3 ms·
Simple really, government is to large and intrusive that there is little to no room for private industry to implement them. Items that are easily transportable,
by Shivetya 13y ago
Simple really, government is to large and intrusive that there is little to no room for private industry to implement them. Items that are easily transportable, or measured at the personal level, like phones, computers, and even cars, are still well within reach.
Some will point to Space X as violating that last line, but look at it from the perspective of that it really is only affected by one part of government. Large transportation projects like the hyperloop would require approval at so many levels and be subject to the whims of so many outside groups that it is insurmountable by private enterprise. Only government can build it because only government can ignore its own rules.
So its not a matter of that we can't think big, we can think big all we want. We just have to find frontiers where bureaucracy is not the primary obstacle.
- ForrestN 13y agoAs well as Rand would like this story, with its normative, visionary captain of industry, its worth remembering that this line of thinking is as bankrupt as it is naive. First of all, it would be utterly impossible for a purely private initiative to build the hyperloop as proposed. Most obviously, the unique feasibility argument here is that the government already owns highways that could bear the tube for most of the distance between SF and LA. But no serious rail line has ever or could ever be built without government help, because it would be impossible to negotiate the purchase of all the land without eminent domain. Pragmatics aside, this is also just a very facile way of looking at things that belies, I think, a certain amount of laziness. The government isn't perfect, and sometimes bureaucracy does hinder good projects, but really the challenge for hyperloop would be garnering public support. If the proposal becomes massively popular, the government will have a huge incentive to build it. Unfortunately it's easier to complain vaguely about the government than it is to convince weary tax payers to fund a massive project using unproven technology. I'd love to see hyperloop built, but I am not desperate for other services that would be provided with the same money (better schools, for example). Much of the reason American business thrived in the second half of the twentieth century is because of the superior infrastructure the government built. Every business in Y Combinator relies on services provided by the government and couldn't function nearly as well if Ron Paul were king. And, obviously, the government has achieved radically ambitious projects before. Have you ever been to Hoover Dam? Driven from coast to coast? Government isnt perfect and can be frustrating, but bureaucracy is almost never the primary obstacle. It's just a convenient excuse.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoThe solution to negotiating land purchase without eminent domain is to play "connect 4" by buying "options" - cheaper contracts that fix a price for a period of time but don't guarantee a sale. As soon as you have a connected path of options between A and B, you can exercise the options and run the line down it. You can spread the option purchases around a whole lot, so that nobody has an incentive to play awkward in return for more money, because you'd simply route around them.
- tootie 13y agoGovernment would be the slickest grease to get this problem solved quicklky as he direclty outlines in his plan. If you want to lay 1000 miles of track (or tube) through private land, you need to get about 50,000 signed up. His plan to put it alongside a highway means you only need one approval.