2 ms·
But what is "individual achievement" in a field like software development? In the sort of teams one typically finds in those 500+ person organisations, nothing
by Silhouette 18y ago
But what is "individual achievement" in a field like software development? In the sort of teams one typically finds in those 500+ person organisations, nothing is truly done by individuals.
Even if a genius developer produces a brilliant implementation of new feature quickly and with a low bug count, someone had the idea for that feature and worked out how it was going to integrate with other features, many people probably wrote a load of other code the feature depends on even if that code didn't itself create the same buzz, people were involved in testing the feature, producing the marketing, and on and on. While everyone might agree that the genius developer had done a good job for the team, how can you say quantitatively and objectively what his contribution was? 10%? 25%? 90%?
In contrast, the success of a project team is generally fairly easy to quantify: divide the cost of running the team by the amount of revenue generated by the projects they produce.
The sad reality is that while serious guru developers may indeed be an order of magnitude more productive than average, and some at the other end of the scale are actually counterproductive, salaries for employees will never realistically reflect this. The bottom-feeders always get more than they deserve, while the top guys will never get credit proportionate to their contribution. After all, this is why many of us get out and go freelance or start our own businesses.
But within that reality, I can't help wondering whether the guys at the top would still rather work with a motivated team than be individually slightly better compensated but surrounding by jealous, bitter colleagues.
- sokoloff 18y agoAnother alternative is to permit salary ranges that are a factor of 2 wide, meaning you can literally pay your "best" people (itself a terribly loaded/complex term) twice what you pay the average qualified employee at that level. Yes, paying someone 10% more than their peer isn't enough to recognize excellence. Paying them double probably is in many cases. Hell, even 50% over makes a marked difference in quality of life and is going to be both noticeable and relatively harder to match. In my past experience, even at employers where everyone to the last employee was totally qualified, there was general consensus about who the top, distinguished cohort was, and to the extent that people were jealous or bitter, it centered around the fact that those people were better, not around the fact that they got paid more. Even if nothing in a mid-sized company is truly done by individuals, I know the handful of employees that would really hurt to lose and the buckets full where we would be perhaps genuinely sad to see them go and wish them well in their next endeavor, but that I wouldn't lose much sleep over it. Survey 10 high-level managers, and the lists would line up pretty well I imagine. If that's the case in your org, and you aren't making damn sure that pay, within fairly BROAD bounds, isn't going to be a reason for the stars to walk, you're doing it wrong IMO.