5 ms·
Some good ideas here, but if I had to give advice to fledging writers I'd start with one rule: just say what you mean. English classes in the U.S. spend a lot
by smacktoward 13y ago
Some good ideas here, but if I had to give advice to fledging writers I'd start with one rule: just say what you mean.
English classes in the U.S. spend a lot of time teaching people how to write five-paragraph essays: one paragraph of introduction, three paragraphs of argument, one paragraph of conclusion. But outside the classroom the five-paragraph essay form is worse than useless: it's actively harmful.
For simple arguments, it's harmful because it forces the writer to jam words down the throat of their argument to plump it up so it fits the format. For complex arguments, it's harmful because it forces the writer to lop limbs off their argument to fit it into an arbitrary box. Most arguments are simple arguments, so the first sin is the greater one.
So much bad writing is bad because the writer couldn't just say what they mean and then stop. They stuff their argument with fluff like it's a damn pillow. An argument should be lean, cut, diamond-hard. Packing it with fluff just makes it soft and saggy. So skip all that -- just say what you mean, then stop.
- grey-area 13y agoSome good ideas here, but if I had to give advice to fledging writers I'd start with one rule: just way[sic] what you mean. Rule No.2 - always proofread before hitting send/post :) [EDIT Re your main point, now that the typo is out of the way] There are various ways of structuring an argument - as a dialogue, as thesis, antithesis then synthesis, or treating it as an oration like Cicero's with 6 parts ending in a peroration. All of them are imposing structure on thought (and thus restricting creativity), and none of them will perfectly fit any argument, but some structure is vastly preferable to no structure at all, which is a far more common problem. The problem most people have in their writing and speech is a lack of structure, and I think the school lessons you evoke are meant to counter that by imposing some (even at the risk of making essays boring and formulaic). I don't think the intention is to forevermore make everyone write in the same structure (which would be a procrustean bed as you mention), but more to show people that you can use structure, and employ it persuade and explain. Students are then expected to grow out of that structure later or explore other possible structures. Once you understand the mechanics of argument, you can then break them with great effect, but only if you do it sparingly, and it's best to know the rules in order to know when you're breaking them. A far more insidious problem nowadays in terms of imposed structure is the habit people have of making a list (as the OP does) as if this is a substitute for properly structuring their thoughts - to me that's a cop-out and not far above no structure at all. Usually the results are then labelled top n x or n things you didn't know about x and contain more than n examples of x, without any attempt at an introduction or a conclusion.
- mtinkerhess 13y ago"Just way what you mean" embodies its own spirit: get your point across, correctness be damned.
- knob 13y agoyour write [[apologies to original poster in /. years ago]]
- smacktoward 13y agoAgh, you're right -- fixed. I plead stupidity.
- smacktoward 13y ago> A far more insidious problem nowadays in terms of imposed structure is the habit people have of making a list (as the OP does) as if this is a substitute from properly structuring their thoughts - to me that's a cop-out and not far above no structure at all. Good point. I agree with it so much that a while back I made a Chrome extension just to dramatize it: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/buzzfeed-delisticator/egdbmlkndoidogdaeaimbkojoeopcgfc https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/buzzfeed-delistica... People don't realize how much Web content is plodding, soggy "listicles" these days until you make it visually obvious.
- antitrust 13y ago> the habit people have of making a list (as the OP does) as if this is a substitute for properly structuring their thoughts - to me that's a cop-out and not far above no structure at all. Speaking as a language professional: If there's no direct association between the parts, present them as a list. Otherwise, you're going to impose narrative structure that does not add meaning and thus is extraneous.
- noblethrasher 13y agoA far more insidious problem nowadays in terms of imposed structure is the habit people have of making a list (as the OP does) as if this is a substitute for properly structuring their thoughts - to me that's a cop-out and not far above no structure at all. Usually the results are then labelled top n x or n things you didn't know about x and contain more than n examples of x, without any attempt at an introduction or a conclusion. http://www.paulgraham.com/nthings.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nthings.html
- ripter 13y agoI like that you rant about the five-paragraph essays with a four-paragraph rant.
- smacktoward 13y agoI live to serve.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoGood work. The main problem here is that you only had two paragraphs of argument instead of three. You could have used that third paragraph to argue the benefits of a five paragraph structure, making your essay less of a polemic. Otherwise, your point was effectively argued, and I like how stop is your last word. 8/10.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoIronically, you have essentially structured your comment as a traditional essay: * First paragraph introduces the topic and states your thesis. * Second paragraph expands on the thesis. * Third paragraph makes arguments in support of the thesis. * Final paragraph summarizes the thesis. I agree completely that too many people think "writing" means "using fluffy language" but the structure of a persuasive essay is a non-fancy, workaday model that works just fine.
- antitrust 13y ago> the structure of a persuasive essay is a non-fancy, workaday model that works just fine. I agree with this, but would like to point out that grey-area's point was that there are other forms which fit other uses: > There are various ways of structuring an argument - as a dialogue, as thesis, antithesis then synthesis, or treating it as an oration like Cicero's with 6 parts ending in a peroration. The five-paragraph comp works very well for a standard argument. Anything that doesn't fit the thesis requirement, like a list or synthesis, might not do so well with that format.
- superuser2 13y agoA true school essay would list subtopics in the thesis, restate the subtopics in each topic and concluding sentence, and then restate the subtopics again in the conclusion. Parent is at least subtle and not so terribly redundant.
- jamesbritt 13y agoI'd start with one rule: just say what you mean. Exactly. Write however you like in order to get something down, but then go back and chop the cruft. Kill stuff like "due to the fact", "let me explain", and anything else that isn't providing either content or context.
- pjungwir 13y agoWhen I used to tutor friends in writing, I'd often read a convoluted, non-grammatical, "academic" sentence and ask, "What do you mean?" and, when they would give me a simple answer, I'd say, "Write that down!" Aiming for a writing style that sounds as clear as speech is a good practice for beginners, and if you can pull it off you're way ahead of most others. A great way to achieve this yourself is to take your first draft (or current paragraph, or whatever) and read it out loud. Don't fake it under your breath. Stand up, go somewhere private, and really read it out loud. If it sounds horrible, rewrite it. This "as clear as speech" goal is basically the style Strunk & White are training people for. Once you've mastered it, you can decide whether you want to go for more (e.g. Faulkner-like, Derrida-like, "casual," etc. Also check out the "spoken++" advocated by _Clear and Simple as the Truth_. You could even read Joyce's Ulysses for a parody of all kinds of writing styles.). But start with just making your writing communicate as well as your speech does.
- yareally 13y ago> English classes in the U.S. spend a lot of time teaching people how to write five-paragraph essays: one paragraph of introduction, three paragraphs of argument, one paragraph of conclusion. But outside the classroom the five-paragraph essay form is worse than useless: it's actively harmful. What also does not help is imposing limits (generally minimum pages) on students, so they feel they need to pad their papers with worthless content. Things like that become habits in normal writing after some amount of time. I did have some technical writing courses at my university that at least tried to emphasize saying what you mean as clear as possible without a lot of fluff, but only engineers and computer scientists were require to take them as far as I know.
- bobbles 13y agoOne of the things I do when writing emails (particularly important ones, or ones going to clients) is after I finish what I would normally write, go back through the whole email and remove as many words as possible. Things like 'we need to move forward and complete x' become 'we need to complete x'. (sloppy example) It's amazing how professional the emails look once you remove all the fluff, but it's something so many people dont do.