6 ms·
I wonder when the movie industry will have a pioneer along these same lines. It's an idea I've had for a while... produce movies on a moderate budget... with a
by TylerE 13y ago
I wonder when the movie industry will have a pioneer along these same lines.
It's an idea I've had for a while... produce movies on a moderate budget... with as many talented screenwriters as there are, there have to be good scripts that go unoptioned. Cast talented character and stage actors instead of big name (big $$) star talent, and quitely make a bunch of really good movies for not a ton of money (Think $15-20 million budgets).
The idea is to have a deep catalog that quitely does well, instead of trying for massive blockbusters that can be $200m losses if they bomb.
There are certainly some filmmakers that sort of take this approach (The Coen brothers, for instance), but I don't know of any studio that has taken the approach to heart. I'm not talking indie studios here, but full AAA productions, just not with big VFX budgets or $50 million cast members.
- danko 13y agoI think the issue here is with the marketing costs necessary to actually get people into theaters. It's so difficult to actually convince folks to get out of their homes for filmed entertainment that it generally takes a $50-$80 MM marketing budget for a film to do _any_ kind of business at the box office. This ruins the economics of the 'mid-sized' film, since if you have to tack on $60 MM of marketing onto the production budget anyway, even the smaller films generally have a high level of risk. Thus the whole market has bifurcated between enormous $200 MM behemoths and $2 MM indie movies with limited theatrical distribution trying to promote themselves virally.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoHow important is it to get into theatres? I'd imagine doing a deal with Netflix that says they have exclusivity for x months but it can still be shown in a limited number of theatres. The promotion Netflix would do (top of the page on netflix.com as well as the press it would generate) might offset the limited marketing budget you have available and get people who want the full experience to watch it in the theatre.
- MartinCron 13y agoIt's probably important to get it into theatres because there still exists a stigma that direct-to-video features are inferior to theatrical features.
- L_Rahman 13y agoIncreasingly however it seems that stigma is going away. In fact a number of indie distributors are currently experimenting with simultaneous theatrical + VOD + streaming services releases with a degree of success. As the average age of people who've come to assume streaming services like Netflix as the norm increases, I think we might a see a greater willingness to forego theatrical releases altogether.
- RandallBrown 13y agoThe Asylum sort of does this. They don't make good movies though, they mostly just make crappy ripoffs of blockbusters. It's a similar model though. Make lots of cheap movies and make money off of all of them.
- JoshGlazebrook 13y agoSharknado!
- DanBC 13y ago> I wonder when the movie industry will have a pioneer along these same lines. You talk as if noone is doing this. But you appear to be ignoring all the Euro cinema produced each year.
- bcgraham 13y agoThis used to be the Hollywood model. In the 1970s, for example, studios made movies like you describe. Over time, they've found it's more profitable to release fewer movies that are surer bets, which is how you get this endless parade of formula movies with $250m budgets.
- VLM 13y agoDon't confuse a local maxima with a global maxima. Or, the dead hand of the free market always wins, err... unless you have no free market. Or confuse narrowcasting with broadcasting. A good Hacker News car analogy would be 70s/80s Detroit iron vs Japanese imports. When its just onshore, long term trend for the local maxima was to ship junk. Then you get some competition and that doesn't work anymore... In the very long run, like the car analogy, the newcomers have to hurry up and cash in while they can, because the entrenched interests will eventually adapt.
- aamar 13y agoIt's not just that it was discovered to be more profitable in the abstract. Technology changes are a big factor too. Since TV achieved widespread penetration, movies have had to promise something new: either visual spectacle, something deemed unacceptable for broadcast, or something too serious/subtle/obscure. The combination of cable and HD TV have more or less eliminated the latter two categories. HD TV can adequately deliver pretty much any non-"spectacular" content. So audiences are, in general, not as likely to visit a theater for this, i.e. pay the cash required.
- TylerE 13y agoThink of what I'm proposing as the "Shawshank Redemption" model. Don't focus on box office sales, focus on the complete picture, and focus on compelling storytelling. Shawshank peaked at #9 at the box office, only making back about half it's budget. In the home video market, it has just exploded, selling over 5 million copies in the UK alone. (http://www.bva.org.uk/news-press-releases/members-press-releases/itv-global-entertainment-makes-history-shawshank-redempti http://www.bva.org.uk/news-press-releases/members-press-rele...). That's kind of mindblowing...about the same number of copies as Sgt Peppers has sold in the UK, and way more than any contemporary album - the closest comparison is probably Oasis's What's the Story? (Morning Glory) at 3.3m units sold.
- chiph 13y agoThat's the "Moneyball" approach. Hire people who can consistently get to first base. With that steady income, you can afford to try an occasional big budget production.
- vinceguidry 13y agoProducing movies involves a metric shit-ton of work. You need a LOT of really good people to do just one movie well. Doing a whole bunch? Quality will inevitably suffer due to lack of attention. It's not just acting talent. Pre- and post-production is ridiculously hard to do right, and will ruin all your hard work if it isn't. I have a friend who does it. Writes, directs, acts, produces. He works constantly, 12-14 hours a day. I feel bad for his new wife. Trust me, the movie craft cannot be scaled like this by solo players who aren't part of the establishment. Not with the current state of the art.
- cdcarter 13y agoExactly. Many people think that the cost of movie production is absurd. WHat could they possibly be spending $200m on?! Salaries.
- TylerE 13y agoThe thing is, if you're not doing some sort of incredibly bloated production, you don't need 10,000 people to make a movie. Most movies are NOT Lord of the Rings. For instance, one of the best critically received movies of the last decade was probably No Country For Old Men. Budget? $25 million. Made back well over triple that at the US box office alone. The King's Speech? $15 million, made over $135 million Argo? $44 million, and that had lots of expensive location shoots in the middle east The Hurt Locker? $15 million Slumdog Millionaire? $15 million Crash? $6.5 million Million Dollar Baby? $30 million All movies that did very well at the box office, and were made for $25 million or less (with one exception). They also all won the Best Picture oscar. So there is PLENTY of evidence that you can make a great movie without getting anywhere near a 9-figure price tag. Of course, for "indie" films, you can go well under that. "Clerks" cost about as much a new car. The original Texas Chainsaw Massacre was barely over $100k....the first Saw movie was made for just over $1m and grossed 100 times that.
- vinceguidry 13y agoYou said your approach was to "make a bunch of movies for not a lot of money." No one's arguing the "not a lot of money" part, what I'm saying is that you can't make a bunch. You can produce one really great movie every two years if you're amazing. That's it. It will take you twenty years to get to "a bunch". That's after ten years of learning how to make movies. It's that hard. This is my friend's website. He takes his craft very seriously and is a workaholic. No day job, this is all he does: http://www.villainpictures.com/work/index.html http://www.villainpictures.com/work/index.html Five finished, full-length projects in the last 12 years, two more in the pipe.
- Keyframe 13y agoThere are multiple problems with that approach though. Serious problems. with as many talented screenwriters as there are, there have to be good scripts that go unoptioned. Sure, but can you spot them? Are you capable of spotting a right script which would make a good profitable movie? Or do you know someone who can? Check out http://blcklst.com/ http://blcklst.com/ Cast talented character and stage actors instead of big name (big $$) star talent Stage acting and film acting are two different disciplines. Vastly different in technique and experience needed. Another point here is that 'big star' talent brings marketing power to the table as well, something you haven't touched upon on at all. Marketing is big part of the game. That's why usually in 'smaller' productions you get a lead or co-star 'big name' with rest of the cast relatively unknown. Not everyone unknown. Not to mention casting is a difficult job in itself. You may find an actor that suits role perfectly, but all of the cast has to function together on screen as well. Think $15-20 million budgets $20m range falls in small production range, so that checks out. Productions are not spending happy, remember that when you see those vertigo inducing budgets. They have thought through their spending well. The idea is to have a deep catalog that quitely does well, instead of trying for massive blockbusters that can be $200m losses if they bomb. Why not both? That's what studios do. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tent-pole_(entertainment) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tent-pole_(entertainment) Otherwise you'd better have deep pockets in order to churn out multiple films and 'hope' some of them will rake in cash. That's because most of the films on smaller budgets aren't profitable at all. It's a numbers game in your proposal then, more risky than tent pole approach. What you propose would be a YC for films, where budgets aren't $10k because they can't be for various reasons and production time isn't two months, but two years.