3 ms·
While not impossible, I think assuming people vote without reading is doing a disservice to HN readers. The ratio of hits on a story to upvotes is huge - from
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
While not impossible, I think assuming people vote without reading is doing a disservice to HN readers. The ratio of hits on a story to upvotes is huge - from purely anecdotal data (mine and others) a 20x ratio is common. Since the ratio is so high, it seems reasonable to assume that most if not all votes came from people who did actually click through. I have no data on the upvote to comment page ratio but I would guess it is even higher.
Of course subject matter, headline, other people's comments make a difference, but I doubt there is a significant blind upvoting of something that hits the front page.
I think it is however a good suggestion - simply an invisible reminder that we put content first. I like it.