2 ms·
But why make it a traditional train? Just build a lightweight train if it gets you all of the hyperloop's cost advantages without the additional costs and comp
by jessriedel 13y ago
But why make it a traditional train? Just build a lightweight train if it gets you all of the hyperloop's cost advantages without the additional costs and complexity of a tube?
- jim-greer 13y agoOn trains the cars have to be connected to each other. The structure has to bear the load of all of them at once. Not the case with hyperloop.
- jessriedel 13y agoIt's totally implausible that that's the primary factor.
- LockeWatts 13y agoWhy? You've given no explanation.
- jessriedel 13y agoNor has jim-greer.
- lmm 13y agoThe reason we have to run long, heavy trains is it's unsafe to run two passenger capsules at 300kph a minute apart. I find it hard to believe regulations will permit that even when they're in a tube.
- cmsmith 13y agoTraditional trains have wheels and engines, which are quite heavy. And with a traditional train you're trying to minimize losses due to air resistance, which is not an issue in a low pressure tunnel.
- dojomouse 13y agoAbove a certain speed wheels present huge issues, which means you need to change your drive mechanism and suspension mechanism. Also, drag is a huge killer of efficiency and hence overall economics. Even at 500kph the drag on a train at sea level is enormous. At 1000kph it's 4 times bigger again, and you've got the sound barrier to worry about. Trying to do the same with multiple small capacity trains is astronomically worse. So, better to have reduced drag... and by now you've basically got the hyperloop.