5 ms·
Why Female Soldiers Were Finally Added to Call of Duty's Multiplayer
- scoofy 13y ago"Our previous engine would not handle that. The way memory worked in the previous engine, it never would have been able to do that." Where is bullshit man when you need him. I don't believe this for a second. Great CoD puff piece HN.
- protomyth 13y agoI posted it because I could not figure out how their reasoning actually made any technical sense. I suspect it is a total BS job, but maybe there is an actual technical reason.
- Zergy 13y agoThere is. To maximize sales the COD engine is designed for the weakest system for it to run on. The Xbox 360 has half a gig or ram and that is shared with the OS, memory is an extremely tight commodity. It is quite reasonable to think that another mesh, texture map, and additional sounds clips will simply not fit in the 300ish megs that XBox developers have to deal with. Of course that can be designed around by having an engine that smart about pulling things in and out of memory. But that's hard to do especially when you have to release a game every year. I should point out I'm talking about multiplayer mainly. There isn't a technical reason for the single player other than it is a lot of extra work.
- lnanek2 13y agoIt's pretty common in game development to up against the wall in terms of texture memory or frame rate performance or way past your limits and needing to cut things before release. It's very believable they didn't have the spare memory for in depth customizable characters. It's much more efficient for the computer to have more characters to render that look the same. Maybe they had the exact same geometry for all players and the exact same textures and just a different label over their heads, or had only a color swap texture difference, etc.. If adding customization meant each player had to have separate data and that data didn't fit in fast caches, it could have broken the frame rate requirements. Writing games, I've spent months on optimizations to do things like draw as many objects with as few data/state/rendering changes as possible to reach frame rate requirements for a smooth game.
- wetmore 13y agoPerhaps the skeleton/rigging/animation is different for female characters.
- INTPenis 13y agoTotal bullshit because they later say that the female characters are the same size in the hit boxes as the male characters. In other words they could have skipped custom character creation and just had static male and female avatars using the exact same engine.
- dragontamer 13y agoFemale avatars existed back in Tribes, or even Unreal Tournament. I'm not a CoD player, but I'm frankly surprised that there wasn't an option. I thought this sort of stuff was a _given_ today. Guess I was wrong. Anyway, this may be a "puff piece", but anyone with half-a-brain can figure out how much of a jackass move this was on --EDIT-- Activision's part. Why did it take so long to create a female avatar? Hell, Halo gave a nod to female players by making female spartans inside of their famous armor. (ie: Nicole-458). You don't even _need_ texture mods to officially play as a female in a lot of these games, lol.
- bluetidepro 13y agoMass Effect is another example of an EA game that has always had the option for Male or Female, and on top of that, LGBT friendly.
- freehunter 13y agoI haven't read the article because Kotaku is blocked at work, but if you're referring to the CoD game mentioned in the title, it's Activision, not EA.
- dragontamer 13y agoFixed. Thanks for the tip.
- thezilch 13y agoUnreal and Quake 2, before those, had female avatars. Now that I think about it, Counter-Strike did and still(?) does not.
- angersock 13y agoAs did Half-Life, Thief, the original Rainbow Six, and Jurassic Park Trespasser. This is not some magical new technology. Note also that the above examples encompass both keyframe and skeletal animation--there's no technical limitation of any meaningful sort here. What's more interesting is the fact that sales seemed quite dapper despite the lack of this feature, which does give somewhat inconvenient evidence towards the idea that the depiction of women in games is not actually a big deal.
- john_i 13y agoI can understand if this was the case for the single player campaign. Where there might be limitations in scripting the story for a female as well as a male character. But for multiplayer, the explanation is a bit more difficult to swallow. I'm not a game designer, nor am I CoD player, but wouldn't a texture pack be able to easily solve this issue?
- schreiaj 13y agoSure, which is more to load into memory which is extremely limited... the exact problem they cite.
- joshdotsmith 13y agoI really like how there was no attempt made to fact check the interviewee. But then I guess if we started acting like real journalists we wouldn't get all these great inside scoops.
- lucb1e 13y agoCall of Duty was originally based on the Quake 3 engine. In Quake 3 there were female characters. Now they're telling us it was not technically possible before? I have my doubts.
- infogulch 13y agoMemory issues because of customizability is a red herring. You've never been able to choose what your player looks like in COD. You play as one of the several pre-defined characters from your team, chosen randomly when you spawn. (Edit: I guess there's a difference for players using a sniper rifle.) From that perspective, I don't see any reason why there couldn't have been a female character. ... except for callouts. In BO2, there are ~5 different models for each team, all male. There are about a dozen different types of callouts that models make in response to different actions, like reloading, killing an enemy, or seeing an enemy. There are also 3-4 different versions of each callout for each team. Since the models are homogenous, the versions of callouts are chosen at random and have no bearing on which model you're currently using. If there were female models the number of callouts that would need to be loaded in memory would double because you couldn't reuse the male callouts for females.
- ryusage 13y agoOkay, so this is a dumb article, but it's not quite as idiotic as it sounds. Kotaku makes it sound like the devs are saying female characters are just somehow more complex technically than male characters, and they literally didn't have the technology before to create them. That's just obviously flat-out stupid. What they're actually saying here is that their previous engine wasn't able to support custom characters, and so they never thought to try and make characters who would be representative of their full audience. When they made personalizing the character a focus, they realized they needed females to be an option, and that prompted them to add it. It's still obviously sexist that it never even occurred to them there should maybe be a female in the game. There's no reason they couldn't have put one or two as options in the game before. But they never actually said it was impossible to do it. That's Kotaku's own not-very-generous interpretation.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brimanning 13y agoKotaku makes it sound like the devs are saying female characters are just somehow more complex technically than male characters, and they literally didn't have the technology before to create them. What they're really saying is that it would be twice as much work with two different modeling and movement algorithms running instead of a single, streamlined approach. It's not impossible, but considering the amount of work developers already have to do and the graphics the games are running, it was left out in favor of a smoother, finer experience. What you noted about creating an engine to support custom characters means that those developers took the time to go back, refactor existing code and optimize around different multiple different models running simultaneously while keeping a smooth experience.
- ryusage 13y agoEh, I don't think they said that at all, and that doesn't make sense anyway. They would need to add an extra 3D model or two obviously, so sure, that's a bit more work, but in the big scheme of things it's very straightforward. By "modeling and movement" algorithms, I assume you mean animations, and I don't see any reason at all that they couldn't just use the same skeleton as the male characters, which negates the need for new animation work. I'm not sure what the point of your second statement actually is, but I disagree with that too lol. I feel like you're making the easy parts sound very difficult and then completely trivializing the part that's actually a lot of work.
- The_D 13y agoKotaku is link bait shitposting. Don't click for the sake of a clean internets. Thank you, the entire internet.