5 ms·
The problem with those services is that the amount of girls just looking for sex is tiny compared to the amount of guys just looking for sex.
by olalonde 13y ago
The problem with those services is that the amount of girls just looking for sex is tiny compared to the amount of guys just looking for sex.
- jseliger 13y agoThat's true in general, but, as I wrote here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6214504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6214504 , the founders presumably know that—and know that plenty of women are looking for sex with the right guy. The interesting question to me is how Pure will solve that problem.
- sdoowpilihp 13y agoThe real question is how does one define "the right guy", and are the requirements to define it for the average women something that can be satisfied within a 24 hour time constraint?
- jseliger 13y agoExactly! That's the hard the problem I presume they are going to solve, or try to solve.
- nawitus 13y agoEasy: limit the supply of men but not women (e.g. let almost all women register, but only let the top x% of the men register). There's pretty much no gender-neutral solution (which is "ironic" since the service is supported by a feminist). EDIT: The app appears to allow requests only if two profiles have been mutually selected as attractive, which would indicate that men need to spam those attractive buttons quite a lot..
- jiggy2011 13y agoQuestion is, how do you decide on the top % of men without falling back onto "shallow" factors like classical good looks or income?
- JeremyMorgan 13y agoYou don't.
- bilbo0s 13y agoAnd therein lies the age old problem of online dating. Why would a rich, good looking guy need a "hook up" service? Tom Brady's mistress, or mistresses, are likely to look a lot better than any of the women on Pure. There is even a joke about it I hear a lot when speaking to online dating startup guys... "...What do statistics tell us about the rich, good looking guys on an online dating service? That they are liars..."
- baddox 13y ago> And therein lies the age old problem of online dating. Why would a rich, good looking guy need a "hook up" service? And yet, online dating sites do okay, don't they?
- xxhere 13y agoI think that for short-term encounters "rich" is a proxy for sanity. It means they have jobs that bring in good money; which means they need to be integrated to the society to some degree and wouldn't have too much time to be focused on stalking someone. It also means that they have something important to lose and have an active interest in not freaking a woman out. "educated" could be a substitute for "rich" - and the educated, good looking, but not very rich people would be ideal for dating sites.
- potatolicious 13y agoIt'll back onto "shallow" factors anyways. Even on "traditional" dating sites the vast, vast, vast majority of messaging occurs based almost entirely on looks. Websites that market themselves as soulmate-finding services haven't solved this, I highly doubt a hookup site is going to do it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jkscm 13y agoHow would limiting the the supply of men increase the chance of women finding the "right" one? I also don't understand how a non-gender-neutral solution is ironic. I can hardly think of any solution to a gender problem that is "neutral". You don't fix gender imbalance with gender neutral methods. Actually forbidding men to spam copy and paste messages to every woman could elevate the experience for women.
- dubfan 13y agoThere's a site that is trying this (not letting men message women until the woman gives permission). I tried it out but there were only about 20 female profiles in my area (a large coastal metro) and most of them were inactive. The ones who were active were unattractive and their profiles were all of the "I'm an easy-going girl who loves to laugh" variety. I'm not sure if that's a result of the approach or just a marketing problem on the part of that site in particular.
- Dewie 13y ago> The interesting question to me is how Pure will solve that problem. Maybe by using something like OKCupid data to extrapolate what an attractive man is in general in the context of online hookups/dating.
- mtgx 13y agoAll of these services all seem to promote some sexy girl on their home page or ads, or whatever - so of course men will rush to it in droves. If they don't want to fall in the same trap, how about promoting it as a service for both genders, but with a man in the ad, or at the very least a couple.
- jiggy2011 13y ago> All of these services all seem to promote some sexy girl on their home page or ads, or whatever - so of course men will rush to it in droves. Actually the latest marketing tactic seems to be the extremely classy "Fuck ugly women in your area".
- bobwaycott 13y agoThis service promotes itself as a service for both genders. The ad features a heterosexual couple hooking up with another woman. Both of the women appear rather normal, neither magazine-style 'sexy' (no fake breasts, no size 0, no crazy makeup), but both are certainly sensual. It even sensualizes the man. I'd say their ad is rather spot-on.
- beachstartup 13y agothis isn't true. it's 2013. women are having lots of sex, and they're on the internet. deal with it. it's just that all the women are banging the same 10-20% of guys. the rest of the guys are not getting laid, except on rare occasion, or inside of relationships. sex is a pareto distributed market. long-term relationships / marriage are not.
- xxhere 13y agowoman here. this rings true. i have a female friend who did online dating, with the specific purpose of finding short term encounters. i would say she is an 8 on every guy's scale, a 10 on most. she went after very physically fit and intelligent guys, messaged them, never got a reply back.
- samstave 13y agoSo what type of guy did she end up hooking up with? If the fit/intelligent profiles she contacted didnt reply... What were her results?
- xxhere 13y ago@samstave, I can't seem to reply to you, but to answer: nobody.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoI'm not buying that a female "9" (on average apparently) went to a popular dating site, messaged a bunch of guys (even 9s themselves) and received no response. There's something else at play here that you aren't telling us or don't know. There are lots of possible reasons no one messaged her back: 1) She messaged only a few people (small sample size) 2) She messaged only people with older, inactive profiles 3) Her information lacked a picture 4) Her profile lacked key information 5) Her picture(s) were bad etc
- bilbo0s 13y agoYou forgot the most likely explanation: 6) All of the profiles for guys who are 9s that she messaged on those dating sites were fake. If a guy is a 9 or a 10, he rarely needs a dating site.