4 ms·
It's kind of funny, I find myself doing the opposite--when I see a completely meaningless title on the HN front page, I assume it's actually something much more
by derefr 13y ago
It's kind of funny, I find myself doing the opposite--when I see a completely meaningless title on the HN front page, I assume it's actually something much more interesting and a mod de-editorialized it into meaninglessness, so I click through to see what it is.
- Drakim 13y agoBut that's not a road we want to walk down, imagine if every title was meaningless! The point of titles should be to give an informing mini-summary about the topic.
- derefr 13y agoIt wouldn't be that bad--being on the front page is itself a prequalification, and being on the front page despite having a meaningless title means it's on the front page for reasons other than being linkbait. Removing titles altogether might make things more meritocratic, actually (if a little more painful for the people who only click things if they're about a certain topic.)
- brador 13y agoIt's trust. Over time you learn to trust the HN headlines for accuracy. Editorialization leads to overhyping junk articles for clicks.
- Supermighty 13y agoI didn't realize it until just now, but I ignore the meaningless titles. I come to HN to catch up on the news first, and save the fluff later. It would be nice if every title accurately described what it was about so I could make better decisions about what to read now, what to read later, and what to pass over.