4 ms·
Well, it kind of sucks that your options in the US are gentrification or Detroitification. It's part of the price we pay for not having the social safety nets a
by bitwize 13y ago
Well, it kind of sucks that your options in the US are gentrification or Detroitification. It's part of the price we pay for not having the social safety nets and public investment in infrastructure that other countries have.
- btrautsc 13y agoI'm curious to what you think the other options are? Gentrification doesn't mean pushing all residents and culture out of a place - but it typically flows to areas with the least resistance (and location/ proximity). So if you have an economically desolate area, and gentrification is at one end of the scale with 'detroitification' at the other - what is in the middle?
- auctiontheory 13y agoThe whole point of this (and a hundred other) articles is that the US is losing its "middle." Increasingly, you are either rich or poor. A have or a have not. Most HN readers are haves or (because you are still young) think you will be haves. But life doesn't always turn out according to plan.
- sebkomianos 13y agoI can't express how much I agree to this - but with a small addition: The "middle" is disappearing in Europe also. The most worrying thing is that if you put 95% of the people on a ship's back, it's going to sink; together with its front.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- moheeb 13y agoNot so with an iceberg, unfortunately.
- sirkneeland 13y agoAnd yet, the riots and looting sprees happen not in San Francisco, but in European countries like the UK, France, and Sweden. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Stockholm_riots http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Stockholm_riots Sweden. Not exactly a bastion of savage Randian individualism. Not to say that generous welfare states are of no value, but the available data suggest they are far from a panacea
- newnewnew 13y agoThat's an inconvenient fact for the standard liberal wisdom to explain. Here's links to information about the French riots: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_civil_unrest_in_France http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_civil_unrest_in_France and London riots/flash mobs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_England_riots http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_England_riots
- bitwize 13y agoHere's an inconvenient fact: Headline-making civil unrest in Europe is "Tuesday" in the American inner city. The European riots are only significant because they're unusual against such comparatively low levels of background violence.
- sirkneeland 13y agoThat's a gross exaggeration. Until you show me a number of burned out hulks of cars from a "Tuesday" in a US city, it's your stereotypes against my actual examples.
- Irishsteve 13y agoI'd imagine the police having guns in America are a great deterrent for rioters
- chrisdevereux 13y agoAlthough interestingly, both the London and Stockholm riots were caused by police shootings.
- dmix 13y agoIn Canada, similar gentrification is also happening rapidly in Toronto/Vancouver. Detroitification happened on the Canadian east coast (when the fishing industry died). And we have better "social safety nets". I don't think social programs manage to keep cities alive or the same as they were, nor would the overall country benefit from trying harder to do so. The main difference w/ Toronto vs SF is that Toronto has a liberal condo building policy so more affordable housing is being built by a (relatively) booming real estate industry. Whereas SF's property development growth has nowhere near reflected its population/income boom.
- vecinu 13y agoI can confirm this fact in Toronto. I can still see some seniors living in older neighbourhoods in Toronto but most of them have moved to the suburbs.
- ImprovedSilence 13y agoI could be wrong here, but I thought much of SF is considered "historic district" or something, therefore new, more dense housing is not being build, thus rents rise like crazy?
- muzz 13y agoYou indeed are wrong. Thousands of units of high density housing is being constructed currently.
- wutbrodo 13y agoI don't think he's wrong. All of the new development seems to be along Market (hell in a one mile stretch of Market near my house, there are THREE huge residential developments going up); i.e., you don't see any new high-rise developments going up in the Mission district (which I believe is designated "historic").
- alxp 13y agoAnd Atlantic Canadian cities are still great places to live because Canada has invested in social safety nets, sane urban development, and not abandoning entire cities. 'Detroitification' is a not-even-wrong way to describe how any population centre in Atlantic Canada has fared.