily disallow GMOs as something not worth funding, especially given that we've been doing it in one form or another for millenia.
EDIT: Clarified by a response, apparently they're only disallowing GMO rewards, not projects.
- dnautics 13y agoIt's their choice... It's one out of ten-odd prohibitions on their website. In the end people working on GMOs are free to use other crowdfunders or roll their own (like I will). Kick starter isn't an entitlement
- zhemao 13y agoThat number is a bit disingenuous, since some of the individual bullet points are pretty catch-all. For instance, No bath, beauty, and cosmetic products; electronic surveillance equipment; eyewear (sunglasses, prescription glasses, and others); firearms, weapons, knives, weapon accessories, and replicas of weapons; medical, health, safety, and personal care products; or infomercial-type products. That's a lot of mostly unrelated things.
- dnautics 13y agoIndeed. I meant for 10 to look large, not small. So, yes, kickstarter has its own reasons for banning various things; and just throw another one onto the heap. They don't bother explaining why these are banned, so why the double standard with GMOs? Actually - all of these things have in common that they're regulated and I think kickstarter doesn't want to run afoul of penalties from regulatory breach or incur regulatory costs or burdens. To a certain degree (region dependent, use-dependent, etc) GMOs are the same way. Arabidopsis is a weed, but you can eat it. Anecdotally, it's quite tasty.
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoBut they are not disallowing GMO projects. You just can't give out any GMO rewards. I still think it is a stupid addition to the rules but I just wanted to make sure we understood what they are limiting.
- jrkelly 13y agoAs the article points out, the main driver of all the big kickstarter campaigns is a reward. So in large part this decision prevents GMO work from being funded.